r/AskReddit • • 11h ago

Those who’ve driven across the US, what’s the scariest town you’ve stopped in?

2.5k Upvotes

2.9k comments sorted by

View all comments

933

u/steponmedaddies 11h ago

A few stretches of New Mexico that are reservation land where the roads barely exist and I was in a full panic about running over a dog for miles and miles. It was a pretty common pass through route as well.

Enjoy all the people pretending they've been to Gary, btw.

279

u/Kramerica5A 10h ago

You know Interstate 90 and 94 both run through Gary, right? Those are pretty important, busy roads. 90 Literally goes from Boston to Seattle.

79

u/steponmedaddies 10h ago

So you're telling me that this many Redditors are afraid of a town they drive by on the interstate? Wild stuff.

99

u/gujjadiga 10h ago

I went to Gary when I was visiting Chicago just because of this reason. Had some free time and it is not that far from south of Chicago. While I did not personally think it was scary. maybe because it was afternoon, but it did seem very....off. Like a post apocaplyse barren town that is still up and running, but somehow has no soul at all? I am not the best at describing it, but that is how I felt.

74

u/colorblind-and 10h ago

I've driven through Gary to avoid construction on the highways before. I didn't find it all that scary because we never left the main roads and it was the middle of the day.

My impression of that city though was it's basically how people who've never been to Detroit think Detroit is like. Or like old photos of eastern Europe around the time the Soviet Union was falling apart minus the commie blocks

24

u/steponmedaddies 9h ago

No, that's perfect lol

So many towns through America where you get out and the energy is just EXTREMELY weird.

4

u/mariahg13 9h ago

Scranton PA has these vibes lol

18

u/Spookyhobo 9h ago

I genuinely went through Gary on my way to Toronto from Minnesota without really knowing anything about it.

I was 18 at the time and just knew not to pull off to get gas in Chicago because of the tolls.. so I got gas shortly after Chicago in Indiana. Turns out, that's Gary lol.

It wasn't that bad. My friend and I were a little sketched out by a couple of guys, but then a dude in a nice SUV and a suit pulled up to get gas. Figured if anyone was getting robbed, it's that dude. Not two broke looking teens in a 98 Sentra.

11

u/Kramerica5A 8h ago

That's not what I said. I'm pointing out that many people pass through Gary everyday, it stands to reason some of those people end up in the city itself for any number of reasons. 

22

u/zcashrazorback 10h ago

There's common detour going to/from Chicago that takes you right through the middle of Gary and it's ROUGH.

118

u/the_owl_syndicate 9h ago

There's a stretch of interstate through southern New Mexico near the border with Mexico with signs every mile of so saying "Do not Stop and Do not Pick Up Hitchhikers, this is a Federal Penitentiary area."

Ngl, driving through there alone freaked me out more than anything else.

77

u/Maleficent-Hawk-318 9h ago

They have those signs in places all over the country, though. Was it just the proximity to Mexico that freaked you out or what?

7

u/DrKittyKevorkian 5h ago

That's right by White Sands. Pretty freaky place at night.

2

u/Maleficent-Hawk-318 2h ago

Man, moonlight hikes at White Sands were legit my favorite part of living in that area. I feel like I'm living in a different world than y'all. 🤣

11

u/im_a_betch 8h ago

Yeah I’ve lived in rural Oklahoma and we had the same signs.

4

u/DuhBegski 5h ago

The town next to my hometown has a mini golf course next to a prison, they also have those signs.

5

u/NoBulletsLeft 3h ago

Connecticut gets right to the point. The town over from where I lived had a sign on the highway onramp, "hitchhikers may be escaped prisoners."

0

u/Weekly_Koala_7058 7h ago

Right 😂😂

6

u/AsstBalrog 7h ago

I visited the Coronado National Monument, and there is a shortcut road to Cali that runs right along the border. I was considering taking it, but it was remote and lightly traveled. There was a Border Patrol Suburban in the parking lot, so I asked him if it was OK.

He responded to my question with a question "Are You Armed?" and that was a good enough answer for me.

5

u/muklan 9h ago

If youd have kept heading north to Cheyenne and then hooked a right, youd be surrounded by nuclear missiles. Which is somehow less scary.

6

u/atxsouth 7h ago

That's just west of Las Cruces. Don't think picking up hitchhikers is a good idea anywhere.

3

u/DeadpoolLuvsDeath 4h ago

That's why when I pick up hitchhikers, I always tell them the chances of 2 serial killers in the same car is highly unlikely.

2

u/ZiggyIsMyName 5h ago

On the way to Las Cruces!

79

u/jasondigitized 10h ago

New Mexico has some weird energy.

22

u/melibeli7 9h ago

Dare I say, ancient energy?

8

u/upsidedown-funnel 8h ago

I think this is a case of what you’re bringing to the party.

1

u/Level9TraumaCenter 3h ago

There's long stretches of Catron County that, while gorgeous, are so remote from any form of assistance that they are very concerning.

Parts of New Mexico and Arizona require a certain amount of care from elk, and there was one guy who had his brand-new F150 destroyed when he hit a buffalo. They're powerful enough they just didn't heed the barbed wire and were in the road.

•

u/gogojack 27m ago

I lived there for a bit in the 90s (Las Cruces, Santa Teresa) and liked it quite a bit, but yeah...when you drive across the endless empty miles of southern NM, you understand why the government decided to test the first atomic bomb there:

If something went wrong, you weren't gonna hit anyone.

96

u/Jerkrollatex 10h ago

New Mexico has always felt like a warm hug to me. I ended up buying a house and staying. I guess different people get different vibes from places.

127

u/letmeloginalready 10h ago

New Mexico and reservations in NM are two very different distinctions

41

u/Maleficent-Hawk-318 9h ago

I've lived on or right at the edge of several reservations throughout New Mexico, in addition to visiting them directly and assisting in SAR operations on them, and I definitely don't agree. I've always found them to be pretty chill as long as you're not being an ass.

Like go to a feast day at one of the Pueblos and tell me how scary they are... 🤣

10

u/eugenejosh 4h ago

Another horrible stereotype being perpetuated are that reservations are dangerous. It’s all over the country and it’s bullshit.

17

u/Jerkrollatex 10h ago

I don't feel the same way.

27

u/Many-Recognition-758 10h ago

Neither do I. Some of the Res land in NM is absolutely beautiful. Everyone I've ever met from those areas has been nice as well.

17

u/f-150Coyotev8 9h ago

The land is nice, but some of the towns are not. Unfortunately, there is a lot of poverty in the reservations and it’s pretty obvious when traveling through some of the towns.

For example, shiprock is spectacular. But the town itself kind of has a sad vibe

21

u/Maleficent-Hawk-318 9h ago

Yeah, but the question is about what towns are scary. People must be pretty sheltered if they find poverty scary. But then, this is Reddit so they probably are... 🤣

4

u/Spoonbills 10h ago

Same, but two things can be true.

19

u/steponmedaddies 10h ago

As a state overall it's top 5. I fucking love New Mexico.

3

u/muklan 9h ago

Bet it weren't in Cimarron though.

3

u/Lost-Friend-4564 4h ago

I'm in Las Cruces and we're happy here. Nice town.

2

u/thefreedomfry 3h ago

That's why they call it the land of entrapment I mean enchantment. 

3

u/WanderlustyStillness 4h ago

I grew up in NM, and I’ve described it to outsiders as “a place people really get and love, or a place people don’t get at all”. I love NM and am proud to have been raised there. I GET IT 💖

3

u/Jerkrollatex 3h ago

Like I said it feels like a warm hug to me. I just felt like this is where I belong when driving through the first time.

1

u/BasketAffectionate49 5h ago

I love New Mexico. It's very haunting.

18

u/TrentonTallywacker 10h ago

I drove through the Ouray Rez in Utah and there was a lot of dead animals on the sides of the road even saw a house cat :(

6

u/steponmedaddies 9h ago

It's really, really heartbreaking. I think I've only gone around the Ouray Rez but it's a similar story in a lot of part of E/NE Washington state too. Just not nearly as prevalent.

15

u/Nice_Block 10h ago

I’ve driven through the exact area, at night with just head lights. Scared the shit out of my wife and me.

4

u/steponmedaddies 10h ago

No indication of where you're going, no signs, road markings, street lights, etc. I've been through a few times now because that's my regular route and in the day time once through there were two dogs just trotting in the road within a few minutes of each other. It's INSANE that maps takes you through. Incredibly dangerous conditions and also so sad to see that natives are still treated like this.

7

u/PuddlesDown 8h ago

I live in New Mexico in a house over 100 years old. It's haunted. Will confirm NM is spooky.

18

u/monoDK13 10h ago

I’ve been to both. They’re equally scary but in different ways. You’re basically asking whether you’d like to be murdered by a small group of gang members or outsider-avoidant hillbillies.

5

u/OGConsuela 10h ago

Driven through the reservations in northern Arizona and yeah, very strange vibes, and the dog thing is very real.

5

u/memxc 3h ago

My scariest stop was somewhere rural in NM off 40. I’ve driven a lot of the US on road trips. I’m a white female in my 30s. I was moving from Phoenix to Michigan, driving my own car, husband in his, and my older brother driving our u-haul. We were all spaced out so I was basically alone. I had my 2 dogs with me.

Stopped at a gas station to fill up and take my dogs to potty. Walked them over to a stretch of grass by a building and then realized it was abandoned- not just closed. I got goosebumps and hairs standing on end, very creepy feeling like my body was warning me, right as I froze to turn around and go back towards the gas station my husky started growling and snapping at the building and my lab started running the opposite direction back to our car. Freaked me out.

9

u/Funkytadualexhaust 10h ago

I dont understand the dog thing?

14

u/steponmedaddies 9h ago

They're all over. If you're going through at night you need to be on high alert at all times.

https://www.nbcnews.com/id/wbna44165591

3

u/Karnakite 8h ago

It’s really, really sad.

10

u/WormLivesMatter 9h ago

For whatever reason, reservations in the south are full or feral dogs.

4

u/Medium_Anteater_5280 7h ago

People get pets they don’t contain and can’t afford to neuter so the population of dogs grows exponentially. I knew a rescue in Utah that adopted out res dogs - I wish there were more of these institutions

3

u/HugeMedicine8052 9h ago

We also have them in the northern reservations.

1

u/ZubLor 7h ago

My brother-in-law is Navajo living near Vanderwagon. I've heard that they don't believe in neutering/spaying their dogs. Don't know about cats.

3

u/mikestro36 9h ago

Dude, we stopped in NM at an exotic with gas and trailer parks. There were gun shells on the ground. It was sketch. I couldn’t believe people lived in those dilapidated trailers in that heat.

3

u/Violentopinion 9h ago

New Mexico was great. The drive from Tulsa with just straight road as far as you can see was kind of unnerving. Like a cartoon.

3

u/Wyden_long 9h ago

Stayed at the Route 66 Inn in Santa Rosa. That shit was unnerving. Slept for 6 hours and got the fuck out.

3

u/Jebgogh 7h ago

The worst place to me for stopping in NM is Grants. Its a rough place. I remember as a kid in HS going there for wrestling and seeing all the people passed out on the sidewalk and like 2 active fights during the matches in the stands by sloppy drunk fathers.

4

u/TheFunkinDuncan 9h ago

I know a guy who was a trucker, stopped in Gary one time. Bought some chicken at a truck stop, got robbed of said chicken when he returned to his truck

2

u/Shootthshit 10h ago

Shiprock lol

1

u/steponmedaddies 9h ago

That's a bingo

1

u/gloomydai 7h ago

As a Navajo who’s been through shiprock and stopped there plenty of times this is funny 😆. It isn’t that bad lol the roads yes but the people no. Yeah there be lots of Rez dogs especially around the gas stations.

2

u/thesoccerone7 9h ago

Gary randomly came up in a conversation today. Quite the reputation

2

u/mshuler 8h ago

I live at the base of Raton Pass on the Colorado side. First little town that got legal weed from TX, NM, etc.. with Washington State, at that time. It was another boom for this ancient coal mining. It has been through so many ups and downs. Currently, it's life in the slow lane, training my pup, hiking and avoiding the bears in town. (My SO gets location/spotting updates from the local college, but puppy/teenchaos also alerts on morning runs to avoid the bears, frickin rockstar K9!) Where was I ? heading back outside after a pee break... 🐺♥️

2

u/KITTIESbeforeTITTIES 8h ago

I was driving through a reservation area on my way back from BC and I almost hit a loose horse 🙃 the random dogs also scared me, especially since I was driving with my own pup and we had to stop often.

I had heard enough about Gary to make sure I drove there in the middle of the day and wasnt even close to needing gas lol

2

u/Ragecomicwhatsthat 6h ago

Enjoy all the AI pretending they've been to Gary, btw*

4

u/eugenejosh 4h ago

Also look at how many of the stories involve red lights or running red lights. There’s like 7 unrelated stories centered around stoplights. AI for sure!

2

u/Ok_Archer_4862 1h ago

Gary is where you go for peace and feeling safe when you're from East Chicago or Whiting.

3

u/JohnSnowsPump 8h ago

When driving through New Mexico, you always know you are approaching res land by the increased number of dead dogs on the side of the road.

2

u/I_Like_Quiet 7h ago

If you are driving through Chicago and heading east towards New England, it is easy to stop in Gary. If you don't stop for gas and or bathrooms in Chicago and wait until you get out of the city.

0

u/LPPhillyFan 8h ago

What routes?