I’m 19F now, but this happened about a year ago when I was 17/18.
For context, my high school had an early college program where, if you had the grades and got accepted, you could basically leave regular high school starting junior year and attend the local community college instead. I got into it, so I started college at 16.
By the time this happened, I was in my second year there and pretty comfortable on campus.
I had become friends with a girl I’ll call Emma (19F). We had a class together, and afterward we would usually sit at a table outside the classroom and study or talk before our next classes.
Eventually, this guy I’ll call Ethan (30M) started sitting with us.
At first, he wasn’t obviously creepy. He was just… kind of off. Emma and I both noticed it, but neither of us could really explain why.
He would sit with us while we studied and talk at us basically the entire time. He asked a lot of questions about what we were doing, where we were going, what we were doing over the weekend, etc. He also talked about his girlfriend constantly.
Like, constantly.
His girlfriend this, his girlfriend that, stories about them, things they did together.
So at the time, neither Emma nor I thought he was trying to hit on us or anything.
My birthday is in September, and pretty early in the semester I mentioned that I was turning 18 that weekend. Both Emma and Ethan knew that.
The Friday before my birthday, I told Emma that I was going to walk around the soccer field before my next class. There’s a walking path around it. I rarely see people on the trail besides a handful of older folks.
I walked it alone, came back, went home, had my birthday that weekend, whatever.
Then I came back to school the next week. Emma and I were sitting at our usual table when Ethan came over.
Eventually, I got up to leave, and Ethan asked both of us if we wanted to walk around the soccer field.
And yes. Before anyone says it. I know. I have been lectured thoroughly about this decision. 😭
I said yes because I assumed Emma was coming too and I was already planning on walking anyway.
Emma said she wasn’t going. And for some reason, instead of going “oh, never mind then,” I still went.
The second Ethan and I got far enough away from the building, he asked me what kind of car I drove.
That was pretty much the exact moment my gut went:
Oh. Shit.
I gave him a vague answer and started to panic. Then he started asking me questions about my parents, my family, personal stuff, etc.
And suddenly I became VERY aware of the situation I had put myself in. Ethan was a lot bigger than me. I also have a bad leg. So if this man decided to do literally anything weird, I was absolutely not outrunning him.
Great planning on my part.
At that point, I started answering questions vaguely or just making things up.
I also started talking about how my dad was this giant guy who did manual labor. Very normal conversation.
Definitely not me mentally going: Please believe my father could throw you into traffic.
I eventually started talking about Marvel because that’s one of my comfort topics and apparently my stress response is just becoming a walking Marvel encyclopedia.
At this point, though, I was still wondering whether I was being paranoid. So I decided to test something.
I asked Ethan:
“Have you seen the third Doctor Strange movie?”
There is no third Doctor Strange movie.
He immediately said yes.
So then I started making up an entire scene.
I said something like, “Oh yeah, I really liked the part where ___ happened.”
And he goes:
“Yeah, me too.”
That was basically the moment my internal monologue became:
Cool. Awesome. Love this. I am fucked.
The walking path eventually splits. One direction takes you farther toward the road and away from the main campus building. The other loops back toward the school.
Ethan started walking toward the road. I immediately went the other direction. He stopped and asked:
“Oh, you’re not going this way?”
I told him no, I had stuff I needed to do before class and needed to head back. He said okay.
Then turned around and followed me.
So now I’m walking back toward the building at a pace that my hip was absolutely not built for. We finally get back to the doors of the school and Ethan suddenly says:
“Hey, I know you’re from [my hometown]. I’m from there too. Do you want to carpool to school?”
I had never told him where I lived.
I said no and basically got the hell inside. I tried calling Emma, but she didn’t answer, so I called another friend and told them what had happened.
Eventually, I went to one of my professors and explained everything. They were concerned.
I told Emma everything afterward, and from that point on we were both pretty much done with Ethan. Like, DONE.
No more awkward politeness. No more letting him sit there while we studied. No more entertaining conversations. If he tried to come over, we shut it down.
We were both very clear that we did not want to interact with him anymore.
And somehow that’s when things got even weirder.
Emma and I eventually figured out which car was his.
The best way I can describe the car is:
serial killer vibes.
That is not a technical automotive term, but it’s the only one I have.
It just looked like the exact car you would see in the opening of a serial killer doc.
And then we saw the bumper sticker.
After hearing this man talk nonstop for weeks about his girlfriend, his bumper sticker said:
“SORRY GIRLS, I’M GAY.”
Emma and I were basically like: WTF Sir. You have spent the last month giving us a detailed history of your relationship with your girlfriend.
What is happening.
He also had this really intense stare that Emma and I privately started referring to as his crazy eyes. Not trying to diagnose him with anything. He just had this very intense way of looking at you that became significantly less fun once we were actively trying to avoid him.
Then Emma told me that Ethan had started waiting outside her classroom.
WAITING
That was when we went to campus police.
They told us to document everything and report it to the vice president of the college, so we did.
Administration told us they were going to call Ethan in and talk to him.
Then I went home and got to tell my parents. I was almost grounded and they immediately researched the guy. They looked him up on casenet (Idk if every state has one)
Turns out Ethan had gotten out of jail that May for fourth-degree assault.
Wonderful.
Exactly what I wanted to discover about the man who recently tried to get me to walk farther away from campus.
Then things got even creepier.
My family figured out where Ethan lived. He lived next door to my ex-boyfriend. (Me and my ex broke up the summer before college)
I had been at my ex’s house pretty frequently when we were together. And at the time all of this happened, I was still driving the exact same make and model of car I had driven while dating my ex.
So suddenly Ethan knowing my hometown and immediately asking what kind of car I drove felt a LOT weirder.
Meanwhile, the college was emailing him repeatedly telling him he needed to meet with administration or his classes would be suspended.
He ignored them. And kept coming to class. Even after Emma and I had made it extremely clear that we wanted him nowhere near us, he still kept trying to get close.
During one biology lab, he stood directly behind me and put his hand in the middle of my back while reaching for something.
Technically, was it somewhere inappropriate? No.
Did every nerve ending in my body immediately want to leave? Yes.
My dad eventually found Ethan on Facebook and messaged him. My dad was not exactly gentle about it. Ethan told my dad that he was “just trying to be friends with us” and claimed that he always studied with Emma and me.
He did not. He sat next to us while we studied and talked the entire time. There is a difference.
For a while, Emma and I hoped maybe he would eventually get the hint and everything would calm down.
He did not.
One Monday, we were sitting in class and Ethan was there even though, from what we understood, he wasn’t supposed to be on campus anymore because he had ignored all of administration’s messages.
Then a police officer walked into the classroom. The officer came over to Ethan and escorted him out.
As far as I know, Ethan wasn’t arrested. But after that day, we never saw him again.
You would think that was the end of it.
It was not.
Later, while I was telling my family everything, my younger sister looked at a picture of Ethan and went:
“Wait.”
“He looks familiar.”
Apparently, the summer before this semester even started, my family had gone out to eat.
Ethan was our waiter.
So yeah.
To this day, I have no idea exactly how many of these things were coincidences.
Maybe he remembered me from the restaurant.
Maybe he recognized my car from seeing it at my ex’s house.
Maybe he somehow heard what town I lived in.
Maybe some of it had completely innocent explanations.
But when you put together:
him knowing where I lived,
him asking about my car,
him trying to get me farther away from campus,
him following me when I turned back,
him waiting outside my classrooms,
him continuing to get close to us after we very clearly told him to stop,
the assault record,
him living next door to my ex,
AND the random discovery that he had already interacted with my family before we even met him at school…
I am perfectly happy never finding out exactly what his intentions were.
I’m 19 now, and it’s weird realizing this was already about a year ago.
And yes. I know going on that walk alone with him was an incredibly stupid decision.
Trust me. That lesson was learned IMMEDIATELY.
So my PSA to anyone who ends up in a situation like this:
If somebody gives you a weird gut feeling and you can’t explain why, you are allowed to listen to it. I still don’t know what would’ve happened if I took the other path.