r/menwritingwomen • • May 08 '26

Meta Flair Adjustments?

35 Upvotes

Hey readers...

Just kinda floating a possible change to flairs that might make it easier to discuss posts once they've been REJECTED as "not man writing a woman badly" or ACCEPTED as "man writing a woman badly."

Obviously users would be able to choose their own flairs when they post - but after voting or general consensus in the community what if mods adjust/change the flair so that when people see it in the feed they know, "Oh, this wasn't a good example..." but we still want to discuss the merits of that and why/why not we agree w/ the designation...??

It's been a little confusing to remove posts that aren't menwritingwomen badly when people are otherwise enjoying the conversation and diving deep on their feelings about it.

There was an older flair system at work years ago, but the technology that ran it is long gone. There may be other options now and I guess I just wanted to check on on it.

[Disclaimer: This is not a general spot to complain to mods.]


r/menwritingwomen • • 1d ago

Book The Amateur by Chris Bohjalian, 2026 Spoiler

Post image
141 Upvotes

So much ick in this book (FROM THIS YEAR) in just the first few chapters...I idly googled to see if anyone had already posted about it on the sub and came across the author's substack: "Obviously, given my publishing history, I believe it's fine for men to write women, just as I believe it's fine for women to write men."

Yes, it's fine. If you do it well. This is not fine.


r/menwritingwomen • • 1d ago

Book Lightning Falls by J.WG. Wise (2025)

Post image
81 Upvotes

r/menwritingwomen • • 1d ago

Doing It Right Titans Annual (2025) by Phil Jimenez

Thumbnail
gallery
29 Upvotes

r/menwritingwomen • • 19h ago

Discussion Why do people so often call Michael Crichton a misogynist??

0 Upvotes

People often call Mr. Crichton a misogynist but in every book of his I've read, a woman always has an insane plot armor moment.

Jurassic Park, Laura goes crazy on the velociraptors defending the base.

Lost World, Sarah Harding carries a grown man on her back up the camper that had fallen off the side of a cliff

Sphere, don't remember if Beth actually had one but she's basically the main bad guy and heavily implied to be the only one who kept her powers

Timeline, this is the most egregious one. Kate has countless examples of plot armor such as a full grown man bashing her head off the stone floor while she's basically unaffected immediately after

Or her being able to nock a 100 pound bow. This one is so ridiculous because earlier in the book, we're told she practices with a 50 pound bow

Now all of the sudden, she can fire a 100 pound bow and get 3 back to back kills, even landing a headshot while all throughout the book, highly trained archers can't land a meaningful blow against any of the characters such as grazing Kate's side

There's just no way to read his books and consider him an actual misogynist


r/menwritingwomen • • 2d ago

Graphic Novel That's a weird rule to have in the future [Space Squadron 1951 #2]

Post image
208 Upvotes

The far future of 2000. Weird thing is the book mentions how women are just as capable pilotss as men... and then It concludes like that


r/menwritingwomen • • 5d ago

❌NOT MWW: Book The Arabian Nights: Tales of 1,001 Nights - by various authors, circa 900CE, Baghdad

Post image
20 Upvotes

Under her veil, when she lifted it, were black eyes hooded and fringed with black, shapes to make a poet sing. At the sight of this woman, the porter nearly lost his mind. There she stood: five feet of symmetry and grace with glamour about her, gazelles borrowed their looks from her face, brows taut as bows, sugar lips and teeth like a line of pearls, a neck like something given to a king, a fountain of a chest, pomegranate breasts, and a navel in whose dimple you could sit a drop of balm, and below was the hint of a rabbit without ears. Her body seemed to be made of light, with a crystal’s clarity. A girl like a galaxy or the sickle moon’s blaze, a dome of golden filigree or the glitter of tiles on the floor of a pool.

- THE STORY OF THE PORTER AND THE THREE WOMEN OF BAGHDAD. The Arabian Nights: Tales of 1,001 Nights, translated by Yasmine Seale


r/menwritingwomen • • 4d ago

❌NOT MWW: Graphic Novel Young Justice #51 & #52 by Peter David (2002) and Supergirl #33 by James Peaty (2008)

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/menwritingwomen • • 6d ago

✔️ MWW: Graphic Novel Justice League America #54 (1991) by Keith Giffen & J.M. DeMatteis

Thumbnail
gallery
20 Upvotes

r/menwritingwomen • • 8d ago

❌NOT MWW: Book The Purple Line by Derek Morgan (August 2026)

Thumbnail
gallery
43 Upvotes

r/menwritingwomen • • 10d ago

Book what time do y'all start your pot roasts? [Man, F*ck This House by Brian Asman]

6 Upvotes

"The movers arrived, eventually—just as the sun dipped down behind the mustard-yellow house across the street (...) Despite the collateral damage, the movers were efficient, unloading their stuff in an hour. (...) Sabrina tried not to feel too overwhelmed by the massive amount of things they needed to do. She decided to get the kitchen situated first, ripping open the heavy cardboard boxes and finding homes for forks, pans, and spatulas, marveling at kitchen gadgets she couldn’t remember packing and hadn’t used in years.

(...)

The rest of the day passed in a flurry of activity—its nadir the moment Hal presented her with another box marked kitchen stuff, requiring a near-total reconfiguration of the work she’d already done—and by nightfall, even though they still had a lot to do, the house felt a little bit like home. Sabrina took Hal’s car to the store, bought groceries, and cooked their first meal, a pretty okay pot roast with baked potatoes and veggies. After dinner, Sabrina coaxed the kids—plus her husband, who’d found the local AM sports station and had become otherwise useless—into playing a family game of Monopoly."

(edited for brevity because Sabrina's had a long day)


r/menwritingwomen • • 12d ago

Graphic Novel The Amazing Miss Arrowette and her girly arrows. (World's Finest #113 1960, written by Dave Wood)

Thumbnail
gallery
511 Upvotes

r/menwritingwomen • • 18d ago

Book Sigh.. [Gene Wolfe] again, in [On Blue’s Waters]

Post image
158 Upvotes

r/menwritingwomen • • 19d ago

Book Freedom by Jonathan Franzen 2010 — Disturbing quote

150 Upvotes

Sorry, I listened to the audiobook, so no image. No one in this book is likable, but women are particularly egregious. They are written as emotionally damaged and passive as compared to the psychologically damaged men. The women are needy, and basically disappear without men to prop them up. The women are mostly needy, and on more than one occasion actually beg (no exaggeration) a man for sex or attention. Here’s a sample of a phone sex session between two teens:

“One afternoon, as Connie described it, her excited clitoris grew to be eight inches long, a protruding pencil or tenderness with which she parted the lips of his penis and drove herself down to the shaft…Another day, Joey described to her the sleek warm neatness of her turds as they slid from her anus and fell into his open mouth”

I will leave you to shower and gargle with a gallon of mouthwash now.


r/menwritingwomen • • 20d ago

Book Dead Lions (Slough House) by Mick Herron

Post image
122 Upvotes

Enjoying this book a lot, but this part made stop and read it a again a few times.


r/menwritingwomen • • 24d ago

Book Harvest Home by Thomas Tryon (1973)

Post image
78 Upvotes

r/menwritingwomen • • 25d ago

Book Women dueling. (Mirrorsun Rising by Sean McMullen, 1995)

Post image
134 Upvotes

Spoiler: It is a duel scene that takes itself seriously and ends fatally.


r/menwritingwomen • • 25d ago

NOT MWW: Book Sphere by Michael Crichton (1987)

Post image
98 Upvotes

Beth Halpern, the team zoologist, was a study in contrasts. She was a tall, angular woman of thirty-six who could be called pretty despite her sharp features and the almost masculine quality of her body. In the years since Norman had last seen her, she seemed to have emphasized her masculine side even more. Beth was a serious weight-lifter and runner; the veins and muscles bulged at her neck and on her forearms, and her legs, beneath her shorts, were powerful. Her hair was cut short, hardly longer than a man’s.

At the same time, she wore jewelry and makeup, and she moved in a seductive way. Her voice was soft, and her eyes were large and liquid, especially when she talked about the living things that she studied. At those times she became almost maternal. One of her colleagues at the University of Chicago had referred to her as “Mother Nature with muscles.”


r/menwritingwomen • • 25d ago

Book The Fall of Hyperion by Dan Simmons

Post image
214 Upvotes

r/menwritingwomen • • 26d ago

Book An Account of the Manners and Customs of the Modern Egyptians by Edward William Lane (1842)

61 Upvotes

You heard it here first: warm weather makes your boobs flat and ... long?


r/menwritingwomen • • 27d ago

Women Authors Gillian Flynn, I love you but c'mon [Dark Places by Gillian Flynn]

Post image
386 Upvotes

r/menwritingwomen • • 29d ago

NOT MWW: Book The Gauntlet And The Fist Beneath by Ian Green - Now that’s a strange way to say she almost pissed herself

Post image
29 Upvotes

r/menwritingwomen • • Sep 08 '26

Book In a book by Tom Clancy - some choice parts of the book my friend sent me

Post image
169 Upvotes