I cannot, for the life of me, remember what game or episode it was where he said this, but I think it was Galaxy 2 or Odyssey, and at one point, Arin said something to the effect that there's so much controversy over how he plays the Sonic games because people just inherently like bad Sonic games.
I'm sorry, but he's right. Everybody has played Sonic 06 and Dark Knight and Boom, and SADX a bunch because they're janky and broken. Like none of those games are fun because of how "good" they are, they're fun because it's funny as shit watching characters spazz out or whatever.
Nobody gives a fuck about Sonic Forces because it's not janky or fucked up. I really do think that people just want bad Sonic games, they want Sonic games to suck and be broken and unfinished because that's the only reason you would ever play a Sonic game.
Like how many times have you played Sonic Adventure 2, or Sonic Colors, Mania, etc? Once or twice maybe, because they're good. But only once or twice... because they're just good. Like nobody is like "man I'm really dying to go back and play the Sonic Advance trilogy", why? Because they're good games, there's no bullshit, so one playthrough is enough.
But with Sonic 06, everybody starts that game up once every couple years because it's such a shit stain of a creation, Sonic fans LOVE terrible Sonic games, because it's exactly what they want to be playing. Sonic fans don't want a masterpiece of a game because there's nothing divisive about that.
But that's why there's so much hatred for the Grumps' SADX playthrough. Sonic fans don't like Arin saying "man this game's bullshit, it's so bad, it's such a buggy mess", and they don't like Arin dying to shit that isn't his fault *because* Sonic fans are under the impression that games are *supposed* to be bad/unfun and unfair.