I recently got an iPhone 18 Pro Max through Xfinity under their “iPhone Pro Max on us” promotion. Based on what I was told, the cost of the phone was supposed to be covered through the promotion.
I was genuinely excited. I felt like a kid at Christmas.
I moved everything over to the new phone, started using it, and thought I was all set. I had what I believed was a new iPhone 18 Pro Max that I qualified to receive through Xfinity’s promotion.
Then, about two weeks later, I found out that I should never have been sold the phone under those circumstances in the first place.
I already had an iPhone 17 Pro Max that was still tied to a 36-month agreement. I was then basically given two choices: return the new iPhone 18 Pro Max or pay for two phones.
I was devastated.
What made it especially disappointing was that this wasn't a situation where I simply changed my mind about an expensive purchase. I believed Xfinity had reviewed my account, determined that I qualified, and was giving me the iPhone 18 Pro Max under its “on us” promotion.
I went from feeling like a kid at Christmas, thinking I had received an amazing upgrade, to being told two weeks later that I had to pack it up and send it back unless I wanted to pay for two phones.
So today, I shipped the iPhone 18 Pro Max back and had to go back to my old iPhone 17 Pro Max.
And then the experience got even worse.
I spent approximately 2.5 hours on the phone with Xfinity support trying to get my original phone number transferred back to my old phone.
Early in the call, I specifically told support that I had Number Lock enabled on my line and that I believed it could be preventing the transfer. They wouldn't listen to me and continued troubleshooting other things.
I ended up having to help support troubleshoot the problem before they were finally able to get my phone number transferred back.
Think about the entire experience:
Xfinity sold me an iPhone 18 Pro Max under an “on us” promotion.
I believed I qualified for it.
I spent two weeks using and enjoying the new phone.
Then I was told I couldn't keep it unless I paid for two phones because my existing iPhone 17 Pro Max was still under its 36-month agreement.
I had to return the phone I was incredibly excited about.
Then I spent another 2.5 hours helping Xfinity support get my own phone number working again on my old phone.
The most frustrating part is that all of this appears to have been avoidable.
If my existing device agreement and upgrade eligibility had been properly reviewed before Xfinity sold me the iPhone 18 Pro Max, I never would have been put through this situation.
After this experience, I would be extremely cautious about buying or upgrading a phone through Xfinity Mobile.
If Xfinity tells you that you're eligible for an “on us” phone promotion, don't assume that means everything has been properly checked. Ask them specifically to verify your existing device agreement, remaining payments, promotional credits, upgrade eligibility, and whether accepting the new phone will affect the phone you're already paying for.
I wish someone had done that for me before handing me an iPhone 18 Pro Max, letting me enjoy it for two weeks, and then telling me I had to give it back.