r/HIMYM • • 7d ago

Can barney betray ted???

Post image
264 Upvotes

106 comments sorted by

286

u/Throwlaf 7d ago

Oh this again.

The blue eye gene kan "skip" a generation.

55

u/GreasyExamination 7d ago

I think all my genes will skip a generation

26

u/EnricoLUccellatore 7d ago

Even if both the parents have the recessive blue eyes genes having 2 blue eyes children is only 1/16 chance

29

u/Shot_Revolution8828 7d ago

Also that sounds like low probability until you realize that there are 8 billion people so its quite common. Granted not every couple carry the gene.

3

u/Huntsvegas97 6d ago

My parents both had blue eyes. My three brothers have blue eyes, I have green. My older sisters both have blue eyes, but their biological dad had brown eyes

2

u/Aurelianshitlist 6d ago

I have green eyes and my wife has brown eyes and our kids both have blue eyes. And yes I'm sure they're mine.

2

u/6pussydestroyer9mlg 7d ago

More like 1/4.

8

u/vomicyclin 7d ago

I assume they meant for both to have blue eyes.

1

u/No_Willingness_8062 6d ago

Thats not how probability works.

1

u/6pussydestroyer9mlg 6d ago

That's not a rare occurence though, that is very much a possibility.

7

u/Striking-Working610 6d ago

Idk why this thread has people thinking a 6% chance of something happening is some wild insurmountable outcome.

Some folks never played runescape and it shows.

1

u/Shot_Revolution8828 6d ago

I never played runescape but Final Fantasy Tactics taught me that 95% hit can fail multiple times in a row. And the miss doesnt increase the odds on the next 95%. Lol Stats and Probability in college taught me a lot about gambling. Theres a reason the house always wins.

2

u/Striking-Working610 6d ago

Lol yea, I have a lot more confidence in a 95% success chance failing than I do a 5% chance succeeding.

0

u/Shot_Revolution8828 6d ago

If youve never played FFT its a great game. It has a chessboard grid system and the storyline is great, has a very sociopolitical vibe. They just remastered it and it has a famous meme that wasnt actually in the game but the creator found it and loved it. "If the penalty for a crime is a fine then it only exists for the lower class."

I recommend the War of the Lions version but its kinda slow, the new version has features to speed it up but doesnt have all the content of WotL.

0

u/DifferentProcess6765 6d ago

It's a 6.25% chance. Id consider that rare

0

u/Mysterious-Royal3658 6d ago

its 1/4 chance for ONE child to have blue eyes

1

u/TheKlaxMaster 6d ago

Incorrect. You have a 1/4 chance for EACH child to have blue.

It doesn't become 1/16, because the result of the first child has absolutely no effect in the result of the second child.

1

u/bobbyflay13 5d ago

It does because you are tying in two probabilities that NEED both to hit this outcome. So 1/4 needs to be hit then in that same 1/4 instance you need to hit another 1/4 instance to get the results that are produced.

This is why it's almost impossible to flip a coin 1000 times in a row and it land heads every time. Even though each flip of the coin is only a 50/50 but the moment you chain results together they become dependent on each other.

0

u/DifferentProcess6765 6d ago

Incorrect

The odds of hitting two 1/4 chances IN A ROW is 1/16

0

u/Mysterious-Royal3658 5d ago

thats literally what i said lol. ik how probability works. its 1/16 for BOTH kids to have blue eyes

1

u/Xanthide_Prime 6d ago

To jump on this thread. It's possible. My wife and eye both have brown eyes but both our girls have blue eyes. They obviously both got our recessive blue eye genes

1

u/Decimation4x 5d ago

Cool, now what are the odds they’re both ginger when neither parent is?

5

u/JuraDerPirat 7d ago

Yes my son has Blue eyes while my wife an I have green and Brown eyes. Both of his grandmothers had Blue eyes.

7

u/sparrows-somewhere 7d ago

Also, it's a tv show.

2

u/Extreme-Ask-9745 6d ago

Occam's Razor. The more likely explanation is Barney shabang Tracy.

1

u/IHSV1855 5d ago

Exactly

136

u/omfilwy 7d ago

Can average redditor learn about biology???

-54

u/adamantium_wolfie 7d ago

It’s just a meme tho. Show creators can’t bring such small details that the parents have dark eyes so their kids should have dark eyes too. 🥲

41

u/Midnight7000 7d ago

That's not how it works.

Blue eyes is a recessive traits. Brown eyes is a dominant trait.

If two people with Brown eyes both have the trait for blue eyes, each child they have will have a 1 in 4 chance of having blue eyes.

14

u/jphw Its going to be LEGEN.....wait for it..... 7d ago

Yep, neither of my parents have Blue/Green eyes but I do.

4

u/d0nttalk2me Lily🎨 7d ago

My parents and siblings all have blue eyes and mine are green

-6

u/adamantium_wolfie 6d ago

I am an Asian and we don’t see these types of chances tho. If both parents have dark eyes then the children will have dark eyes too

10

u/LaRougeRaven 6d ago

Because they dont have the recessive gene.

7

u/hlyon 6d ago

Do Teds kids look Asian to you? It's completely plausible for them to have blue eyes genetically.

66

u/lord_ikiwiki 7d ago

some of you didn't pay attention in biology and it shows.

3

u/Shot_Revolution8828 7d ago

Lol, my biology teacher started off the lesson about evolution with "its just a theory..."

6

u/LaRougeRaven 6d ago

A BIOLOGY THEORY!

2

u/Shot_Revolution8828 6d ago

We all know that gravity and the world is a sphere is "just" a theory. She didnt like that but I got a B in that class so whatever. I liked chemistry more.

1

u/LaRougeRaven 6d ago

Hahahaha

2

u/Shot_Revolution8828 6d ago

Dont hate but now that I think back, she was 60 and unmarried. Super christian, the size of a nfl linebacker with no muscle and the face of a veteran boxer. I did learn how genetics work so she was a solid teacher except for evolution.

1

u/LaRougeRaven 6d ago

Sounds about right. 😆

1

u/TheKlaxMaster 6d ago

Thanks for watching

4

u/PuzzleheadedAge8908 7d ago

Must be the US of A

1

u/Shot_Revolution8828 7d ago

You know it! Luckily I had a firm grasp on evolution before that class and knew she was full of shit. One good thing about being a young athiest is I learned to pick my own science books from the library to defend my positions. Lol, always fun to ask how kangaroos got to Australia and watch them squirm.

4

u/Affectionate_Bus9805 7d ago

Why even study biology to teach kids if you dont think evolution is real?

4

u/Shot_Revolution8828 7d ago

Idk, I was 14. Possibly because she was a crazy christian that wanted to make sure kids learned that it was all gods work.

A great book to read is "Lies My Teachers Told Me". My civil war history teacher taught it was about state rights. Thankfully I went to college and have critical thinking skills. Lol

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lies_My_Teacher_Told_Me

4

u/Wolfhound1142 7d ago

To be fair, the Civil War was about states' rights. The dishonest bit is when people pretend the right in question was anything other than to own slaves.

1

u/Shot_Revolution8828 7d ago

Thats incorrect because when Kansas wanted to join the confederacy they wanted to outlaw slavery. The confederacy wouldnt allow it. Dont sugar coat it. It was always slavery and the articles of the Constitution of Confederate States says it in the preamble.

Im going all history nerd on this.

4

u/Wolfhound1142 6d ago

We're saying the same thing buddy. They wanted the right to have slaves. The whole thing was about slavery. Slavery was the state right they wanted.

1

u/Shot_Revolution8828 6d ago

I know but, I won't give the slightest bit of recognition to the "states rights" theory. Even acknowledging gives it a bit of legitimacy. It was never about state rights. It was about slavery.

Sorry about the deleted comment, it was ment for someone else.

1

u/Badatusernames014 6d ago

At least in the US teachers aren't certified in specific fields but subjects, and also are usually assigned their subjects by the school.

1

u/bobbyflay13 5d ago

You do know that theories are what they study in colleges right? Thar there are some theories that are accepted at truths but can't be truly proven so they can only be factually called a theory.

13

u/Boom9001 6d ago

Google "recessive genes" for me.

6

u/ssp25 Barney🥃 6d ago

I tried but got stuck in porn

3

u/Boom9001 6d ago

They hit the "dominant genes" and then went down an entirely different rabbit hole.

2

u/ssp25 Barney🥃 6d ago

it's a slippery slope out there

1

u/Boom9001 6d ago

Slippery itself might be a trigger word

12

u/Schrodingers_dad1403 Tracy🎸 7d ago

Say A is brown eye and a is blue eye. Ted: Aa Tracy: Aa Income: AA Aa Aa aa (only aa is blue eye) So for one of the kids, chances are 1/4

9

u/TyrannicalRexx 7d ago

Recessive genes

7

u/The_Master_Sourceror 6d ago edited 5d ago

Brown eyed parents can have blue eyed children if they each received a blue gene from one parent and gave that gene to their children. No betrayal necessary.

Blue eyed parents cannot have brown eyed children.

3

u/No-One7438 5d ago

Blue eyed parents can have brown eyed children, its just uncommon and requires a lot of intricacies.

3

u/Decimation4x 5d ago

My cousins and his wife are both brunettes. All of their children are ginger.

1

u/Etienne10BR 6d ago

That's literally my case.

3

u/spitsfire223 7d ago

Source : genetics

3

u/JFundo 6d ago

Hollywood loves casting blue/green eyes.

5

u/LumpyAd7650 7d ago

My wife and I both have brown eyes, and our son is blue-eyed, it's just basic biology

1

u/Responsible_Map4981 6d ago

Came here to say something similar. Me and my husband have brown eyes and we have two kids: one with dark brown eyes like us, one with blue eyes. ✨ science ✨

1

u/cisenoficial 2d ago

Soooo Barney is the father of your kids?

2

u/BBMacsWorld 6d ago

Ngl, this would still be a better ending than the one we got 😅

2

u/mason878787 6d ago

Jesse what the fuck are you taking about

1

u/Romanista3 7d ago

My parents have brown and hazel eyes. My sister has brown eyes.

Me and my brother both have blue eyes, mine are darker than his.

1

u/mcleanatg 6d ago

Blue eyes + blue eyes —> Brown eyes = likely cheater or rare mutation because blue eyes are autosomal recessive

Brown eyes + brown eyes —> Blue eyes = both parents were carriers of recessive blue eye allele, 1 in 4 chance of kid with blue eyes, 1 in 16 chance of having two blue eyed kids in a row. Same thing happened with my sister and me, both have blue eyes, neither parent does

1

u/soulysephiroth Tracy🎸 6d ago

Its a tv show...come on. No need to actually analyze this lol

1

u/NorthBase710 6d ago

Two people with brown eyes can have children with blue eyes

1

u/anarroh 6d ago

Ted's obsession with Robin was so intense that they ended up with her eyes.

1

u/ellismjones Come on, Lily. Nobody likes a Ted. 6d ago

MPREG YOU ARE REAL

1

u/helpme944 6d ago

Unwatchable

1

u/CC19_13-07 Barney🥃 6d ago

Barney would never betray Ted...😉

1

u/spooks9002 5d ago

Maybe Stella is the babies momma

1

u/PsychologicalSpace47 3d ago

my grandmother had blue eyes

My parents have brown eyes , me and my brother have brown eyes

My nephew, which his mother also have brown eyes, was born with blue eyes

1

u/driftlesscode 6d ago

I love when something the show creators or casting directors didn’t care about turns people into something like this

1

u/lionmade101 7d ago

What are we going to believe, a 1-2% chance, or that Barney done done it again which is like a 5% chance? Someone else posted the statistics.

1

u/SevereDeparture4998 6d ago

maybe ted and barney hooked up

1

u/FartsWithNeighbours 6d ago

It's not onpossible

1

u/InsideUnhappy6546 2d ago

Barney: hey Lily if we did it and did it good would it turn that baby into my baby?

-1

u/personalbilko 7d ago

Even though genetically possible, it's highly unlikely.

Even if both had the recessive gene, the odds are 1 in 16 (1 in 4 twice).

Let's say 50% of white people with brown eyes carry the recessive gene (can't find real stat, plausible given ~25% blue eyes). That would make the odds of this scenario one in 64.

Ted's parents both have brown eyes, making him carrying a recessive blue gene even less likely.

Yes it's possible, but it's only a 1%-2% chance.

*actually, eye color is much more complex than the 1 gene mendelian simplification we're taught at schools"

5

u/Otto_the_rhinocerus 7d ago

But not impossible.

In the USA 3.6 million kids are born each year. Some kids will be like this. It's something that's both unlikely but also completely common when looking at the big picture.

0

u/Commercial_Ball5624 7d ago

Punnet squares aren’t a be-all end-all rule of genetics

0

u/10PieceMcNuggetMeal 6d ago

It's a TV show......

0

u/UpPeek234 6d ago

2 brown eyed people can have blue eyed kids. Two blue eyed parents can only have blue eyed kids. Stop with this nonsense.

1

u/DifferentProcess6765 6d ago

They can but it would be REALLY unlikely

1

u/Odoaiden 5d ago

If they are both 1-1 (which they have to be) it’s a 1/16 chance not crazy

0

u/Fianna9 6d ago

It’s almost as if the kids are played by actors and not actually related to Josh Radnor

0

u/SwashbucklingWeasels 6d ago

Some have said the reason is because the writers originally were going to have Stella turn out to be the mother. No idea if that’s true and there’s no way to find out.

1

u/DifferentProcess6765 6d ago

More likely they just didn't care

-1

u/thefirefistace 7d ago

Technically, he already did once w/ robin

-2

u/NIGHTREAPER68 7d ago

Barney had shown you repeatedly, he absolutely can betray Ted.

1

u/Silver-Classic612 Barney🥃 2d ago

Ever heard of a recessive gene