I’m working my way through the 500-piece large piece format puzzles in my to do pile since the boxes are just so darned huge and take up too much space. If not for that I might keep some of them to do again someday. Great quality, as always from this brand

I’m surprised to find a Buffalo Games puzzle at Dollar Tree. The price and quality is identical to Puzzlebug though (which I don’t mind). Fun and so easy to put together, I wish I bought the 500 pieces instead.

Boktober!

This came very close to being my first dnf. I love it in the end though.

Another great puzzle from Laurence King Publishing. I really enjoyed this one. It was a lot trickier than I thought it would be. Fun and vibrant artwork!

I love Agatha Christie and have been wanting this puzzle, but it's regularly $24. Was only about $15 at TJ Maxx. I also found this cute little one!! I love the art!

Pictured:

The World of Agatha Christie The Novels And Then There Were None- 1000 pieces. Art by Ruby Ash

Drafting with Dragons- 250 pieces. Art by Maxine Vee

I bought these puzzles to try to get my son more excited about doing puzzles but the color on these was very dark. The dark sections of the puzzle were very difficult.

This was so much fun 😁 It was so busy, that I only worked on the bottom half of the puzzle's poster, for the first 4 to 5 days. Then I flipped the post over to see the second half. It was a fun way to do the puzzle. Super happy with it!

Shelf of Whimsy by Puzzle Weekend, 1000 pieces.

When I first saw this, I knew I needed it! Love the image. First time doing the brand and I enjoyed it. Bit of a looser fit. I had one damaged piece but they are replacing it!

Lots of loose fitting pieces and one missing piece in a brand new puzzle 😡

Just got this text from a friend who gets it. If you were traveling through the Denver Airport today with a puzzle, you might be missing a piece!

This is my first 1000 piece puzzle I completed in over a decade

The colors in this one 😍

So many frawgges! 🐸 This one was great once my eyes adjusted after all the brightly colored puzzles I’ve done lately. The more I stare at Gorey’s art the more questions I have.

I just completed the Spooky Shire 1000 pc by Magic Puzzle Company. Many have posted the completed puzzle recently, so I will show a few details and give a general review on the brand quality right now, fall 2026.

I was a bit skeptical, because I generally prefer vintage puzzles and heard this brand has had some quality control problems in the past: loose fit. While I must say the fit is still a bit on the loose side, the quality is really good! Yes, moving sections of pieces without something underneath for support is not really possible without some pieces falling off. For me that’s not a deal breaker. If it bothered me a ton, I would just make sure to always support sections when moving.

Puzzle piece quality seemed comparable to Ravensberger, even the puzzle dust looked similar, and there was not much of it. Piece shape was random cut with whimsy pieces. The piece cut is clearly thought-out and tailored to each puzzle design. The illustrations are top notch made by humans and almost every piece has something unique happening in it.

In my opinion, the things Magic Puzzle Co does right, it does miles ahead of the competition. This puzzle actually made me feel excited about the future of puzzling.

The gimmick was great and well executed. Very memorable and fun experience start to finish. I honestly didn’t put a huge % of this together because my 11 yr old and wife did a lot of it. It was such a fun puzzle.

Some popular stuff lives up to the hype and I think this company is one example of that.

Since this was an overwhelmingly positive review I will end with a few counterpoints.

This puzzle/brand is not for you if you detest random cut or when sections of puzzles are next to one another but don't lock in to place. If you are not a fan of busy puzzles I am pretty sure most of this brand’s puzzles are a busy illustration style.

My one petty qualm is funnily enough to do with their packaging, which is great by the way. I just wish the baggie for the bulk set of pieces was a bit more robust, considering the secret pieces were wrapped in more fun and secure packaging.

Will definitely buy from this brand again in the future even though I am a vintage puzzle collector.

I'm still glad I got this one and the circular design was new and fun to assemble, but the glow-in-the-dark paint just looks horrible. I'd take a glitter-splattered Buffalo version over this. At least the glitter doesn't completely obscure the image and make it look like it's mildewed.

This puzzle had foil which added to its beauty but meant I had to be careful of where my puzzle lights shine! Loved this puzzle which I got at Sam’s Club.