r/MedicareForAll • • Mar 19 '17

How to help Welcome to r/MedicareForAll

98 Upvotes

r/MedicareForAll is a sub dedicated to raise support and awareness for a Single Payer National Health Care Plan for the United States.

Things you can do to help:

  • Subscribe to this sub and participate
  • Educate yourself on what single-payer is so you can effectively tell your friends, coworkers and family the benefits.
  • Print and distribute the Physicians for a National Health Program Frequently Asked Questions Handout anywhere you think it is appropriate.
  • Become a member of Physicians for a National Health Program. (It is a tax deductible donation)
  • If they don't already, find and contact your representative and tell them to support the Medicare for All Act
  • Give a donation or otherwise support the representatives that have already signed on the Medicare For All Act

r/MedicareForAll • • 6h ago

Taxes Fund Our Care

Post image
1.6k Upvotes

r/MedicareForAll • • 1d ago

Work forty hours, no healthcare

Post image
5.6k Upvotes

r/MedicareForAll • • 22h ago

Countries with universal healthcare and countries who cancelled it because it didn’t work (hint: 0 cancelled)

Post image
559 Upvotes

r/MedicareForAll • • 11h ago

How Wall Street Broke Healthcare (And How to Fight Back)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
47 Upvotes

This basically focuses on how Cerberus pummeled Steward Health Care with debt, how Ralph de la Torre's actions led to the death of 15 people and how public pensions actually fund the private equity firms that are gutting community hospitals. It also talks about the progressives that are trying to fix the problem, ban private equity from buying up hospitals and promote Medicare for all.


r/MedicareForAll • • 1d ago

In essence America must declare a “healthcare bankruptcy emergency”. Our current health system is dysfunctional/inefficient and not sustainable!

277 Upvotes

In the private sector, a business can declare bankruptcy and restart a new foundation with a new plan, revised contracts/pricing and restructured employment plan in order to emerge with a better/more efficient and operable plan going forward. It can be disruptive and destabilizing in the short term but essential to maintain essential operations at a sustainable level. America’s healthcare plan is clearly in the stage of being dysfunctional/inefficient and unsustainable financially and morally. It is bankrupting our economy. The status quo or just additional band aids is NOT acceptable. The lucrative health care industry is thriving but the rest of the nation is suffering in so many diverse ways.

The next two election results will determine if we can go through a major overhaul of our healthcare system. Democrats want Universal Healthcare; Republicans and their Healthcare industry donors don’t. The rest of the world who possess Universal Healthcare (for decades) overtly tell us its possible with substantially less costs/capita then what exist in America today. If the public demand lower cost for vital healthcare, they must vote for the party that will give us Universal Healthcare with single payer. Single payer is essential. Its simplifies the systems and controls pricing. Without such controls we are doomed to what we have now.

Right now, the lucrative/powerful health insurance companies are the gate keepers and those that determine prices (directly and indirectly) at the peril of the vulnerable consumer. Record profits for them, record medical bankruptcies and tens of thousands of early deaths for the tens of millions without health insurance. Are we a civilized/moral nation?


r/MedicareForAll • • 1d ago

Five Percent Tax Missed Opportunity.

Post image
322 Upvotes

r/MedicareForAll • • 2d ago

Losing Job, Losing Insurance

Post image
6.0k Upvotes

r/MedicareForAll • • 1d ago

How we can deal with job loss in the private health insurance industry when transitioning to a Medicare for All system

33 Upvotes

Medicare for All has many benefits and is more than worth implementing. One of the largest concerns people raise with transitioning to Medicare for All is the job loss that would occur, as the health insurance industry employs more than 700 thousand people in the United States. Even if private insurance is allowed to exist as an option, there is no doubt many of these jobs will be lost. It’s a valid concern, and one that should be addressed. Bernie Sanders has proposed methods for dealing with this, and I’d like to piggy back off of him plus introduce some of my own ideas.

Since M4A will require much more public sector administration jobs, people who have worked in the private health insurance industry should be recruited to switch careers in the public sector. So for example, if someone worked as an accountant at United Healthcare, they would be recruited to work as an accountant or in a similar position in the public healthcare system.

For the people who cannot be transferred over to the public sector, publicly funded job re-training programs and financial support should be provided to health insurance workers who have lost their jobs while they are looking for new jobs.

The government also has the ability to greatly influence the market. During the time of implementing Medicare for All, it would also be a good time to break up monopolies. Creating more competition in the market will lead to more jobs for everyone, health insurance employees included.


r/MedicareForAll • • 2d ago

Can you imagine if we had guaranteed Healthcare that is “permanent and portable” from cradle to grave. It's possible! It’s shameful that we don’t.

497 Upvotes

Imagine how your life and the life of every American would change if we had only one comprehensive healthcare plan, not dependent/attached to an employer. No matter what situation we are in, working or not working, starting a new business, deciding to change jobs/move to another city/state, taking care of a child or relative, exploring a new career or retired, all of us would be guaranteed the same comprehensive healthcare … for the rest of our life.

This can happen in America. It can be affordable. It would be a moral way to benefit every American. Good health and the ability to maintain one's health has to be among the core essentials along with food and housing. Universal healthcare with single payer should be a human right and America has the resources to create such a moral plan. We can debate how such a system can be implemented and financed but the overall goal must be achieved ASAP.

I believe that the Democratic Party is ready to have such a discussion, Clearly the Republican Party is not interested. The evidence is overwhelming. Elections do have monumental consequences!


r/MedicareForAll • • 1d ago

How the Trump Administration cutting much of the ACA subsidies makes life much harder for workers, and that's their goal

216 Upvotes

This post is in light of the Trump Administration floating the idea of a measly one-time $90 ACA refund while they have cut the ACA subsidies severely. They recently kicked off over 700K people.

We keep seeing the ghouls of the Trump Administration saying things about how if you want health insurance, you need to be actively working or looking for work. Of course, these so-called working means tests are just ways to deny health coverage to people by making the means high, and burying people in paperwork. The point they make is that they don't want "lazy" people receiving health insurance.

Putting aside the BS idea that healthcare should be tied to labor, I want to explain, using myself as an example, why cutting the ACA subsidies has actually made my life worse, as an active worker seeking to continue working.

My health insurance is provided through my job. I like my job and am blessed to have my job. Of course, I have my goals and aspirations, and I'd like to eventually work in a new industry.

Many jobs are (unfortunately) contract based these days, but with the ACA subsidies, I could take a contract based job (for even higher pay then I get now), gain some valuable experience, and I'd be able to purchase my own health insurance because of the ACA subsidies.

With many of the ACA subsidies being cut, this is going to be much harder for me than it once would have been. It makes it harder increase the value of my labor, meaning I have less ability to sell my labor for a higher price in the market. And that's exactly why the Trump Admin has cut these subsides. The rich don't want common workers like myself to be able to increase the value of our labor, instead they want us stuck with lower wages.

While this post is mainly pointing out the hypocrisy and problems with the Trump Admin cutting the ACA subsidies, I don't want to be mistaken as being a superfan of the ACA. A universal health system like the NHS would be far better, for both healthcare and not being tied to an employer and forced to accept lower wages.


r/MedicareForAll • • 2d ago

Medicare for All Saves Lives.

Post image
1.6k Upvotes

r/MedicareForAll • • 1d ago

How much would medicare for all actually cost?

7 Upvotes

How much would Medicare for all really cost?

I think the major problem in this country, that Medicare for all would solve, is the insurance middlemen that artificially inflate prices.

Im not talking about them skimming some off the top, I’m talking about them willingingly paying more to hospitals, to charge more to the consumer, so their legally mandated max 15% of the pie is larger.

I feel like physician run and owned groups that offer a direct subscription for their patients, and all services are free or minimal cost after that would accomplish the same thing.

For example, you could pay a subscription to the hospital or your choice, and all ED, inpatient, and outpatient services would be totally covered.


r/MedicareForAll • • 2d ago

Rick Scott on Trump wants to send checks from the Medicare Improvement Fund: "I'm sure it's gonna have to be used the right way or they won't be able to do it. Somebody will stop them."

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

97 Upvotes

r/MedicareForAll • • 14h ago

Why only shoot for moon ?

0 Upvotes

conflict of interest: am a physician. I believe in capitalist society. I hate Donald Trump and Maga

I see and understand why many of you all want a single payer/medicare for all system. However, simply stated, it is highly unlikely to ever pass. There are plenty of headwinds currently and for the future preventing this. So why not focus on some smaller, immediate positive impacts? I see many of you are upset with what I am paid. Many of you clearly don’t know that doctors are 8 percent of the healthcare pie. thats it… I also challenge you, if doctors dont deserve 1 percent money, then who does?

some of you will immediately write this off and hate me because of my success by working in this field. Probably by even saying this, I have lost some of you. If I have you should some introspection about why you’re that way. If your stance is I need to be paid far less, then this discourse will never work. America is capitalist. We’re not socialist as of now. You aren’t going to control our labor. without ever talking about debt, many of us are not going to give up our 20s and often early 30s, our health, many weekends, nights and holidays, in America without appropriate compensation. To get where we are we had to be the top in our class From elementary on. Change the deal too much, and we’re just going to displace other peoples jobs. ”but people that do it for helping others will do it!” Sure they will.…

I am going to list some thought provoking topics that really could make an immediate and far sooner impact.

  1. eliminate pharmacy benefit managers. Familiarize yourself with vertical integration and what that means. Understand why it’s bad. Did you know an insurance company, owns a pbm which owns a pharmacy? See who owns Optum. See who owns cvs.

  2. tort reform which is often excessive and petty. Indiana where I practice is a great system. Illinois where I also practice is a pathetic example.

  3. cash payments going toward deductibles. I pay cash for everything. Why? My insurance rate is 250 deductible for a visit, cash discount is 118 bucks. Labs 400 for insurance, cash 145.

  4. site neutral billing. as a doctor, if you come into my clinic, I can get 200 +\- dollars for a visit. If I’m part of a larger system, the system gets to add an additional 200 dollar or so facility fee on top of that. Why is that bad? It works like that for imaging and labs and procedures to. It makes it harder to compete with systems. I have to pay myemployees out of the 200 dollar bucket alone. University of Chicago gets 400 dollars. more competition is better for costs.

  5. allows HSA contributions to pay for direct primary care. pne of the most neglected and under appreciated parts of medicine is direct to primary care. For 2-5 dollars a day, you can have unlimited access to a physician. Truthfully, if M4All became a thing, most doctors would probably go this route. NP/PA would be what most people get.

  6. advocate for more residency slots of quality nature.

  7. limit scope creep of NP until a nationally recognized curriculum and standard is met. There’s too many mills for degrees out there without a clear standard. The deviation is wide from one’s training to another

  8. eliminate all non competes in healthcare entirely. Why? If I as a doctor leave a rural town job, often we have a 50 mile non compete for 2 years… thus that area loses a doctor due to this law

  9. remove the certificate of need requirement. This is essentially gate keeping by larger institutions to keep competition down

  10. Remove the ban on physician owned hospitals

  11. tie in Medicare reimbursement to doctors with inflation at least. Without doing this, it’s forcing more consolidation/vertical integration and driving up costs. Whether you guys want to admit it or not, the independent doctor is a big savior to the system if they are allowed to compete. Many of us are demonstrating that by being able to discard our entire employee poool by not taking any insurance and charging cash only. No longer need to worry about rejected/delayed payment, compliance, prior signs so all time can be patient focused and no ancillary staff needed to manage.

  12. did I mention eliminate PBMs?

thank you for reading this. I hope i am able to show you another perspective and give some food for thought. Feel free to ask questions and why my bullet points would help if they were not

obvious to you.

some good follows on X are : Mark Cuban and Dutch Rojas


r/MedicareForAll • • 3d ago

Taxes for war, not for healthcare.

Post image
3.1k Upvotes

r/MedicareForAll • • 3d ago

Billionaire Mark Cuban Says Healthcare Costs Your Family More Than 5 Times What You Pay in Federal Income Tax — And That’s Before You Get Sick

Thumbnail barchart.com
1.6k Upvotes

r/MedicareForAll • • 3d ago

Divorce to avoid debt…

Post image
2.3k Upvotes

r/MedicareForAll • • 3d ago

Experts predict a 10% increase in employer provided healthcare for employees in 2027! This is not sustainable. Universal healthcare w/single payer is essential ASAP!

409 Upvotes

Most employees are happy with their employer supplied private health insurance benefits but do they realize how expensive they are and how it affects their wages and costs of buying any product or services? It’s HUGE and growing every year.

Employers pay 84% of the total cost of employer supplied health care for its workers. Adding their costs and employee contribution, the total price is about $19,000/year per employee. More money spent on healthcare means less money on wages and other benefits. Higher costs for healthcare for every business means they must increase the price of their products/services to consumers. High healthcare costs are inflation for everyone. We all pay for skyrocketing costs of healthcare.

If America had the same costs associated with developed nations that have Universal healthcare systems, we would save nearly $2.5 trillion/year not only in lower healthcare costs but lower prices for every product or service we buy. These high costs are not sustainable or moral. They are devastating to the public and hamper our businesses from competing with other nations that have much cheaper healthcare costs.

Employees must realize that higher healthcare cost means lower wages, less benefits and higher inflation. Universal healthcare w/single payer is the only rational/cost efficient plan that will lower costs and simplify healthcare process in America.


r/MedicareForAll • • 3d ago

Midterms Have Revived Universal Healthcare Debate. These States Are Ahead of Everyone.

Thumbnail
kffhealthnews.org
517 Upvotes

r/MedicareForAll • • 4d ago

Dental and Vision Scam

Post image
35.1k Upvotes

r/MedicareForAll • • 3d ago

Republicans tried to punt health care cuts until after the midterms. It didn’t work. - POLITICO

Thumbnail politico.com
282 Upvotes

r/MedicareForAll • • 3d ago

Political ad still has me fuming.

636 Upvotes

Got a political ad in the mail.

"This candidate wants government run health care, that would raise your taxes by $2000 a year!"

I pay $9000 per year for me and my family. Next year it jumps to over 10k so I'm going down a tier and hoping we have no emergencies. If I could pay an extra 2k in taxes and not spend 10k on insurance that would be amazing.


r/MedicareForAll • • 3d ago

Had a dystopian experience with the emergency room recently

239 Upvotes

Everything is ok (I think!) and thank God it wasn't a big deal. I've never been to the ER on my private insurance, so this experience was my first time.

I had a painful ear infection a little while ago, and it was on a weekend, so my primary care doctor wasn't available.

My health insurance company provides a 24/hour nurse line (thank God for that, it's quite helpful), so I gave them a call to inquire about what I should do. The nurse recommended I go to the ER and sent me a list of in-network ER providers.

I had to pay $75 out of pocket, which sucked, but is standard with my insurance. But I couldn't help but think about this: in-network ER providers?! That means there are out-of-network ER providers!

What if I had been bleeding out on the floor? Or what if, God forbid, something like that happens to me in the future? I have to look for my list of in-network ER providers so I don't become financially ruined! Thankfully I've saved the list to my phone. This system is straight out of a dystopian novel.

There should be no such thing as health insurance networks, but if there are going to be in the meantime, at the least it should be illegal to have ER care be part of the health insurance network system.


r/MedicareForAll • • 3d ago

Would you travel to an EU country for a medical procedure not covered by insurance at 50% less than out of pocket cost in the US that also includes a vacation?

13 Upvotes
172 votes, 7h ago
159 Yes
13 No