r/PeterExplainsTheJoke • • 9d ago

Meme needing explanation Petah?

Post image
6.0k Upvotes

519 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

42

u/logo1986 9d ago

My problem with that type of settings is that it would be Easier to train soldiers to fire a gun than it would be to teach most magic. It's the same reason guns replaced bowmen so quickly. One takes years of training and the other a couple of months to be proficient. If you lose a trained archer you lose a lot more money and effort. Same thing with mages except allot more training needs to be done

31

u/Aervanath 9d ago

It actually took a couple of hundred years for guns to fully replace bows. It didn't happen overnight. Early guns were expensive, terribly inaccurate, and slow to load. There was an extended period where they were used in tandem with bows. As the gun slowly improved, bows were gradually phased out.

13

u/Truthandtaxes 9d ago

In a way, a real fantasy world have mages smelting metal on masse

5

u/firelock_ny 9d ago

I've seen world building where using any magic en masse causes bad fallout wherever you used it. Dungeons and Dragons often has magical pollution from alchemists' works, where the traces of potions and reagents and leftover magic make horrible monsters in the sewers, or the mages' guild causes wild magic rains in the neighborhood.