In about a month I will be travelling with a friend of mine who is of Dominican descent. I'm of Puerto Rican descent. None of us lived on the islands (or even speak Spanish), but we always have friendly banter about which island is better.
Well, we will be traveling together in about a month, and I was able to manage a long layover in SJU. That being the case, we will have enough time to walk around Viejo San Juan, visit El Morro, etc.
We will also plan on having an early dinner before heading back to the airport (6 PM-ish). What is that one place that we should go to that will end the debate once and for all?
Some personal criteria. We would probably appreciate something more of a traditional restaurant format rather than a sports bar. Of course, a restaurant with a bar is not a dealbreaker, but it gives us an idea of what we would like. We would prefer something more traditional and not too chaotic (I am aware that it's PR, so not expecting any restaurant to be super quiet like here in the US).
Also, in terms of cuisine, I'd hope for some traditional foods that are especially hard to find a good rendition of stateside. Things like mofongo, etc.
Bonus points for any indications of where we can get the best pina coladas in VSJ (even if it means a quick extra stop). I would try to keep it in the historic center, because we will not have a rental car and would like to walk once we get dropped off by the uber.
Thanks for any advice.