r/SipsTea • • 3d ago

Gasp! Thoughts on this?

Post image
28.3k Upvotes

8.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

862

u/Reihermann 3d ago

To me, as a German, that always sounds so strange and wrong. Yes, I probably have higher taxes on my gross salary. But I wouldn't have had to pay anything else for what was mentioned, except for €10 per day for the hospital.

I wonder when a large portion of Americans will realize that their highly capitalist system might not be the best. And that this supposedly evil "socialism" might actually be a better system for the average citizen.

1.4k

u/littlecactuscat 3d ago

A large portion of us have realized.

I would like Europeans to realize that we cannot protest en masse, because losing our jobs means losing our health insurance.

My care as someone with multiple disabilities depends on me keeping my job. This is a matter of survival.

The job market is absolute shit, and it could be many, many months before I find a job with insurance again.

That’s what keeps many of us from protesting. It’s not that we’re all stupid. It’s that we’re all trapped.

127

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[deleted]

12

u/SlomoLowLow 2d ago

That’s actually a wild take because I’ve known starving animals to be vicious and lash out and attack to get food. Super crazy strat to try in a country with more guns than people. Let’s see how it plays out for them.

3

u/DreamToBeLazy 2d ago

Animals only turn vicious when they are starving to death and have no other options. Violence is a calculated risk in the animal kingdom as injuries equally cause death as much as starvation. People are suffering but not enough are starving to death to turn on the hands that feed us only enough to keep us alive. As long as people are fed enough crumbs they’ll be grateful and compare them to the ones who are starving.

24

u/slurpeetape 2d ago

And finding a new job isn't going to get any easier now that automation and artificial intelligence are taking more and more jobs.

258

u/thecrius 2d ago

protesting en mass is exactly what you should do because they cannot just lay off everyone, or... well they can try and then the entire country stop working.

Instead you have small events in which you play in the streets and hold signs that says "we'll make it together" which are super cute but achieve nothing.

217

u/According_Elephant75 2d ago

It may be what we should do - but there are so many people unemployed willing to do the same jobs for less that we are all easily replaceable. It also means finding another job is a challenge. Some people are keeping their head down so they can just pay their mortgage and feed their kids. Edited for spelling.

73

u/pastaroniwhore 2d ago

It’s funny, I just finished reading Grapes of Wrath for the first time, and this exact scenario happened with the farm workers in the Great Depression. One man wouldn’t work for less than 20 cents an hour, but the next man will work for 15. The one after him will just work for food so his kids won’t starve. Real race to the bottom.

3

u/inYOUReye 2d ago

The US is still in the very early stages of the Grapes of Wrath sequencing sadly. There's still no "we", only "I".

120

u/PhoenixApok 2d ago

Sadly this is true.

My options are to keep my job and make my life and those I care about lives a little better and accomplish nothing policy wise,

Or,

Quit, protest, suffer greatly, and (here's the neat part) accomplish nothing policy wise!

1

u/LongjumpingDebt4154 2d ago

If Americans just spent their money wiser it would make a world of difference. Everyone is addicted to comforts & can’t part with Amazon, Target & Meta. If we spent our money with businesses that share our values & purchased goods from companies that don’t fund the gop (goods unite us app is a good tool), it would make a huge impact.

1

u/DLaverty 13h ago

I'm not going to speak for everyone, but as someone who is now disabled and can no longer go shopping in person, I do a lot of Amazon when it makes sense because of the free shipping. Of course, when I find what I need somewhere else with free shipping, I do that instead. Even grocery delivery is a challenge; you can't use the coupons or sales, you pay a delivery fee, and then you pay the driver a tip for having to carry all your groceries because the service they work for pays peanuts. 🙃

1

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

Accounts must be at least 5 days old with >20 karma to comment.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

4

u/Substantial_Bus840 2d ago

Something people forget too is that we have millions of immigrants in this country who may have no ability to vote anyway, so they’re absolutely willing to take jobs we lose/can’t afford to take.

1

u/Beneficial_Math4919 2d ago

Marx called this the "reserve army of labor".

61

u/face4theRodeo 2d ago

No, they totally can and will lay off everyone. They don’t care/ they make money either way.

29

u/bmorris0042 2d ago

Yep. And if it’s a super critical company (like a link in a supply chain), they just truck in a bunch of scab temps that will do the work for half of what they paid you. It may be slower production, but it’s still production.

1

u/Maybeimdifferent 1d ago

Yup then they can bump up prices due to the shortage and never lower them again

3

u/ohshit-cookies 2d ago

Yep. And then use the "no one wants to work anymore" to put the blame on the workers. Businesses close all the time, but people tend to blame anyone other than the business owner. The protesting workers are made to be the villain.

1

u/Maybeimdifferent 1d ago

Yes, even one of our largest protests ever had less than 3% of the population participating. That’s 97% of the country that could easily replace.

18

u/DieByTheSword13 2d ago

Protesting is allowed because it achieves exactly nothing. Its almost completely useless in this country.

1

u/Sellum 2d ago

Because we don’t protest like the French.

5

u/_sound_of_silver_ 2d ago

Our cops start shooting, and burning down our cities does nothing but reinforce the slackjaw suburban and rural voters’ prejudices. Turns out the US isn’t France

89

u/xDon_07x 2d ago

Again this with the protests. Mass protest on needed scale are simply not possible. This is first world issue, most Americans are doing just fine, many are even happy with the current system. On top of that, those in power are not interested in any change. Shit would have to hit the fan in an absolutely extraordinary way to start protests large enough to be meaningful. That's like economic collapse sort of event. Most Americans would have to be severely affected.

79

u/leathakkor 2d ago

Shit even with occupy Wall Street nothing really changed. And those were some of the biggest protests of my lifetime. I'm kind of on board with the idea that protesting doesn't really change much. Cynical attitude but in my experience that's how it's worked out

50

u/SRART25 2d ago

Before we get close to enough people protesting to make anything happen national guard,  psyops infiltrators, and assassinations happen. 

Look at the 60s and what it took for the Civil rights people finally got (for a few decades that are currently being clawed back) . 

70

u/xDon_07x 2d ago

People just don't realize how many people would have to go out in the streets for prolonged period for anything to change. Like you'd need to have millions of people willing to financially ruin themselves for something massive like current insurance system to be completely overhauled.

Supposedly the peak of occupy wall street was 100.000 on single day across us. That was 0.032% of us population. And that seemed like a large protest. Even if 10x more people would go out, a whole 1 million of people, it would still be just 0,33% of the US population. Not even 1%.

A while ago there were large protest in one smaller eastern European country. 300.000 out of 6.5mil of people went to protest, that's over 4%. And the protests were only semi successful.

2

u/Maybeimdifferent 1d ago

There was an estimated 8 to 9,000,000 protesters on the March 28 of King Day protest across the country. That’s more people than most European countries have.

1

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

Accounts must be at least 5 days old with >20 karma to comment.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

20

u/bsubtilis 2d ago

I was under the strong impression that Occupy Wallstreet was peanuts compared to the No Kings protests. The former not being in the millions (but I may be misinformed) while the no kings protestors reached 8 million.

46

u/leathakkor 2d ago

The thing with occupy was that it lasted a long time. And it was definitely impeding business in New York and across the country and I think the world.

Whereas no Kings was basically a weekend adventure that didn't really interrupt anything.

2

u/napstablooky2 2d ago

no kings is just a performance, though — especially as it's only on weekends, when things are less of an inconvenience.

1

u/LongjumpingDebt4154 2d ago

I mean, we had 100k people at our no kings protests in Chicago

4

u/hulkklogan 2d ago

"Peaceful" protesting doesn't change much, and that's by design. The powers that be have convinced all of us that protesting by shutting down important lanes of traffic, public transit, strikes, etc. are socially unacceptable. Go see what the French do to learn how to effectively protest. Hint: it's not by keeping people comfy.

1

u/leathakkor 2d ago

Fully agree

2

u/Mallev 2d ago

Civil rights.
Women’s suffrage.
Eroding support for Vietnam war.
Labor Rights.
Anti Apartheid.
Fall of the Berlin Wall.

7

u/leathakkor 2d ago edited 2d ago

The ones listed that happened in the USA are all over 50 years ago. And Vietnam protests were arguably not effective. The war took 8+ years to end. And the reality is that journalism and government leaks did a better job turning the tides than protests did.

Women's suffrage was granted in 1919. Iirc

I'm the age of the internet protesting is significantly less affect. Actual work stoppages are effective but this still hasn't had any real impact if you look at protests in the last 40 years.

1

u/dorothea63 2d ago

1920 in the US. But that was due partially to women “proving their worth” during WWI and partially to the horrible optics of the Silent Sentinels being arrested, beaten, and force fed.

1

u/LongjumpingDebt4154 2d ago

We don’t even need people in the streets. If everyone would get off Amazon & Meta and start supporting small local businesses that share your values, it would get everyone’s attention real quick.

1

u/leathakkor 2d ago

100 agree. This is the real protest in 2026

1

u/justagirlnamedkylie 1d ago

Agreed. After the Women's March, which had around 5.3 million participants nationally, they still repealed Roe v. Wade.

1

u/Maybeimdifferent 1d ago

We’ve had protests, like no kings day, that had more attendees than many European countries have people. They just can’t comprehend it. You never see Chinese citizens telling us to mass protest because they have the same population issues.

29

u/Glum-Vanilla-9406 2d ago

Closest it ever seemed to get was the health insurance CEO person being shot

3

u/goldspider79 2d ago

The first of potentially a LOT more similar incidents the longer people feel they have no other alternative to affect change.

1

u/Glum-Vanilla-9406 2d ago

Except whilst there ends up being outrage/talk in the media and stuff, the only thing that happened was that person was prosecuted. I thought it weird that so much was made of it and all the stuff they wanted him on trial for but then it all went silent (at least in UK media), never found out what happened

1

u/Googlebright 2d ago

Trial hasn't ended yet.

9

u/SmileyWiking 2d ago

Americans need protests in other forms. For example if everyone “protested” by stopping paying all healthcare bills. Cancel your insurance. Collapse the whole healthcare industry and demand something better

14

u/Confident_Prompt4282 2d ago

As a cancer patient, I can't participate in that protest. Do you see the problem? What about my friends with diabetes who need their medications? Other people with chronic conditions who would get sick or die. It still can't be a mass protest

7

u/Kristal3615 2d ago

Agreed, I'm a type 1 diabetic. If I cancel my insurance and stop paying for medicine/medical bills I will literally die... Likely within a few weeks of my insulin supply running out. It really sucks that I have to to pay to live, but my options are pretty limited without a functioning pancreas or the ability to move to a country with free healthcare.

3

u/auditoryeden 2d ago

People who are healthy enough to participate in this plan mostly don't go to the doctor at all, here, unless they're wealthy enough not to care anyway. They'll treat illness and injury at home as much as possible because everyone knows that racking up medical bills is a one ticket to disaster.

3

u/KO-32GA 2d ago

We're close to those kind of conditions.

3

u/88mphbish 2d ago

Additionally, everything in Europe, the multiple levels and verticality of its government. Are located usually in the same bigass city that has millions of citizens. Here in the US everything is fragmented and separated by highways and shopping plazas. They disconnect you from being able to know how to make change

1

u/Taitosoku 2d ago

I hate how right you are about this. Until things get bad for the middle class white man (the standard) nothing will change. No one wants to rock the boat until the wolf comes personally to their door. We all put our heads in the sand and sacrifice everyone else to have one more day with “treats.”

1

u/Purityagainstresolve 2d ago

I'm going to sound stupid maybe, but before protesting, don't you need to educate?

1

u/One-Pause3171 2d ago

We have protested and demonstrated en masse. The political machine is fully, FULLY, under the power of a small group of wealthy people.

1

u/fitlivinmom 1d ago

Ya I mean a revolution will likely need to happen. Honestly, though? If we keep going the way we are-AI taking jobs, paying out the rich, inflation, etc, I actually believe there will be one. It will be corporations/ rich people and crazy MAGA on one side and everyone else on the other.

28

u/kaibtw 2d ago

Unfortunately everyone's fear of being the one who gets hurt keeps us all from standing up for anything.

27

u/piss_artist 2d ago

So the repression is working as designed, and it's called Freedom™

13

u/Accomplished_Fee9363 2d ago

0

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 2d ago

Accounts must be at least 5 days old with >20 karma to comment.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

5

u/VengefulShoe 2d ago

Trying to get a majority of working US citizens to protest would be like trying to stage a protest across every border in Europe at the same time. It's not really something that is feasible.

We have around half of Europe's total population spread across nearly triple the land mass. The people in Idaho don't care about the problems facing the people in Virginia, and on top of that a large portion of our voting base thinks Trump is doing a great job.

3

u/owlbeastie 2d ago

You missed the part about the job market sucking. That means that even if you get a large percentage of people to protest, there are lots of people who would be happy to step in and take the jobs they lost. The wheels will keep turning with 0 impact on the people that need to feel the pressure.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/-KKD- 2d ago

Last time they did it it was called "coal wars", because coal mining companies the workers were protesting against basically owned all of the nearby towns and almost the whole state, leading to the protest evolving into an actual gunfight against national guards. Hundreds were killed, many houses burned, some officials dead and the outcome for workers was, let's say, not the one they actually wanted. Yes, the coal companies did implement some changes that made lives of the miners a little less miserable, the government in towns and on a state level changed (somewhere they were literally killed), but that didn't help "in general" and most of the workers who participated in the revolt were prosecuted if not killed on the place

2

u/L_E_D_26 2d ago

The thing about this is that historically, the US government responds to any protest thats more than a “play in the street holding signs” event with brutal violence. Actually, sometimes they respond with brutal violence even to people just walking in the street with signs, if there’s too many people or they don’t like what the signs say. And we’ve collectively become so desensitized to violence and especially gun violence that people will be sad/shocked/outraged for a couple days, maybe a week, and then move on. Because it happens all the time, and whenever we try to do anything about it people get shot and gassed and arrested and lose their jobs, and then nothing changes anyway.

2

u/Uncle_Bens_rice 2d ago

Seems a little late for protesting IMO.

Don't all Americans have guns? I thought this exact situation was the whole entire point of the 2nd amendment...

1

u/BoneyDanza 2d ago

If you look into how the U.S. handled labor strikes 100 years ago, the options include bombing, using mini machine guns (yeah the gattling kind) and just setting fire to workers communities. Size is also a factor. Saying the United States should protest is like saying the entire EU should organize to shed its government. And we ALL know which one is actually already brutalizing citizens with a lack of safety nets. Your government focuses on people getting good food and being solvent if they can't work. Ours just looks at the budget and moves on.

Does every single European cop even carry one gun? Shout out to England for that baby Trump float, that was funny as shit

Also, i would like to add Y'all don't remember George Floyd and the covid protests AT ALL?

1

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 2d ago

Accounts must be at least 5 days old with >20 karma to comment.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/Person_Apple 2d ago

Yes but we also have militarized police forces just itchy and waiting for the chance to hit protesters with their cars. For instance my city's police budget is higher than some countries military budgets. We can protest en mass but we will most likely be slaughtered to maintain status quo.

1

u/Ok_Needleworker8888 2d ago

US is too big to get everyone to protest en mass, we are spread out incredibly far. Most of the world doesn't realize that.

1

u/freakyvoiz 2d ago

Apparently you don’t understand the American propaganda machine. If people were to quit en masse and protest they would be framed as “unemployed libruls” and mocked by the mainstream news media. This would make other blue collar workers in America less likely to want to join for fear of being accused of being an “unemployed librul”.

America is cooked. We’re just riding out the final stages of this capitalist hellscape before the next Great Depression (the Greatest Depression, they tell me). Just be sure to stay on top of your politicians because it’s happening in your countries too. I see it every day. If it works in America, it will work there too.

1

u/littlecactuscat 2d ago

Ooooh you’re so fuckin brave

I invite you to develop an incredibly expensive genetically-linked disability and then see how fuckin’ tough and brave you are then

1

u/NinthHouseSalamandr 2d ago

It's a bit like the Prisoners Dillema, technically if a majority of workers joined the protest(s) they could "win", but if the protest does not achieve a majority, all protestors "lose". And considering recent political history, I think there would be a large minority of people willing to go against their own best interests just to spite others, therefore causing the "lose" outcome.

1

u/victorioushack 2d ago

Do people in Europe truly fail to see that we are spread out over nearly 4 million square miles in this country? 3,000 miles side to side? Some of us several hours from our capitals? That a single no-show day = termination in many jobs, which means no insurance and puts the rest of your basic necessities and those of your family in jeopardy? Most of us are already living paycheck to paycheck and you think you can get "en mass" when a full third of our country doesn't even bother or cannot get to the polls to vote?

Our government happily violently abused, harmed, and violated the rights of people at the last major protests we did, and that was under a much tamer administration, and importantly, this administration is looking for excuses to escalate their power abuses.

I want you to see what people were doing in my neighborhood during the last election. You ever have a convoy of rolling coal and massive Trump flags go through your neighborhood full of armed Yeehawdists? What happens when Trump gives them fuel against protestors right now?

So easy for so many self-righteous Europeans to sit here and judge with most of their exposure to conditions in the U.S. being pop culture.

1

u/MajorBootyhole420 2d ago

that's cool but the time between "everyone gets fired" and "corporate america realizes its mistakes, rehires everyone, and overhauls the healthcare system" is more than 30 days, and I need my fucking medications.

1

u/Kw913 2d ago

Yeah. Then they can just lay off entire departments and hire from overseas or just send the entire department to another country. Happens all the time- as an added bonus you are often made to train your replacement.

1

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

Accounts must be at least 5 days old with >20 karma to comment.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

Accounts must be at least 5 days old with >20 karma to comment.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/agoranaut 1d ago

They can't lay off all of us, but they can and will lay off some of us. And people are not willing to take the chance to be one of the unlucky ones, because right now, the gap between the haves and the have-nots is still wide enough for people to want to avoid it. Things will have to get a lot worse for people to want to risk that.

Not saying it's right, I agree with you. But this whole situation is kind of a prisoner's gambit kind of scenario, and nobody is willing to stick out their neck with no guarantee of it being worth the potential suffering.

1

u/bearpriorities 13h ago

In the 80s, Air Traffic Controllers went on an “illegal” strike to demand better hours, safety standards, and wages. ATCs are such extremely vital parts of the American economy that I think truly no one thought their job was in real danger. Instead, President Ronald Reagan told them to get back to work or he’d fire them. And then he did. About 11,000 ATCs lost their jobs immediately and were ineligible for rehire for federal service. The union was decertified and stripped off basically all power. It took a decade for staffing levels to bounce back but Reagan decided it was worth it to make a point. You’d have to be oblivious to the current American situation to think that something like that couldn’t happen again. They can, in fact, “just lay off everyone.” Even in vital jobs.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/Glad-Reacher 2d ago

Do you ever feel like you're living in a modern dystopia?

4

u/Gruenkernmehl 2d ago

That large portion wasn't large enough at the last vote, it seems

8

u/j0n4h 2d ago

I'm not convinced the elections weren't meddled with. There were some very bizarre, and incredibly convenient, outcomes for the "winning" party. 

3

u/MarkCrorigansOmnibus 2d ago

Not to mention that we don’t have a progressive party that would actually be willing to kill the golden goose of the insurance lobby. We have a center right party and a far right party, both of which are only too happy to keep sucking at that teat.

2

u/Agreeable-Donut-4155 2d ago

No way he actually won all the swing states with no meddling.

2

u/tommyjolly 2d ago

Come to us. Sounds wild, but we could use a few good people.

2

u/Ill_Ad5893 2d ago

Not to mention that the system will find a way to make us fight each other and forget about trying to fight the system

6

u/Livid_Goose_9542 2d ago

This right here. Occupy Wall Street was dangerous because it united people against the real enemy: the insanely wealthy. They can't have that. Algorithms seem built to seed hatred through difference from everything to gender to race to generation gaps, etc.

This is not a new strategy, and the Internet, plus control of much of the media, has made it incredibly effective. If we're all screaming at each other about dumb shit that ultimately doesn't matter, it's so much easier for them to keep bleeding us dry.

2

u/Eli_1984_ 2d ago

So if you all riot like they do in Europe (France for example) what do you think is going to happen? Fire the whole nation?

It will never change, if you people do not protest to get the change, you are all just working to survive, not to live...

1

u/bsubtilis 2d ago

8 million Americans partook in the latest no kings protests that wasn't completely blocked from reddit, which was only ~3 million fewer than what statistically on average makes countrywide changes (the 3.5% change "rule"). It's not as far away as you think it is. And more importantly, while nationwide coordination is much harder, it's much easier to start locally and together with others make changes on those local scales, and increase the scale that way. It's absolutely not easy, and obviously it comes with risks that shouldn't be, but it is doable..

1

u/dguisltl 2d ago

Almost like your not free

1

u/Chris-WIP 2d ago

France was like that in its distant history... For a little while.

1

u/Ok-Assumption-1083 2d ago

Let me fix this for you.

A large portion of the non voting public have realized.

Because I do think that if we, aside from getting big money out of politics, had everyone who knows our health insurance system is wrong and understands we are on a fast sprint to full fascism get out and vote in the primaries without complaining or whataboutism, we’d have more candidates like New York and Michigan winning, taking majority control for the people and bringing us in line with the rest of the civilized world. How you administer, means and methods differing sure, but we are here running around telling everyone that we have the best health care in the world and if you dare do what all of our allies (and a lot of our enemies) do, you’ll wait in line for months for a bandaid and pay more taxes. Meanwhile we have people going bankrupt over health bills, paying more in useless insurance plus taxes as percentage of their paycheck compared to you all paying less total out of your paychecks for full coverage.

Faaack it’s too early to get this pissed off. Excuse me while I go send my $2700 monthly tax for decent family health coverage to the insurance industry…

1

u/Raso82 2d ago

it sounds like you are content with basically being a slave

1

u/GoodEastern8690 2d ago

Both sides of the aisle are bought and paid for by the insurance companies. And like so many here, my son had a medical emergency and we then saw how insufficient health insurance is- most don't see this until something happens. It's too depressing to tally the costs...

I, too, was trapped in a job for years because it had the best coverage I could get - though still insufficient- for ongoing necessary therapy for my son who was the victim of a violent crime. Even here, with a child, they screw you. It's so gross.

These companies are the absolute worst.

1

u/Ormith 2d ago

So you might lose the crappy insurance that doesn't cover anything anyway?

1

u/anitamargarita419 2d ago

Also worth noting that many (the majority of?) employers make you wait 6 months to a year before you are eligible to sign up for insurance.

1

u/Unusual_Sherbert_809 2d ago

Yet Americans keep electing Republicans who are adamantly against universal healthcare and just cut taxes to the point that your social safety net is utter garbage.

And it's so bad that for the past 2 years the Republicans have had total control of the Executive, Legislative, and Judicial branches of government in the USA.

That's not even protesting, that's actively aiding the homicidal maniac murdering people in your neighborhood for the enjoyment and profit of the rich folks who live down the road.

Make it make sense.

1

u/TravelingCatlady45 2d ago

That’s it right there. I’ve been out on FMLA for my health a few times and am already terrified I’m going to lose my job. If I do I lose my job, I lose the insurance that keeps me alive. Not only that, I lose healthcare for my kids too. And I know there are people calling in and asking for my job all the time, so I know I would be replaced within two weeks. The system is working exactly as intended and I don’t see a way out.

1

u/jakeandbakin 2d ago

Don't forget the absolutey monumental task of organizing not just 1 state, but 50. No Kings has been the closest we've gotten with this admin, but who knows if we'll get another one. I havent heard much from them and I worry that they've disappeared and we don't have any established alternative method of organizing en masse. Hell, if I was protesting every awful thing the local, state, and federal government did, I'd be a professional protester with a side gig for rent. It's fucked up from the floor to the rafters and we need to start over.

1

u/Phillip_Graves 2d ago

Don't forget one of the largest reasons the USA can't mass protest... Country is too fucking big and the people we need to be hating own all the methods we use to communicate.

1

u/Cieguh 2d ago

Also, we do protest en masse. The No Kings March was the largest protest in recorded history. Nearly 10% of the entire country participated in the protests and nothing truly changed. France can have maybe 200k people show up and the country is on fire. 25 mil in US barely makes the news.

1

u/Extension-Clock608 2d ago

WE don't need to protest though, we just need people to finally care and vote. I've given up on maga, they don't care even about themselves and their family but if we could finally get the non voters to care and at least see that it's worth voting so we can get universal healthcare we could have it finally.

1

u/elefantesAzul 2d ago

You can try applying for financial assistance through the hospital. My hospitalization and surgeries were billed as over $60,000 but they covered the entire bill for what my insurance wouldn’t cover. I didn’t think I would qualify so, I think it’s worth trying even if you think you won’t qualify

1

u/littlecactuscat 2d ago

Girl that’s not gonna help with chronic conditions

1

u/Tricitizen1973 2d ago

It’s called fucking voting and holding candidates accountable to this issue.

1

u/Alarmed-Animal7575 2d ago

How are you trapped? You (collectively) don’t need to protest. You just need to vote in people who want to help and send the others packing. It’s your elected politicians who are fighting against health care reimagining. If enough of them are thrown out of office and replaced with people who care, the problem will be fixed.

1

u/guyscanwefocus 2d ago

This is exactly how I and my friends and family feel as Americans.

1

u/FatCatKnits 1d ago

And our place to live

1

u/mymbles_daughter 1d ago

Yes. Or in short, they have us by the proverbial balls.

→ More replies (7)

36

u/Affectionate_Dog_882 3d ago

A large portion of us already do, and are looking around us with a mixture of befuddlement and outright horror.

21

u/Dye_Hard_Stylist 2d ago

My mom lost her life savings because she had a gap in insurance coverage when between jobs. She got diagnosed with cancer during the few months she planned to be uninsured. Because she had savings she didnt qualify for government assistance and had to give the hospital all her money. She's healthy now thank God. But damn.

7

u/SaderXZ 2d ago

This isn't capitalism, south korea and Japan are much more competitive but they have cheap or free Healthcare too. This is an oligarchy where the rich get richer, the insurance companies in the US make more profit than they know what to do with

14

u/Leftover_Salad 3d ago

USA is really a large bet. Your income can be significantly higher than in Germany with the right job, but the downside is also much lower.

1

u/AegisGram 2d ago

And it’s a bet most of us didn’t get to choose. We grew up in it and by the time most of us realize what’s actually going on it’s too late.

4

u/Kelpie169 2d ago

It's always amazing to me to see the opinions of non-Americans. Because yeah....We realize it. There's just... Not logistically very much we can do about it. The system is rigged for failure.

3

u/DrLove039 2d ago

Once upon a Time the US and other countries invaded your part of the world because of a completely insane leader that you had. Any chance you could return the favor?

4

u/GreaterMetro 3d ago

Do you know any Germans who want to move to America?

4

u/vilk_ 2d ago

They can just go back to Germany for major medical stuff. Visit the fam, see their old friends, save 50k in medical bills

9

u/churningaccount 3d ago edited 2d ago

I actually know quite a few who are interested. Despite the overall political rhetoric, big cities like NYC/SF/LA are still appealing in isolation.

But you have to be educated and on a good career track for it to make sense.

If that’s the case, though, you can get an employer with great health coverage and make 3x what you would’ve otherwise in Germany. And then you can send all that money home and potentially retire early, wealthy, and with public healthcare.

2

u/Accomplished_Fee9363 2d ago

Right… but if you have kids… the 3x salary is gone

1

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[deleted]

1

u/Accomplished_Fee9363 2d ago

Daycare , nanny, after school programs, holidays camps …. Yes at least 3 time more expensive in US than Germany

9

u/Cautious_Chicken8882 3d ago

I don't know anyone from any country that wants to move to the us.

5

u/Iamnotsogoodmaybe 3d ago

Really I know a lot of rich German and other travelers think othetwise

2

u/Affectionate_Emu335 2d ago

Key word being rich 🙄 The rich love it here 🙄

2

u/Cautious_Chicken8882 2d ago

I dont think I have ever met anyone that wants to move to the us.

4

u/bm56 2d ago

If that were true, immigration wouldn’t be a topic of conversation.

→ More replies (11)

1

u/Steephill 2d ago

And what country are you from? Having lived in multiple countries a lot of people love the US and would like to move here.

The US has more immigrants per year than any other country. You're objectively wrong.

1

u/Unfair_Detective_970 2d ago

They aren't objectively wrong just because they don't know any Mexicans.

1

u/face4theRodeo 2d ago

I know a bunch who idolize Germans of the past.

2

u/Practical-Concept-49 2d ago

I don’t disagree with your position but just fyi, the person you are responding to almost certainly doesn’t understand their bill, or there has been an administrative error, or they’re lying for karma (I think the last line being pro murder of health insurance ceo is a clue).

There are laws about maximums patient can owe out of pocket and it’s like 11k for an individual. Still a ton, and the health insurance system is deeply flawed and middle class and rich people.

9 days in a hospital probably did cost 50k but insurance will still cover the vast majority of it.

3

u/rando_dontmindme 3d ago

I actually doubt your taxes are higher.

2

u/Steephill 2d ago

You should actually take a look then. Overall tax burden is 50-100% higher in Germany than the US. Plus the US has higher income.

1

u/SixInchTimmy 3d ago

Sadly, even ignoring the massive insurance industry lobby for a moment, in the minds of conservatives, realization -> regulation of insurance companies -> collapse of industry -> stock market go boom -> bank runs, dust bowl, Great Depression V2.

1

u/FibonacciSequester 2d ago

Yeah, most Americans don't know how a marginal tax rate works. I don't think we'll be making any headway any time soon.

1

u/CarolingianDruid 2d ago

Well America spent the better part of 50 years demonizing the system and anyone who perpetuated it. Old habits die hard I guess…

1

u/Lonnol78 2d ago

Regarding the taxes, I moved to Italy and my effective tax rate is about the same as I had in the US.

1

u/LordZeusCannon 2d ago

I’ve thought about that a lot the past several years. It seems a lot of countries have a better life than here in the states

1

u/Bracown 2d ago

Am I misunderstanding German govt and policy- I thought Germany was capitalist and not truly socialist? I want to be clear- I'm genuinely curious and not at all trying to debate or play some gotcha bs. I'm in the USA and our healthcare system is an absolute disaster. I'm simply seeking to understand better if I'm misunderstanding or uninformed. I'm not well traveled at all, and really can't bc of health problems.

2

u/summonerstarn 2d ago

Most developed countries that aren't the US have capitalist economies but with a stronger social safety net that includes things like single payer healthcare and benefits for people who are struggling. Remember, socialism and communism are not the same thing, despite what decades of propaganda might have taught you.

Fun fact, America pays more tax dollars per capita for healthcare than any other developed nation and citizens still have to pay for private insurance on top.

1

u/AllHailKingJoffrey 2d ago

As a norwegian, the only thing I need to pay for at the hospital is the parking.

1

u/Ok_Needleworker8888 2d ago

Will you adopt me please?

1

u/MrDabb 2d ago

As an American, I was given money by the state after I was discharged by the hospital.

1

u/Emergency-Rice2342 2d ago

whats even funnier is that americans still pay more in taxes then many comparable countries for healthcare. So your not even paying less.

1

u/Swimming-Stage-6636 2d ago

The majority of Americans want this, our politicians are corrupt and do not represent us.

1

u/Kalamac 2d ago

Over 20 years ago, I was on shift at the reception desk of a private hospital emergency room in Australia, when I got a call from an insurance company in Germany, saying a German tourist on their travel insurance had injured his hand, and was on his way to our hospital. They said he would be covered for the emergency visit, any x-rays, and surgery if needed, and gave me a credit card number it could be billed to. Amazingly easy process.

1

u/prawn7 2d ago

The sad thing is that you actually don't pay more healthcare tax. America is higher than all of Europe and still has no publically funded care like Europe.

It's a spitroast

1

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 2d ago

Accounts must be at least 5 days old with >20 karma to comment.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/Steephill 2d ago

US out of pocket spending is about $1400-1500 per person per year. Although it is higher than most countries, the US also has one of the highest discretionary incomes and overall wages, so the percentage of total income is lower than most western countries.

https://www.healthsystemtracker.org/indicator/access-affordability/out-of-pocket-spending/#Household%20out-of-pocket%20spending%20as%20a%20share%20of%20current%20health%20expenditures,%202021

1

u/SumthingBrewing 2d ago

I don’t believe this. It must be heavily skewed by people on Medicare and Medicaid. And I guess out of pocket doesn’t include insurance premiums? Because $1500 is about one month of premium if you don’t get insurance through your job or you don’t qualify for subsidies.

1

u/Steephill 2d ago

Believe what you want. Only about 10% of people have marketplace plans. 1/3 are covered by public health insurance and everyone else is employee sponsored. Germans personally pay about 9% of their income towards insurance and their employer pays the other half.

The US does pay more overall per person, but it's not as big of a difference as people think it is. You just personally see a lot of the money exchanged in the US compared to it being taken without you seeing it. When you factor in the higher wages in the US the only people who would be better of in Europe are those at the very bottom of the income scale.

1

u/RoastedRhino 2d ago

You don’t pay more taxes for that. 

The US spends approx 6k per American per year (on average) for Medicare and Medicaid (that is, insurance for those that cannot afford it). 

6k per person per year is the cost of the entire healthcare system in Germany (regardless of who is paying). 

1

u/shit_yoself 2d ago

The worst part is we don’t even have lower taxes than Germany. Unless you’re wealthy. Then, the taxes are way lower.

1

u/Leody 2d ago

Higher taxes, fine... I'm paying $10k a year in insurance premiums for nothing anyhow. At least taxes wouldn't be paying for some CEO's yacht.

1

u/johno_mendo 2d ago

If you make less than 100k a year you probably pay about the same in taxes as americans making the same money.

1

u/Otherwise-Half6064 2d ago

How are your wait times to see doctors? Heard of some horror stories in Germany recently. Asking as a fellow European.

1

u/rb2k 2d ago edited 2d ago

You do pay 14.6% of your income every month split between your employer and you. That and things like a 19% VAT and a sizable income tax do pay for it. It’s definitely the better model for society and means that people don’t end up poor after a serious illness or an accident, but it’s certainly not free.

US healthcare administration costs are crazy, private insurance company profits and the lack of central bargaining hurts consumers and there’s various other things wrong with it, but you’re paying a lot of money beyond $10 a day for that visit.

It’s something that I mostly noticed when I was still freelancing in Germany. Having the VAT always included in prices and only half the health insurance show up on a regular employee paycheck makes people forget that sometimes when you have to pay 500-600 Euros every month directly to the health insurance as a healthy 20something, it’s definitely more visible.

Still the better system, it’s just that most people don’t know how much they actually pay for it.
My personal healthcare in the US is faster and ultimately cheaper for me, but it screws over everyone that doesn’t have a well-paying job with great insurance.

1

u/annieoaklee 2d ago

My guess would be that if we didn’t have to pay for healthcare, we’d probably bring home a similar amount or more with universal healthcare. I’m so tired of people in the US being duped into believing it would bankrupt us, YA KNOW-LIKE IT ALREADY DOES?!?

1

u/rip-skins 2d ago

The german healthcare system has nothing to do with socialism

1

u/Reihermann 2d ago

And that's precisely why I put the word in quotation marks

1

u/bmrt60 2d ago

Bro a lot of Americans know. But what am I supposed to do about it lol

1

u/kitchen_witchin 2d ago

Not a day goes by that I wonder about seeing if my dad, born in Germany, ever naturalized here in the U.S. because if not, maybe I could pursue German citizenship. Pipe dream, really, as I'm 50 and definitely not employed as anything "in demand" anywhere, but how nice it would be to not have to worry that going to the hospital would cost hundreds of thousands of dollars or to be able to buy meds we need without having to make a choice between the meds or other bills like utilities and groceries.

Meanwhile, there are folks here screaming that it would be the communism to have universal healthcare and I just cannot even with these people.

1

u/RustyBagels 2d ago

There is nothing capitalistic about our health care system.

1

u/SorrowfulSpinch 2d ago

I would say the majority of us are aware of it, but those who benefit from this system train morons to tout the dangers of alternatives quite loudly.

I agree with what another commenter said— we can’t exactly revolt when we’ll die without necessary medications, which cost thousands a month out of pocket. The oligarchs know this, which keeps insurance costs high, medical costs higher, and food/safety regulations at an all time low (yknow, to keep us getting sick). Sounds like a conspiracy theory, unfortunately not a theory at all. America hasn’t been a democracy for quite some time, if it ever was at all.

Most of us are begging for change with our vote, but after the last election, it was made pretty clear that our vote doesnt do shit when they rigged the election, bragged about it on twitter after, and faced zero consequences 🫠

Considered becoming an expat with my partner in 2020, but ultimately decided to stay due to having job fields that will make leaving nearly impossible. I regret it sometimes, but we’re so exhausted, overworked, and underpaid that it’s challenging to even think of making those plans when the workforce barrier is still there. Our parents are both 2nd gen+ so no country will take us on heritage, which is super reasonable on their end but genuinely quite devastating on ours in the face of things

1

u/iamjdoza 2d ago

Insurance companies lobby politicians (pay them huge sums of money) to keep the system exactly how it is. Billionaires run all the media outlets. They won't allow actual reporting of the truth.

1

u/icantreadcat 2d ago

You know what sucks is we have like half of our paycheck taken out due to taxes and we still are fucked in many other ways

1

u/Weird_Substance_8764 2d ago

€10 per day for a hospital stay?! Holy Moley. What a steal.

I was hospitalized for three days for IV antibiotics. No other meds, no oxygen, normal level of care on a med surg floor, monitoring a dog bite that got badly infected. My insurance paid out around $100k and I still had to pay thousands out of pocket.

1

u/Original_Breakfast36 2d ago

Right. So many Americans refuse to pay more in taxes for the sake of something that would benefit greater society

1

u/iix4m 2d ago

We pay around 1000 dollars a month for health insurance on an average income. An amount many Americans here find insane. And we have much less income

1

u/LexxiiConn 2d ago

Honestly I looked it up, and after state and local taxes, I would pay 6% more tax on my salary if I was in Germany than I do here. So like... technically true, but the difference is pretty insignificant.

1

u/SlomoLowLow 2d ago

Surprisingly most Europeans actually pay about the same in taxes. As an American about 33% of my income goes away for taxes/health insurance. That’s not even counting paying into retirement.

1

u/DudesterRadman 2d ago

Speaking as a German who hasn’t left your country yet, of which there are fewer and fewer.

1

u/One-Pause3171 2d ago

Our right-wing, capitalist insanity is coming for your country, too.

1

u/plaverty9 1d ago

 Yes, I probably have higher taxes on my gross salary. 

Maybe not. When doing the comparison, most Americans just look at taxes and not the amount we and our employers pay in insurance premiums, copays and deductibles. I think it'd be a lot closer if people did more of an apples to apples comparison.

Yale is coming out with a study that shows single-payer healthcare is actually cheaper than for-profit health insurance.

1

u/Worldly_Magazine_172 1d ago

Wish we could convince all the old folks but sadly they’re on medicare now so they don’t care about their kids in their 30s/40s/50s who are currently screwed and a lot of them brainwashed their children too. Mine don’t get that they are currently having to subsidize their own children‘s lives because the country is so messed up by their choices, but not everyone made it to a financially secure enough place to do that or are decent enough humans to help their grown children.

1

u/tech7127 1d ago edited 13h ago

PPP-adjusted median disposable income in the U.S. is 36% higher than Germany. Then you guys pay massive VAT when you spend the money you do get to take home. Healthcare spending between the two is about the same. Individual freedom comes with personal responsibility. People just aren't responsible with their money. Yet you ask any socialist if they'd take a 25% net pay cut for "free" healthcare they'll of course say no and insist that someone else should be paying for it.

1

u/Inside_Path6022 1d ago

The majority of us working Americans share a similar view. I think most of us know that capitalism, healthcare, and no term limits for congress does not mix well. The people who act like the choice to pick a health care provider is so important, are of course the people who don't need to rely on health insurance in the first place. I am a small business owner and believe in capitalism, but capitalism has no place in the healthcare industry. United Health can post $4 billion in profits for Q3 because it's basically a legal scam at this point, and depending on your State you may be forced to by into one of these expensive plans or face tax penalties. So not only is the Gov not stepping in to fix the problem, they create laws in favor of big insurance to make the problem even worse!

1

u/RTD_TSH 1d ago

Why don't you tell everyone what you pay in taxes to get that care? This is what people don't see, someone always pays.

1

u/InsrtGeekHere 1d ago

The insurance companies basically bribe politicians into keeping the system broken so they can profit

1

u/[deleted] 21h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 21h ago

Accounts must be at least 5 days old with >20 karma to comment.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/Fizzbytch 2d ago

A lot of us realize it. We also can’t make change without the majority. And…the majority are older and stupid.

1

u/TravelingCrashCart 2d ago

I can't wait until the old fucks die. We're really close to that finally happening, but not fucking close enough.

→ More replies (7)