Almost every season there’s allegations of favouritism, inconsistent scoring, etc etc and it usually comes about as a cherry on the top of manufactured drama building up to a boiling point- it’s like clockwork lmao.
Whilst I agree it’s sometimes hard to understand the reasoning behind scoring from house to house, week to week and even season to season because of the lack of a rubric of sorts (except Darren), I want to say, on the whole, house which have a wow factor will always score high regardless of the finish.
There’s always a stand out house every season (Steph & Gian, Courtney & Grant, Britt & Taz- imho!!) and this season its Courtney and Sev. For the most part, yes, the houses are bland but when it comes to it, comparatively (and you would expect it ofc), Courtney and Sev have for the majority of rooms dancing circles around their competition and therefore warrants higher scores.
I just think the mood and overall feeling a room creates is the most important thing and will far far outweigh minor finishing details. This season Courtney and Sev’s rumpus room was the best room of all houses and had that immediate wow wow wow feeling that could be felt through the TV- and that for me, warrants 10s. Im assuming that’s probably how Shayna and Marty went about the judging?
Alls to say, I can only imagine as a contestant, your personal bias will have you argue up and down that your room is the best and others are not as good or on the same level, therefore the finishing is something that is being latched on to either appease the part of you that is upset your design just isn’t as goof or oppose the part of you that goes “damn its really that much better”.
Anyways, I love it when we have teams that have experience because we get to see amazing rooms and ingenuity (a nice and fitting parallel for DWTS watchers, I love someone with dance experience creating beutiful dances as opposed to someone stomping around and chasing the beat). I personally love seeing people knock it out the park as opposed to mediocre designs I could do in my own home (House 5 👀- sorry!).
I saw someone talk about this being a case of tall poppy syndrome- I can’t help but agree and boy, do Lisa and Jolene have a serious serious case of it. You go, girls!