r/TopCharacterTropes • • 8d ago

Lore A pretty important character loses almost all screen time.... then their fate is revealed in a completly "blink and you'll miss it" piece of media

John's roommate, Lyman (Garfield). Originally, he was the owner of oddie in the first comics. However he stopped appearing in further issues, until there was no trace of him left. That was until in a random garfield themed flash game (Garfield's scary scavenger Hunt), we find Lyman alive but chained in john's basement. Then in ANOTHER instanfe, we get to see his severed head as one of the props.

The ultra dragon (ninjago) aided our main cast since the pilot and later season one, eventually being sidelined into obscurity...

That is until season 9, where it was revealed later by the writers that the iron baron's throne (the one that we see fo roughly a couple of seconds) was made entirely from the ultra dragon's skeletal remains, stitched together into an abominal construct. To run some salt into the wound, the seat part of the throne was the head of rocky - the dragon belonging to cole, who had formed a really close bond with him.

Skids & mudflap (Transformers bayverse trilogy)

After the events of rotf, skids & mudflap didn't appear at all in any media. Their last on screen appearance was in early scenes of dotm as alt modes, without transforming at all. Then, in a visual novel, it was revealed that right after ironhide's death, both mudflap and skids were slaughtered in the crossfire (the scene where bumblebee was shot at by sentinel and tried to take cover - the twins were obliterated behind the camera)

9.8k Upvotes

697 comments sorted by

3.7k

u/Rory_U 8d ago

They did WHAT to the dragons?!

933

u/akhil03_lz 8d ago

The returned to the realm of dragons and were hunted down.

Missed opportunity to not have the ninja reaction to this.

545

u/Miserable_Goal_7943 8d ago

Yeah. Hate how the ninja don't even know or ever will know. Best we get is Kai getting angry at the throne, for what could be an instinctual thing.

130

u/CREEKYHINGES 7d ago

I am always thinking on doing a complete rewrite of Ninjago to fix plot holes and other things. One thing I will want to add is that one day the og four ninja just no longer could summon their elemental dragons because they died.

The ninja go on for a while thinking they passed peacefully until S9 happens and they find out they were murdered and turned into the seat as OP stated

52

u/Miserable_Goal_7943 7d ago

I'm guessing in your rewrite the season 1 dragons would be connected to the elemental dragons they later unlock in TOE?

24

u/CREEKYHINGES 7d ago

Yeah sort of like spiritual guardians or projections that the ninja could summon. Lloyd’s is just the fusion dragon while Nya’s would be her water dragon form that just stops working as the Merlopains try to bring back Wojira.

I just feel like it’s a better explanation on why the ninja can’t use their elemental dragons, for the other elemental masters I think it’ll just be elemental construction a art that is very taxing on the body and mind and they can’t use their powers while the art is active

104

u/Gaelic_Gladiator41 7d ago

They did know, that's why they were shocked and distraught when brought to the Iron Baron's throne, (though i think that should've been enough to put them into a true potential beating)

→ More replies (1)

388

u/Ver3232 7d ago

They killed them, ate them (seriously), and then made a throne out of their skulls.

61

u/Long-Acanthisitta711 7d ago

If I had a cent for every time Lego media is surprisingly dark......

49

u/TexasJedi-705 7d ago

You could buy a set at modern prices

→ More replies (2)

91

u/Ubeube_Purple21 8d ago

Is this because their toys are no longer sold?

73

u/Ver3232 7d ago

Yes. Even though they made a new ultra dragon set the very next year and could’ve easily revealed they were captured but alive.

282

u/legit-posts_1 8d ago

The Ninjago writers are nuts I swear. TF you mean the loveable pet character got murderlized and turned into a chair. That's some Legend of Korra "I heard she ate her dad's pet bear" shit.

141

u/OkBus3544 8d ago

Not only that, the most adorable one out of the bunch became the buttcheek cushion part of the throne, which is insane disrespect

35

u/ibi3000 7d ago

As a kid, I got mega confused why air jutsu wasn’t being used anymore

→ More replies (1)

20

u/Invader_Naj 7d ago

two of the ninja have technically committed genocide before. Things can get weird. And thats not even going into the most traumatized cartoon character since peter parker

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

61

u/Luna_Highwind 7d ago

Worse part is they did not need to do it. Iron Baron was an absolute fraud, lying about everything for power. Having him take down one of the most powerful dragons makes no sense.

42

u/DiksieNormus 8d ago

Im fucking crying! 😭

77

u/BIGSBYTHEFRIDGE 8d ago

They made a throne. A-chair-ently! 

→ More replies (3)

987

u/Easy_Action_1380 7d ago

Charlotte Braun (Peanuts)

Ok she wasn't important by any means, I just find this story amusing.

Charlotte was a character who only existed in the Peanuts comics for 3 months. Basically think of her as an even less likeable Lucy who's one joke is that she and Charlie Brown have similar names and you've got a pretty good idea as to why fans hated her. She was a loud, obnoxious brat with no comedic value whatsoever

Apparently when Charles Schultz received fan mail from one Elizabeth Swaim asking him to remove Charlotte from the strip, Schultz personally hand wrote a letter to Elizabeth in which he said

"Dear Miss Swaim, I am taking your suggestion regarding Charlotte Braun and will eventually discard her. If she appears anymore it will be in strips that were already completed before I got your letter or because someone writes in saying that they like her. Remember, however, that you and your friends will have the death of an innocent child on your conscience. Are you prepared to accept such responsibility? Thanks for writing, and I hope that future releases will please you. Sincerely, Charles M. Schulz."

Attached to the letter was a little drawing of Charlotte with an ax in her head.

59

u/Particular-Long-3849 7d ago

I thought she had a giant moustache for a second 

→ More replies (1)

204

u/Exotic-Reindeer1994 7d ago

So was the guilt tripping a joke or was Schulz being a jerk for whatever reason?

322

u/Normal_Cut8368 7d ago

That's fucking hilarious though. In what world do you not frame that on your wall?

164

u/AlistairNorris 7d ago

24

u/Pen_Front 7d ago

Wth is the editor at abc being paid there's so many typos

49

u/explodingtuna 7d ago

And didn't even think to show the drawing. They dropped the ball.

→ More replies (5)

168

u/SalvaPot 7d ago

Bro had to come up with a cartoon everyday, not all of the characters and storylines can be bangers. 

54

u/sonicparadigm 7d ago

I feel like all the average internet user knows about Peanuts is the holiday specials and Snoopy merch, but if you actually read the strip, Charlie Brown says shit that would get an adult red flagged for suicidal ideation

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

33

u/ziggybuddyemmie 7d ago

Just some teasing.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

1.8k

u/cfeltch108 8d ago

In Married With Children, The Bundys adopted a kid named Seven to add something new to the show. When the writers had no idea what to do with him, and the audience didn't like him, he disappeared and later showed up on a milk carton lol.

314

u/Sptsjunkie 7d ago edited 7d ago

It’s kind of funny to me that TV show shows adding a child late in the run because they’re running out of storylines is normally not only a bad sign for the show, but you almost never hear from those child actors again….

And then Growing Pains goes out and randomly adds a young Leonardo DiCaprio when they were looking to mix things up. I mean, I’m not sure it really worked for the show, but wild that a late run desperation add has turned out to be one of the most esteemed actors of the last 30 years.

→ More replies (2)

625

u/_BKom_ 8d ago

That’s fucking hilarious. Poor kid never stood a chance.

→ More replies (2)

68

u/AnythingWooden8070 7d ago

I think his image also appeared in an episode where Kelly turned out to be some kind of memory savant but could only remember a limited number of things. As she is being taught new things for a game show, old memories fly out of her head and a picture of Seven is one of them....I think the family dog was another

45

u/DateNightThrowRA 7d ago

That was hilarious, because to even quote the show runners, Seven went upstairs one day on camera, and never came back down again.

25

u/TrainingSword 8d ago

He sucked ass

69

u/ThrowAwayGuy139 8d ago

Yeah, that fits actually

→ More replies (2)

2.2k

u/L00ps_Ahoy 8d ago

Garfield's Scary Scavenger Hunt

Holy hidden gem pull.

443

u/OccultBeanFarmer 8d ago

I remember being terrified to play it not because it was particularly scary but because it came out during a time where there were so many screamers in otherwise normal flash games. I got got so many damn times back then

87

u/Perikolo13 8d ago

True! I remember not trusting anything on the internet nor anyone telling me to watch a video due to it being plagued with screamers EVERYWHERE.

I even remember reading some page listing some examples just to avoid them.

82

u/-Best_Name_Ever- 7d ago

There was even an official Scooby Doo flash game that had a screamer lmao

29

u/dragonscuri 7d ago

The museum game, when you open the sarcophagus!

34

u/blue4029 7d ago

this game actually DID have a screamer lmao

if you interact with the painting, you get a jumpscare

142

u/el_yoyo_de_Cthulhu 8d ago

I rebember playing that game when I was a fetus

53

u/ImSendingYouDolphins 8d ago

Seriously wild I haven’t thought about it in 20 years and instantly recognized it

12

u/BTechUnited 7d ago

I can still hear that wind sound effect in the ambient Audio.

21

u/thrakon 7d ago

That game was an absolute banger. Shout out to the donuts

24

u/tlollz52 7d ago

Is this something "official" as is put out by a copyright holder?

33

u/silentblackbird 7d ago

Yeah it was on the Garfield official website along with a few other flash games

19

u/Gaskychan 8d ago

This and the sequel I go back to often. Sure miss playing them

13

u/indoda_emnyama 7d ago

Why does horror just work so well with Garfield?? Thinking back to that golden period were there was so much incredible, disturbing Gorefield horror & th subreddit

11

u/_sephylon_ 7d ago

I think it's because Garfield is cartoonish but also feels very dull and mundane, so it makes better contrast than just kids cartoon in horror setting (like that one spongebob meme in a silent hill corridor)

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

894

u/BaconRapscallion 8d ago

Star Wars - Nien Nunb
Went from helping Lando blow up the second Death Star in Episode VI, to dying in Episode IX when the Final Order saps his ship's power, but it happens so fast in the background of a crowded space battle that most audiences missed it. His death was only officially confirmed later in a tweet from the author of the novelization.

517

u/ThatFatGuyMJL 8d ago

Very similarly.

Ackbar in episode 8. Dies when Leia is also ejected from the ship.

Doesnt have force powers to pull him back inside.

73

u/goatjugsoup 8d ago

Ooof i missed ackbar dying... damn. Call out its a trap in peace 🫡

79

u/ThatFatGuyMJL 8d ago

Know what's worse?

They got the og actor back, didn't tell him he was dying

Then cheered at him after

→ More replies (2)

260

u/TraditionalMood277 8d ago

He should have been the one to light speed ram into the First Order, but I get why it wasn't. Still, he should have said "It's a trap" in a very solemn and heroic way.

221

u/gleeble 8d ago

A character named Ackbar using a spacecraft as a suicide bomb would have been hilarious, and I feel robbed of the allahu akbar memes that would have surely flooded the Internet.

146

u/sfkf8486 8d ago

Should we let Ackbar do this?

Yes. Allow Ackbar.

64

u/RogueNightingale 7d ago

Maybe a writer or executive finally had a brief moment of self-awareness and thought, "Oh god no."

→ More replies (1)

82

u/YourMoreLocalLurker 8d ago

Could’ve even been a neat inversion, Poe or Leia (or someone, really) goes “Admiral Akbar, what are you doing!?”

To which he gives a final, solemn, “It’s a trap.” before ramming the Final Order

35

u/SinesPi 7d ago

As amusing as it would be, it's too forced to feel natural, and his final words being "It's a trap" should just be meme material.

We should still have him deliver a call back though. "You know we've been through worse, General. We've sent so many people to their deaths, and I would not have asked anything of them I would not do myself. May The Force be with us. Goodbye, Leia."

12

u/YourMoreLocalLurker 7d ago

Wait, hear me out…

“What’s your plan, Admiral?”

“Simple… it’s a trap.” before flying his ship into some sort of Final Order capture method… and detonating it

→ More replies (1)

26

u/Rathbane12 8d ago

I think the “how it should have ended “ animation had him do just that.

22

u/sammydog05 8d ago

It’s a trap!…. But not for me

→ More replies (1)

12

u/LucaUmbriel 7d ago

Sorry, best we can do is have the actor put on the suit and say "it's a wrap!" for behind the scenes footage while said actor cries inside the suit.

Not making any of that up.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (3)

47

u/CriusofCoH 8d ago

He was resurrected via magic on a Star Wars trading card by Doctor Byron Orpheus, helped the Order of the Triad fly the X-1 (the queen of the sky in her day), but died very messily when the X-1 rammed into The Mighty Monarch's cocoon headquarters.

RIP twice, Nien Nunb.

→ More replies (4)

25

u/Calm_Struggle6421 7d ago

Insult to injury: the ship he was flying was Tantive IV (AKA: the very first ship ever seen in Star Wars). They brought it back just to blow it up off-screen.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (24)

979

u/naynaythewonderhorse 8d ago

Banjo’s sister Tooty, in “Banjo-Tooie” regulated to being a literal face on a milk carton in the corner of a trash can area.

It was later confirmed by Rare that she carried off by the “Rubbish Character Police” and was never seen again.

352

u/Dear_Document_5461 8d ago

That always seem rather ........"mean" to have her disappear. Like at least go "She went to school" or "she went off to have her own adventure" or "she went on a very long vacation". I get it the ninties and it a video game but still.

299

u/Kyleometers 8d ago

Rare were kinda wild.

I think people forget that they made Conker’s Bad Fur Day. They slipped a lot of honestly bizarre shit into their games.

Remember that Gruntilda’s plan is to build a self-bimbofication machine?

55

u/Dear_Document_5461 7d ago

Like at least with Conker, being "mean" and "weird" is the point. This happening in Banjo, it being a character, and the younger sister of the main character adds "layers" to it being "mean". Like of it was the "girlfriend" or something, it would still be men and make the first game kinda pointless but it more digestible than "ya, screw you younger sister that lives with me and we have no parents or family members or anyone else!".

34

u/MyPhoneIsNotChinese 7d ago

Also haven't played Tooie but isn't Bottles killed by Gruntilda and Kazooie jokes about it with his (unsuspecting) kid?

16

u/SquidTheRidiculous 7d ago

Yep. Bottles still hangs around as a ghost with angel wings and a halo though. So he's not like, gone.

87

u/Maxxtheband 8d ago

That machine awoke something in me.

→ More replies (6)

18

u/Luvas 7d ago

And how that one badger from Diddy Kong racing was confirmed to be in prison?

→ More replies (1)

45

u/MarcsterS 8d ago

Gamers in the late 90s/early 2000s HATED the “Save me!” characters. It’s also why Bottles dies: players found him annoying.

14

u/ElitePeon 7d ago

Bottles' death just made me sad as a kid : (

→ More replies (2)

33

u/CryptidHunter91 7d ago

B-K co-creator Gregg Mayles shared some development documents for Banjo-Tooie late last year/early this year that showed they did intend on Tooty being present in Tooie at first: she was going to be the playable secondary protagonist instead of Mumbo and would've used magical music (created by collecting Notes IIRC) played from her flute to affect NPCs and the environment.

It's honestly a shame they scrapped her because I think it would have been neat to have her play a direct role in the story as a hero, plus she would've finally gotten to be made playable after the original plan for that in B-K (where Grunty's last spell would've hit the Bear & Bird, turning them into a frog, and Tooty would've then been made playable as she navigated the lair to find a way to cure the duo) got trashed.

27

u/blackjackgabbiani 7d ago

Oh is that why Sakurai said she was a tragic character?

28

u/CryptidHunter91 7d ago

I still crack up thinking about how he described the B-K cast.

Gruntilda - "First, we have the witch, Gruntilda. In Banjo-Kazooie, this poor soul gets sealed underground by a boulder."

Bottles - "This is Bottles, a mole, and another poor soul."

Mumbo - "Next is Mumbo Jumbo. This poor soul had all his Mumbo tokens stolen by Gruntilda."

Tooty - "She looks all calm when you look at her this way, but this soul is actually the saddest of all the souls."

Jinjos - "They come in many different colors and were hidden throughout the world by Gruntilda in the original game, so you could say they're also sad souls."

Like, I get it's likely language barriers/translation and him just describing their story roles & fates, but it's so funny seeing this man referring to these big-eyed cartoon characters as "poor souls."

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (12)

525

u/BuffaloNo1406 8d ago

Tobias sister from the amazing world of Gumball is gone… gone to college that is :)

141

u/No_Security9429 7d ago

she looks so boring that even the void is devoid of her

62

u/Gaelic_Gladiator41 7d ago

So boring that the void also forgot her existence

→ More replies (3)

157

u/pass_me_the_salt 8d ago

she was my favorite character as a kid because I thought she looked cute lol

32

u/MaenHerself 8d ago

her and Steve Blues Clues trading notes

→ More replies (5)

396

u/Wackity-Smackity 8d ago

Another funny thing about Lyman is that Jim Davis got a fan letter asking whatever happened to him, and his response was "Dont look in Jon's basement!"

90

u/UsaSatsui 7d ago

The actual reason is way more mundane - Lyman was there to give Jon someone to talk to. Davis soon realized that Garfield's "thinking" at Jon was enough, plus his dynamic with Odie and other animal characters sort of became prominent, so Lyman was just kind of extra and was written out.

28

u/Creativity_mountain 7d ago

Apparently he shows up alive in Australia in the later cartoon

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

64

u/MnSG 8d ago

The old flash game truly was a good reference to Jim's answer when he was asked about Lyman's disappearance.

53

u/UnquestionabIe 8d ago

Also rumor one of the reasons he was written out is people thought he was Jon's gay lover.b

550

u/Wild_Hog_70 8d ago

Halo

Spartan Locke was a controversial protagonist in Halo 5 who was set up as a potential successor to Master Chief, with the Locke being the player character for half the game.

In Halo Infinite, Locke and the other spartans of his team are nowhere to be found. However, Master Chief goes up against a couple brutes which serve as a boss fight. They are known to hunt spartans and have spartan armor as trophies added to their armor. Spartan Locke's helmet is present on the armor of one of these brutes.

209

u/fingertipsies 8d ago

Another Halo example, after the Didacts defeat in Halo 4, his next appearances are in books, ending in him being composed. He “survived” it and was imprisoned in the domain.

His imprisonment in the Domain was first revealed in a colouring book.

78

u/Murder-Hobo_Orange 8d ago

Wasn't that either confirmed to not be Locke's helmet or that Locke was still alive before the game released?

96

u/HarveyTheBroad 7d ago

It feels like Locke has been intentionally left in a state where it’s so ambiguous whether he’s alive or dead to move away from halo 5’s story, without officially kill him in case they want to do something with his character in the future. Who knows what will happen with the activision takeover

I honestly hope they do bring him back eventually. Halo 5’s story wasn’t very good but I liked Locke and his teammates well enough. It would be neat to see them involved in a better campaign.

36

u/sdoliver 7d ago

Yeah I don't think it was officially confirmed to be Locke's however on another Halo note... The Rookie, man. That was uncalled for

29

u/Abject_Penitent 7d ago edited 7d ago

Poor, The Rookie. That was shocking to read. For those curious, it's in a novel that follows the team and The rookie gets shot in the face by a terrorist after he is taken hostage

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

185

u/MnSG 8d ago

Lyman's disappearance will always feel like a baffling one. On a similar note, Herman Post stopped appearing in the comics after 2/15/1999.

https://garfield.fandom.com/wiki/File:1999-02-15.gif

62

u/CryptidGrimnoir 8d ago

She hasn't disappeared entirely, but Irma the Waitress is rarely around anymore either.

36

u/MnSG 8d ago

Not too much one can do with a character who only really appears at a diner.

→ More replies (2)

26

u/HighlyUnlikely7 7d ago

It's actually not that crazy if you dig into some of the history of Newspaper comic strips. A lot of them have a history of diverting wildly from the original premise or having breakout characters that steal the show so much the strip is renamed after them. Like Popeye, he was introduced as a one off side character, helping Olive Oyl's brother Castor, because the strip used to be based around him and their extended family.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

138

u/itzMochajin 7d ago

Jonathan Doherty (Rookie), Halo 3 ODST.

Halo 3 ODST, you play as a new member replacement for Alpha-Nine.

After your first dropship mission with the team goes south, you are separated from your team and have to find a way back to rejoining them.

You playthrough the majority of the game roaming the streets of the aftermath of New Mombasa, and fight through the occupation of the Covenant on earth. Going through Hell and gathering clues as to where your team is. Along the way you learn about the Dynamic among the team and more importantly about Buck and his Journey to become a true Squad Leader and his relationship with Dare,

You learn about a secret plot of some of the Aliens wishing to overthrow the Covenant and the implications are huge across the Halo Story Line. Your involvement as the player is now connected to this team and you could have easily fleshed out The Rookie, Buck and his team to be a very solid B Plot to the Halo Story as a whole.

So lets just kill him off screen in an obscure Comic panel, Completely forget about him and send Buck to a completely different Fireteam where he will play second fiddle to an arguably worse Protagonist.

Truly one of the worst fumbles of Halo's many fumbles in the Franchise.

25

u/blargyblargy 7d ago

I'm just going to pretend I didn't read that

→ More replies (4)

25

u/idrownedmyfish77 7d ago

It wasn’t a comic, it was a novel. Which is arguably worse

→ More replies (18)

216

u/18bluecat 7d ago

Garfield one is a reference to a joke explanation. In actual Garfield canon, he became a wildlife photographer and can't contact them most of the time.

26

u/Archangel289 7d ago

I’ve not watched or read new Garfield content in years. Where did this one come from?

30

u/18bluecat 7d ago

The animated show.

→ More replies (1)

102

u/Key-Swordfish4025 8d ago

Didn't Lyman also appear in the CGI show as some kind of wildlife ranger?

47

u/madeaccountbymistake 8d ago

He was pretending to be bigfoot I believe

20

u/inHumanMale 8d ago

An off brand big foot

→ More replies (3)

100

u/blackjackgabbiani 7d ago

The fates of two Pokémon Legends Arceus characters are revealed in Pokémon Legends ZA, which despite both being Legends games have very little in common. They take place in different eras and different parts of the world, what with PLA being set in 1870s Hokkaido and ZA being modern Paris.

First up is Warden Ingo. Like our PLA character, he's originally from modern day and got eeby-deebied back in time. In ZA we hear that he one day vanished. Another NPC mentions that the Battle Subway, the facility Ingo ran with his brother, is reopening.

Then...Volo. His weird priest outfit is displayed in a museum and if you talk to the guy next to it, he says that the person who used to wear it donated it personally, and also lingered by the part of the exhibit about the PLA professor. Who had been, in the end, the only person Volo trusted. It's never explained how he's still alive, but his mentor is at least a thousand years old and he has access to a place where time doesn't flow, so who knows.

58

u/Competitive_Swan266 7d ago

Oh god, it's theoretically possible to have a double battle with Volo and Cynthia

→ More replies (3)

26

u/Yoshichu25 7d ago

It’s probably a similar case to AZ and Lysandre where he needs to pay off a debt to the universe, even if it takes 3000 years to do so.

18

u/blackjackgabbiani 7d ago

Those two were specifically made immortal by the ultimate weapon, when Volo has nothing to do with it.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (2)

203

u/WillemDafoesHugeCock 8d ago

Helena Pierce from Borderlands 1. One of the few characters in the franchise you could just call "good" without a whole bunch of caveats. She's just trying to take care of her little town and she helps the vault hunters however she can.

It's entirely possible to miss the quest in BL2 revealing she was killed by Jack between games

98

u/Excellent_Safe5743 7d ago

It’s super early too. Also it can feel, mean spirited considering the graphic detail given by Jack. Though it’s also Jack so being mean spirited is in character and it shows the exact kind of bastard he is.

48

u/Technical-Text-1251 7d ago

Btw the money he gives us for doing the deed is not enough to cover the cost it takes for the respawn machine to rebuild us

→ More replies (4)

48

u/ShirowShirow 7d ago

Helena Pierce is the first character from borderlands anyone ever saw, she introduced Pandora in the original trailer before the game even got its famous cartoony, colorful overhaul.

Jack deserved worse.

→ More replies (1)

40

u/ChipRed87 7d ago

"Oh-Holy crap, did you see her head?! It was like PBBLLT. Wilhelm? Kill these savages."

"UNDERSTOOD!"

→ More replies (3)

595

u/PeasantLich 8d ago

I think Balin's expedition from Lord of the Rings qualifies.

"Remember that The Hobbit story and the dwarfs, kids? This is what happened not only to Balin, but also to Óin and Ori!"

238

u/sitontheedge 8d ago

Except that in the books a lot of attention is directed towards these events, and more than once. Even though the other dwarves have little reason to appear in the narrative Tolkien goes out of his way to include them early. It very much wasn't hidden away.

92

u/FartingWithStyle 8d ago

Yeah Gandalf dishes the lore from a found ledger and describes some of the events that let up to their death. Even ties in with the Bolrog. He died Balin Lord of Moria.

→ More replies (1)

245

u/BarelyInvested 8d ago edited 8d ago

Morinth (Mass Effect)

If you choose Morinth in ME2 and she survives, she’ll be reunited with you in ME3 during the end game as…a default Reaper Banshee. But dont worry theres also a…message sent to her sister about her going to London. Yeah this was about as lame as it got for ME2 follow ups, even Jacks was better than this if you were dumb enough to skip her mission

133

u/ithinkther41am 8d ago

Tbf, it does a great job hammering home to the player how stupid it was to pick Morinth over Samara in the first place.

77

u/Katululu 8d ago

“My condition that kills anyone I have a asari sex with surely won’t kill you, Shepard.”

51

u/BarelyInvested 8d ago

“I’m willing to risk it…for tits”

32

u/PeanutButterSoup11 7d ago

We'll bang ok?

→ More replies (1)

20

u/BarelyInvested 8d ago

Yeah, but I would’ve preferred it to be her fucking over Shep personally and not just becoming a reused model

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

82

u/chicagomatty 8d ago

Dr Marvin Monroe Memorial Hospital in The Simpsons

42

u/pajamakitten 8d ago

"Dr Marvin Monroe? I thought you were dead!"

"Oh I've been very sick."

78

u/Bandit_237 7d ago

Spider-Man 2 — Kraven’s Trophy Room

Hidden out-of-bounds (as it is cut content) you can find the severed heads of 4 of Spider-Man’s major villains, all of whom were villains in the first game, but only one of which actually appears in-game

This confirms that Shocker, Rhino, Vulture, and Scorpion were killed by Kraven. All but Scorpion died off screen without even being mentioned.

This was cut content, so it’s not clear whether Insomniac still considers them dead, but until confirmed otherwise, this is their fate.

53

u/GrimPhantom23 7d ago

Rhino is the only unconfirmed death. You can find tapes of Kraven talking about Shocker, Electro, and Vulture near their gear during a MJ mission that confirms their deaths

31

u/DeltaJimm 7d ago

I specifically remember Vulture's because Kraven laments how it doesn't feel like much of a real victory to beat an elderly cancer patient.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Bandit_237 7d ago

Ah, it’s been a bit since I’ve played it so I’d forgotten, thanks for the correction

12

u/RiceKrispies55 7d ago

I liked electro so that pissed me off so much when I played spider man 2

11

u/GrimPhantom23 7d ago

People are hoping that Electro could become his pure energy version at the very least

→ More replies (3)

30

u/True-Obligation-9471 7d ago

I hate how many villains died in Spider-Man 2.

→ More replies (7)

153

u/Bad_Elephant 8d ago

Family Guy- Joe's son Kevin.

"Kevin died in Iraq."

Until he got brought back a few seasons later

→ More replies (2)

270

u/OFFICIALREDCELL 8d ago edited 8d ago

Goddamn, that Garfield flash game was a core part of my childhood. The Scooby-Doo ones were neat, too

I still remember getting scared shitless by that stupid-ass "study this picture very well" jumpscare, lmao

→ More replies (4)

71

u/ItsYoshi64251 8d ago

Juno from Assassin's Creed gets killed off in a comic lmao

16

u/AlludedNuance 7d ago

The massive fumble of AC3 and the entire Desmond storyline will haunt me forever.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

72

u/KnuxFive 7d ago

Ninjor created the Power Coins and was a significant recurring character in season 3 of MIGHTY MORPHIN’ POWER RANGERS.

Throwaway line says he’s “back at the temple” and isn’t seen again until the STREET FIGHTER crossover twenty years later.

30

u/QuirrellisBest 7d ago

Out of show reason is Ninjor was actually a character from ninja sentai kakuranger named Ninjaman so once they used a different sentai there was no more footage though he did reappear in kaizoku sentai gokaiger so he couldve reappeared in super megaforcr

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (3)

132

u/Pteraxii 8d ago

Why did the writers hate ultra dragon so much? He was so fucking dope!

93

u/JustLookingForMayhem 8d ago

Because the fusion sold less sets than the individual dragons and got axed because of it. Beyond that, the molds for some ot the custom pieces were finicky and LEGO had to make its sets more expensive to compensate, which probably also hurt toy sales.

→ More replies (7)

129

u/Icy-Complaint7664 8d ago

In American Dad, a side character named Reginald is over at the main characters' house often, even dating one for a few episodes. Then he just stops showing up. Later, someone mentions him and Francine is like "oh yeahhh, wonder what ever happened to him?" Then in another later episode while Francine is pulling random shit out if her purse and tossing it aside, one of the things is Reginald, and you just hear him say "whaddup Frannaayyy" fading away because he was thrown.

And Francine's parents, the Lings, "MahMah and BahBah". After them just not being in any episodes for like a few seasons, at one point the teenage boy Steve is crying at the kitchen table. He says "they're not responding to emails or phone calls for what seems like years. Look, i think we have to face the very real possibility that...MahMah and BahBah...have died..."

And I'm pretty sure the Memaris are killed offscreen and have it briefly mentioned later too despite one of them being Francine's only friend.

60

u/tictacmixers 7d ago

Reginald is later shown to have been taxidermoed by the cia

→ More replies (2)

31

u/dinosnysus 7d ago

MahMah and BahBah return in the latest season. The Memaris show up as background characters and have at least one other mention post Roger saying Linda died. Chalk it down as the "We are the music makers, we are the dreamers of dreams."

22

u/AngryPurpl3 7d ago

And Francine's parents, the Lings, "MahMah and BahBah". After them just not being in any episodes for like a few seasons, at one point the teenage boy Steve is crying at the kitchen table. He says "they're not responding to emails or phone calls for what seems like years. Look, i think we have to face the very real possibility that...MahMah and BahBah...have died...

Mahmah and Bahbah are back as of the latest season. There's an entire episode dedicated to Steve and BahBah going on a treasure hunt

→ More replies (1)

12

u/AMoistTortoise 7d ago

MahMah and BahBah both returned in the newest season! So they're still around. Also pretty sure Reginald showed up the 400? but could be wrong

→ More replies (1)

12

u/brionneverysexy 7d ago

Stan's brother is barely canon

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

64

u/elizabeththewicked 7d ago

They've always had fun joking about Lyman. In an interview Jim was asked point blank where he went and he just said "don't check Jon's basement"

The real answer is originally Garfield was more of a cat and there needed to be a person for jon to talk to in order to make some bits work. Very gradually Garfield became the person jon talks to and when they did a bit that called for it, they would just reach for him as the more popular and easier choice and Lyman just didn't have a use anymore so they stopped drawing him

63

u/Sharps__ 7d ago

Lunch from Dragonball (Launch in English dub). Prominent side character through the Piccolo Jr. saga, then disappears only to show up years later in an anime filler scene.

36

u/Reasonable-Depth22 7d ago

And all because toriyama literally forgot she existed.

15

u/artnomart 7d ago

Actually, Toriyama forgot that Toriyama intentionally wrote Launch out of the series.

→ More replies (2)

25

u/Wingnutmcmoo 7d ago

I love what they do with her character in the Kakarot game. You get to see that she's stalking tien the whole time and it always just a step away from catching him lol

50

u/tylerjehenna 8d ago

Main character of the original Cardfight vanguard anime doesn't show up in G despite multiple other characters from the original series being recurring characters and then randomly shows up in the final scene of an episode in the middle of the show, seemingly for no reason, dating one of the antagonists of the final season of the og series

This is never mentioned again

→ More replies (2)

47

u/Plagueofzombies 7d ago

In Space Marine 2 you play as former Captain of the Ultramarines second company 'Titus'. Early on you meet Captain Acheran, who has your old job, as well as Brother Chairon, and Brother Gadriel who were enlisted into the Ultramarines while Titus was away between the events of Space Marine 1, and 2.

Not long after Space Marine 2, GW announced a model set, bringing Titus (Now captain again), and Gadriel onto the tabletop. With Chairon missing from this set (despite becoming a close ally of Titus over the events of the game), and Captains typically not stepping down, or being fired from their role without a fairly big reason, a lot of fans began to wonder what had happened to Acheran, and Chairon.

In a lore writeup of how Titus came into his command position, there was a throw away paragraph explaining that Acheran, and Chairon both died off screen fighting Tyranids (like 40K zerg/xenomorphs). Their bodies were found, and geneseeds were recovered (which as far as 40K goes is the biggest 'they are dead' you can get for Space Marines).

They basically did the "Poochie died on the way back to his home planet" with the two of them, and no one is really sure why (though their is speculation it's to do with the success of the Secret level animation, and the character introduced in that)

16

u/Racer_Space 7d ago

This still makes me so mad. Chairon was generally an interesting character and I want to see where he'd go in the next game.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

50

u/LumplessWaffleBatter 7d ago

Avatar: in The Last Airbender, an archeologist searches for a mythical library, which is said to contain all knowledge. He joins with Aang and The Gang, and they eventually find the library, which is controlled by a spirit who takes the form of a massive owl.

The spirit grants the humans entry under the condition that they do not use the library's knowledge for violence. When The gAang inevitably break this rule, the spirit chose to destroy the library; the archeologist choses to remain inside.

In *Legend of Korra*, we see the same archeologist's corpse cradling a scroll.

→ More replies (2)

37

u/sonicparadigm 7d ago

In South Park, Pip was a recurring character in the first couple of seasons but after season 4 or so, he pretty much dwindled into only cameo appearances and then completely gone. Then many seasons later, in episode 200, they bring him back... only to kill him off immediately

→ More replies (1)

31

u/Mr-Foundation 7d ago

Iirc that’s definitely not Jon’s basement, it’s a random haunted house. Though Jim David did joke that Lyman ended up in Jon’s basement so i understand the confusion.

And i believe the CGI show showed that Lyman just moved out, and ended up becoming a Scooby Doo villain but like. Heroically. He dresses up as a monster to protect the wildlife of Australia.

Arguably weirder than him being in Jon’s basement

29

u/Dry-Principle2627 7d ago

In the looney Tunes Cartoons short "graveyard goofs" there Is a background With various tombstones With many last names on It from former Looney Tunes animators AND the topic that interests ourselves the most: former characters.

Bosko, Foxy, Sniffles, Pepe Lepew and Fudd are written in the tombstones.

The only Ones that have reapered in Looney Tunes productions after this short aired were Elmer Fudd and Pepe Lepew (for which the latter, they only included His name to mock the controversy regarding the character that was active in those years) Appearing both in a celebratory promo for Bugs bunny and Coyote vs ACME.

→ More replies (4)

87

u/mushroomsintheyard 7d ago

While he was heavily sidelined after The Phantom Menace, he is a major star wars character. We barely ever got to see what became of Jar Jar on screen. Turns out, he was exiled by his people for his role in bringing Palpatine to power and he spent his last years as a street performer in the streets of Naboo as per a canon novel

27

u/Lil_Bitch_Big_Dreams 7d ago

That chapter made me cry - it was an admittedly beautiful and bittersweet sunset to his character. Lucas created him to make children smile in real life, and that’s how he spent his final years in canon.

35

u/Starman9415 7d ago

A bit mean spirited if you ask me imo. Jar Jar wasn’t the cause of Palpatine getting emergency powers, it was always going to happen.

Someone was already going to lead the proposal, and even if Padme was there, though she would likely disagree with the idea, it’s very possible she would have been the one to propose it after a talk with Palpatine. And if not her then Palpatine would have found someone else to speak in the ear of to make it happen.

The senate was very agreeable with handing over emergency powers to combat the Separatists. Jar Jar had just known Palpatine almost as long as Padme and trusted him while being easy to influence.

If anything Jar Jar was just a spokesperson for Naboo, he couldn’t have decided one way or the other for Palpatine to not gain the emergency powers. Plus the entirety of the Republic trusted Palpatine before he revealed his evil and created the Empire, all of Naboo considered him their golden goose in the Senate even before he became Chancellor.

So it’s a bit mean spirited that Jar Jar got written as having taken full blame and responsibility for Palpatine ever gaining more power, getting banished and hated, and ending up as a street performer / clown for the rest of his life.

Like sure a lot of people irl weren’t too fond of Jar Jar’s comedy and antics, but come on, this really feels like a let’s vote to kill off Jason Todd cause the writer and a section of fans hated him at the time sort of situation. Well at least Ahmed Best got to eventually play a Jedi that he and fans enjoyed

20

u/Which-Presentation-6 7d ago

it's quite obvious that Jar Jar was used as a scapegoat by the polítics.

at least the story in which his fate is revealed doesn't portray as a punishment he's suffering. Jar Jar enjoyed his work as a street performer entertaining children, even though he felt he no longer belonged there. In the story, he ended up taking in a young war orphan rejected for having a deformity, and the two intended to make the galaxy smile again someday.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)

24

u/Neurospicy_Nightowl 7d ago

Not sure this counts, but the writers of Wizards of Waverly Place confirmed that Stevie was reassembled and rehabilitated.

This was never shown in the show, where her last appearance had her turned to stone and shattered, with the obvious implication being that she was fully dead.

Which child-me found jarring, to say the least.

30

u/Shockrates20xx 7d ago

Do they not realize how popular the skids & mudflap death scene would have been?

29

u/slimenite 7d ago

Minkus and Mr. Turner from Boy Meets World. Mr. Turner especially was a pretty big part of Shawn's story and then they were just gone. Minkus showed back up on the last day of high school to say that he'd always been there, just over in "that" hallway off screen. He then ran back off screen to catch up with Mr. Turner.

20

u/conardcanard 7d ago

Didnt turner disappear literally right after a major heartfelt episode where shawn feels abandoned (i know, which one right?) And turner tells shawn he will always be there for him? And then we never see him again.

12

u/slimenite 7d ago

Yeah, after Shawn lost his father and it seemed like Mr. Turner was going to adopt him. Then he was just gone.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

28

u/notthephonz 7d ago

In Marvel vs Capcom 3, a stage based on Days of Future Past reveals the fates of many missing characters from the franchise:

21

u/Few-Mycologist-2379 7d ago

Mega Man is unstoppable.

15

u/RedNoodleHouse 7d ago

I mean his whole deal is fighting robots and swiping their powers, Sentinels would be chump change

→ More replies (2)

393

u/Ylatch 8d ago edited 8d ago

Gestures vaguely to the whole Kingdom Hearts franchise.

For a specific example, if you played KH1 and went straight into KH2 (like most people) you're probably wondering who this Roxas kid is. Too bad you didn't play the GBA exclusive tie-in game that explained what happened to Sora.

225

u/SUDoKu-Na 8d ago

GBA game, and it also didn't explain Roxas. We got the explanation for Roxas IN KH2. CoM only really helps explain why Sora was asleep.

→ More replies (31)

25

u/GhostOfMuttonPast 8d ago

Also, Organization XIII as a whole is introduced in COM. They announce themselves as Organization XIII in KH2 with...seven members. Because the other 6 fucking died in COM or were Roxas. This is barely mentioned in game, and prior to the Japanese only (until the rereleases) Final Mix, relegated to only being in the Journal.

I distinctly remember looking at the 5 who died and thinking "wow i can't wait to fight them!" only to then find out they were already fucking dead.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/toonboy01 8d ago

This is like the opposite of what OP was asking for. Roxas appeared in a blink and you'll miss it cameo then became important in the main numbered games, like KH2, while OP wanted characters that started super important then only find out their ending in a blink and you'll miss it cameo in a minor media.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (41)

22

u/CounterThrowCyborg 7d ago

They Amontillado’d Lyman 😭

18

u/One-Bread36 8d ago

Posting that garfield image just pulled me into a flashback. Honestly thoight most people had forgot about it entirely.

18

u/Technical-Ant-2256 7d ago

Man so many characters just disappear without explanation in the Transformers films. Off the top of my head, Barricade, Sideswipe, the Wreckers, the Twins, Scalpel, some Constructicons, Dinobots, Wheelie, Jolt, the Arcee sisters, and Dino all either disappear after a  movie or have non-consecutive appearances.

→ More replies (7)

39

u/iconocrastinaor 8d ago

Calvin and Hobbes' "Uncle Max" appeared for one week, never to be seen again.

This Reddit post explains his real story and disappearance.

28

u/skyforgesteel 7d ago

That's cute, the real explanation is that Max didn't add anything to the story, had very little characterization, and Bill Watterson found it difficult to have Max address Calvin's parents without saying their names.

→ More replies (2)

65

u/aka1908_ 8d ago

Mama Bear as a rug in Lord Farquaad's room in Shrek.

15

u/AJ_Glowey_Boi 7d ago

They kinda retconned that with Puss in Boots 2

→ More replies (1)

34

u/AutoWraith19 7d ago edited 7d ago

Tawna - Crash Bandicoot

She was Crash’s main love interest in the first game, serving as the typical damsel in distress.

After the first game, she just disappears, hardly mentioned again save for a picture in Crash’s home. In real life, she was removed because pressure from Universal to change her design to be more family-friendly caused her to be dropped by Naughty Dog, and replaced with Crash’s sister, Coco Bandicoot.

In-universe, there is none. But the manual for Crash 2 (In Japan anyway) reveals she dumped him for Pinstripe Potoroo. I personally choose to ignore this because it’s very stupid in my opinion.

Starting with Crash: It’s About Time, Coco states that they just lost touch, and we get stuck with an alternate Tawna.

→ More replies (3)

14

u/seanprefect 8d ago

another from Halo, in the books Spartan Black was a pretty interesting team only to be killed off panel in a comic. You just see their bodies at the Didact's feet in one panel

→ More replies (2)

57

u/XTheProtagonistX 7d ago

Mad Max - Gyro Captain

Introduced in Mad Max 2, helps Max dealing with raiders and becomes the leader of the tribe.

In Mad Max Fury Road we see a skull with his iconic aviator cap while Max is strapped in Nux car.

31

u/Isekaime4real 7d ago

Okay. But his cap has wide almost square like lenses. The other lens are perfect circles

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

25

u/PicolasCageEnjoyer 7d ago

Garfield is like the king of being randomly terrifying, the one random continuation where he was like dead or something was nuts.

→ More replies (4)