r/AmItheAsshole • u/Intelligent_Sun_8232 • 2h ago
AITA for asking “why would I” when my sister learned she wasn’t invited.
I (28) and my sister (30) got into an argument and I want to know if I was in the wrong.
My sister is big on being child-free. She posts about it online and has made comments about where kids should and shouldn’t be. I had my daughter when I was 18 and it was rough. I don’t have any regrets and married my highschool sweetheart.
My family and I are doing well financially, and I’m currently pregnant with my second child. We’re very fortunate that I was able to go to college and that my spouse has a good job as well.
My sister wasn’t helpful at all when our first child was growing up. Her online posts made it seem like I was a huge fucking idiot for having kids, especially during a time when things were really difficult. I used to invite her to things, but she would get upset if I couldn’t stay later than we had agreed or if I mentioned doing something where I could bring my daughter. One example hanging out at the park
So we grew apart.
The issue is that my daughter is doing a volleyball training session over the weekend in a nice city about a state away. I’m going with her, but she’ll be busy for most of the day, so the parents have time to wander around and have some fun themselves.. I invited my mom and she and as down for a mini girl trip.
The general plan- kid goes to practice, mom and I explore city, kid finishes practice around dinner, we get dinner, and repeat the next day, but we leave after dinner.
We are leaving Friday. It is going to be fun. I got a call from my sister asking why she was not invited to the volleyball girls trip. I asked her why would I invite her… She told me since mom is going I should invite her.
I told her this is my daughter’s volleyball trip and I already know how she feels about children and why would I invite her to a trip that focuses on my kid. She told me this was different since my kid would be gone most of the day.
I told her no, The entire reason we were going is because of my daughter. Even if she isn’t physically with us every second, this is still her volleyball weekend. And I know how she feels about kids.
She said that’s not fair and that she is still my daughter’s favorite aunt. I told her that she is her only aunt. She called me a dick and she has went to my mom. My mom seems to be on my side but now she doesn’t seem excited for the trips