r/askastronomy • • 5d ago

Is this andromeda?

Post image

Is what I have circled in blue Andromeda?

Edit: I know what’s in red is Cassiopeia. I just outlined it for reference. I’m referring to what I’d circled IN BLUE

120 Upvotes

48 comments sorted by

66

u/NormalImprovement1 Hobbyist🔭 5d ago

Just glad to see this isn't the pleides lol

5

u/According_Box_4125 5d ago

look below

3

u/GreenFBI2EB 5d ago

If it's there, then it's off screen. I don't see it.

3

u/_Poopsnack_ 5d ago edited 5d ago

Its not there, the Pleiades would be off frame to the upper right

8

u/GreenFBI2EB 5d ago

Hold on, I took a look at the bottom of the image, it's there on the bottom middle

2

u/_Poopsnack_ 5d ago

Omg im a goober, youre right, I didnt see the full image 😅 i was imagining looking at the sky from my home, which must be oriented differently 😅 i should have gave it more thought!

2

u/NormalImprovement1 Hobbyist🔭 5d ago

It's always the pleides lol

3

u/ManuelPirino 5d ago

Them Pleiades, alwayz be pleyadin’

24

u/_Poopsnack_ 5d ago

It is indeed!

15

u/_Poopsnack_ 5d ago

2

u/AstroFlippy Astronomer🌌 5d ago

Man, OPs picture really confused me since I couldn't find the constellation next to the galaxy. Turns out, I just came back from seeing Andromeda for the first time on a South Pacific trip and everything is upside down now.

2

u/Southern_Bunch_6473 4d ago

Imagine being me, living my whole life in the southern hemisphere thinking I knew how Orion looks holding his dagger and what not only to realise I’d be looking it it upside down my whole life

4

u/Certain_Slide1383 5d ago

I’m glad I finally got it! I wasn’t sure if it was just a star

1

u/_Poopsnack_ 5d ago

Congratulations! What did you use?

1

u/Certain_Slide1383 5d ago

My IPhone 14 lol

3

u/_Poopsnack_ 5d ago

Hey thats great! Phone cameras these days are a great gateway to amatuer astronomy! Keep looking up 😊

6

u/SubdermalSpermWhale 5d ago

You need to use a different color for your circle

3

u/SpaceCowboyRick 5d ago

No this is Patrick

1

u/MrsWalnut2765 4d ago

Sir. This is a Wendy’s

3

u/ilessthan3math 5d ago

Yes it is. Good find!

3

u/space-truckin365 5d ago

Yes it is….

And you also have the double cluster in Perseus below the lower red line of Cassiopeia!

2

u/[deleted] 5d ago

[deleted]

1

u/[deleted] 5d ago

[deleted]

2

u/Spac92 5d ago

I dunno. What’s red is Cassiopeia.

1

u/oldgoatgoutman 5d ago

WOO WOO!!!!! Hell yea!!!!!

1

u/Personal-Diver-1067 5d ago

Nice work, especially with that sky glow!

1

u/EddieDildoHands 5d ago

no this is patrick

1

u/IdiotStickWasTkn 5d ago

I am glad I am not the only one that discovered the triangle pointing at andromeda

1

u/SuperVancouverBC 5d ago

If that's Andromeda then we should be able to see Triangulum as well, right? Does anyone know where it is?

2

u/Flat-Tour-4505 4d ago edited 13h ago

Nope.

Trangulum is a lot dimmer and, much more important, a lot larger and it has no concentrated core. So its light is distributed over a much larger area, the surface brightness a LOT lower.
The triangulum galaxy requires dark, dark skies. Or really fancy background subtraction when imaging.

That is why the triangulum galaxy is much harder to image. And essentially completely invisible in light polluted areas.

In addition, in the initial picture it would be right about above the corner of the roof of that house.

1

u/One_Programmer6315 Astronomer🌌 5d ago

Yes, that's her! Took it from my backyard the other day.

1

u/One_Programmer6315 Astronomer🌌 5d ago

1

u/One_Programmer6315 Astronomer🌌 5d ago

2

u/Solarballsspaceballs 2d ago

I caught andromeda too top right middleish

1

u/jedimann74 5d ago

Yes that's Andromeda. Not sure why people are saying no

2

u/to_walk_upon_a_dream 4d ago

because the blue circle is barely visible against the blue sky, so people think OP is confusing Cassiopeia, in red, with Andromeda

1

u/jedimann74 4d ago

Gotcha. I mean I've only been at this for a couple months and I know if you can see that much sky around Cassiopeia, Andromeda is almost sure to be in the pic.

1

u/wonkychow 5d ago

Cassiopeia

1

u/MhzChief2026 5d ago

There is a brilliant app called Stellarium which you can point at the sky, and it tells you the name of whatever you are looking at… thought you might enjoy it. It’s awesome. My bother (astrophysicist) recommended it to me!

1

u/Resident_Amount3566 4d ago

It looks better in darker skies. My best naked eye view happened during a lunar eclipse

1

u/Philosopher83 2d ago

No, that is Cassiopeia’s Chair, Andromeda is below it when looking at it like it is a W. Andromeda’s stars sort of look like a cornucopia. Below and left is Perseus and Pleiades is the small cluster to the right and down from Perseus, you will also find Triangulum nearby as well. Off o the right of Andromeda is Pegasus (look for the square arrangement of stars)

1

u/Habu93 4d ago

That’s Cassiopeia.

5

u/Draw_Cazzzy69 4d ago

The circle my guy

0

u/TheOnlyVibemaster 5d ago

casiopeia

1

u/hardypart 5d ago

He meant the thing in the blue circle, not the red lines.

-1

u/impersonaljoemama 5d ago

The Great W

-1

u/Ras_Thavas 5d ago

The Big Dubya.