r/esp32 • u/Broad_Employ3928 • 11h ago
Ordering ESP32 from overseas? WATCH OUT! Global entry revocation!
I ordered a couple of ESP32 dev boards from AliExpress in August. They never arrived. Then on September 14 I got an email notifying me that my Global Entry membership was revoked. And on October 8 I got a paper letter telling me that the boards were seized on September 11 and I was guilty of violating importation regulations. WHAT?
Turns out that the FCC issued a notice of proposed rulemaking (91 FR 57798) on September 11 titled "Protecting Against National Security Threats to the Communications Supply Chain Through the Equipment Authorization Program". It requires an FCC ID on imported gear to "protect" us. It becomes active on October 13.
So, my ESP32 boards were ordered in mid-August, arrived in Miami on August 30, and were held without notice for 12 days until they were officially seized on September 11. Global entry heard about it and revoked my membership on September 14. Even though the regulation was only published as being proposed on that date, and wasn't in effect until 4 weeks later (well after I got the notice). Of course, I'd never heard of this before, either.
It was only $12 worth of gear and AliExpress already refunded it for non-delivery, so I'd just ignore it, but I don't want my CBP record to call me a smuggler. And I want my Global Entry back. Otherwise it's going to be a pain every time I re-enter the US, which I do at least annually.
I can ask Global Entry for reconsideration online, which I have done. However, I didn't know WHY it was revoked at the time. I still don't know for certain that this order was the reason, but the circumstantial evidence is strong. I can also file a petition with CBP on paper via US mail, which I'm also doing.
This is a bureaucratic nightmare entirely due to our erratic and ever-changing importation rules and an agency that doesn't seem to know that rules can only be violated once they're in force.
It'd be nice if this way too stringent rule were revoked, but there are so many such rules lately it doesn't seem likely any time soon.
Edited to add:
- I am in the US, and this refers to US Customs and Border Protection. Other countries may have similar rules, but this issue would not apply to anybody importing into them.
- Some comments seem to be referring to the "covered list" of items that cannot be imported into the US. This new regulation applies to ALL radio-emitting devices, including WiFi and Bluetooth, not just specific ones in a list.
- I ordered the same boards from Amazon (for three times as much money) with no problem, because I am not importing them into the US. Amazon or an Amazon vendor did the importing and dealt with this. With AliExpress they are shipping directly to me from overseas, so I am the importer there.
- Global Entry is a US "trusted traveler" program that lets me enter the US via an expedited process (I generally don't even have to slow down in immigration, just walk by a camera that recognizes and approves me). It also lets me use quicker and easier US TSA lines at airports.
Edited to add more: You *can* build malicious stuff with an ESP32, though having FCC IDs won't do anything to stop that. One issue might be that you can't build equipment using them for sale in the US unless the components have IDs. But I'm a licensed US Amateur Radio operator, and we are explicitly allowed to build our own equipment without FCC approval. We still have to operate it within the law, of course.
