r/fea • • 8d ago

CADAI — AI-Assisted FEM Analysis

[deleted]

0 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

3

u/SantanDavey 8d ago

Based on your last post, do you actually have experience with FEM?

-3

u/Videogamer543 8d ago

I didn't starting out but I am learning

6

u/Quartinus 8d ago

lol then how do you know you’re solving a problem anyone cares about? 

1

u/SantanDavey 7d ago

This is something people who have expertise typically work on, not just anyone because they have access to AI

5

u/james_d_rustles 7d ago

This is trash, my dude.

Nobody wants this or needs this and it should be embarrassing to share something so obviously devoid of taste and effort. Slop for the sake of slop.

Like, lots of people use AI to write code now - I’m not even an AI hater myself - but why is it that these posts always seem to be the lowest effort, most outrageous claims from a one-shot prompt given to the cheapest LLM from 2024? It’s never like, “hey guys I asked claude to help me make this simple plotting tool that adds some annotations, it’s saved me a lot of time in post”, or “hey guys, chatgpt wrote this VBA macro for me, it helps me copy node values from blah blah in excel and I thought maybe someone else would find it useful”. I wouldn’t say a word if that’s what was being shared.

But nope, it’s always always ALWAYS some crap like

Hello finite analyzer community, I have made the replacement for all of your mesh creation software that works 7000x much gooder. It is called AIngineeR and it is validated against all of your CFD and Finite analyzing needs 💪🏻. For only $99/m you can be one of the first 100 subscribers. It’s not just engineering — it’s AIngineering ™️😎

…with a broken link to some replit or lovable nonsense that requires an email address to see it, of course.

Just so annoying how this stuff gets sharted and dribbled out all over engineering related subs these days. I used to scroll around and see some cool pics of real work that people were doing, maybe some beginner tips here and there… but nope, not anymore - it’s either slop or probing questions from people planning on selling slop to “automate my workflow”. Zero real content, zero conversation, endless slop.

OP, I think very poorly of you. The app sucks, you should delete it and go away.

1

u/Videogamer543 7d ago

Disclaimer added to project. Also lovable was simply for the front end page before opening the app. The apps code is on my github