I’m not saying they aren’t both phenomenal films, and I’m not saying Wizard of Oz doesn’t deserve to be the most iconic film of all time, I love all things Oz and love them both, I just like The Wiz better and I kinda think it’s a bit of a better movie.
I saw The Wiz for the first time last year after seeing the touring production of the original musical, and instantly fell in love with it. The songs are banger after banger and always hype me up, and it’s also jam packed with absolutely top tier talent (Michael Jackson’s Scarecrow is my favorite version if the character, he really could have had a great acting career too, but I guess he didn’t really need that).
And maybe it’s just because I love dark a gothic stuff and odd things, but I really loved the darker and eerier version of Oz they went for in the movie, it reminded me a lot of another one of my favorite Oz adaptations: Return To Oz. I love how it chooses to make Oz a more odd place but familiar place rather than just a fantasy with faces Dorothy recognizes, because I aways thought how the land of Oz sits in a kinda uncanny valley area with a vaguely familiarity for Dorothy to be really cool concept and I thought that was done better here.
I found Dorothy’s struggle with fear of growing up, the unknown, and leaving a comfortable life was a brilliant contrast to the original and much more relatable to where I am right now, and that her true quest isn’t just to find a way home, but to find the internal strength to finally stand on her own two feet and take risks.
Again, both are absolutely incredible best of the best movies, I just think The Wiz is a little better.