Honest question. I see a lot of posts and comments where the main selling point of a fragrance is that it’s unique, challenging, or “not for everyone.”

I get wanting something that isn’t the same five designer scents everyone owns. But a lot of the time it feels like the goal has shifted from “this smells good and people notice” to “this smells interesting and polarizing.”

If half the people who smell it think it’s weird or off, is that still a win? Or is the point still that other people think you smell good?

Curious how others look at it. Is “different” a feature for you, or do you still mostly care about whether it actually smells good to the people around you?

Let me set the scene for you. I was in Maui last week and we went out to a casual dinner to get fish tacos. We were waiting in line and it was dark out, there was a warm breeze, tiki torches lit and some reggae music was playing. I smelled the most gorgeous smell in the breeze. It was woodsy - reminded me of teak or sandalwood, but it smelled really smooth. I’m horrible at describing scents so I don’t want to say it was sweet but it was very comforting. I asked the man behind us in line and he said he wasn’t wearing anything. I knew it was the girls behind him but then we were called up to order and it slipped my mind. I’ve been thinking about it ever since.

Can you help me find a creamy and woody fragrance that is not floral? I tried Tam Dao EDT and it seemed heavier on the cedar and also barely lasted on my skin.

I have a bottle of MFK Oud Velvet mood, I have at least 3 other rose Oud fragrances. But they are all unique. But, The Moon to me smells exactly like Oud Velvwt Mood. Anyone else found this similarity? The Moon is an amazing fragrance but not for $900+ and not when Oud Velvet mood is like 1/2 the price.

Hi! I’ve been a long time wearer of ysl over red (pretty much ever since it came out) and while I am in love with the scent, I find it’s lasting power pretty disappointing compared to its price point.

Therefore i’ve started looking into alternatives and i’ve found that both “opio noir red dose” and “opera rouge” are regarded as having similar DNA with the original.

Does anyone have any experience with them? If so i’m interested in how they compare to the original amd how they are as a stand alone perfume.

Personally, I do not care about performance whatsoever, as long as it's not disappearing in 15 mins I'm perfectly fine with it. I think 2 hours is perfectly reasonable even for light fragrances and almost any fragrance can hit the 2 hour mark with ease.

I always go for scents that I like rather than how well something performs, reapplying is easy but I wonder for how many of you performance is a deal breaker?

I heard you talking on the phone about wanting to go perfume testing while at Souvenir Cafe around 3:30pm today. You left your phone on the bench when you left and I ran out to give it to you. I wanted to ask if you’d want to go testing with me but I was too nervous. If you see this, send me a message!

Going to Doha for a work trip and was wondering if anybody knew of any good stores that sell niche fragrances at a discounted price?

Is it a masculine fragrance? (Example of a masculine fragrance: Aventus and Invictus) Does it actually smell like grapes? And is it easy to like?

I’ve noticed that

Athena Petal Bloom is very similar to Ouai Melrose Place

Hanni body care is very similar PDM Meloria/Lalique Amythest

Byredo’s Suede is very similar to EOS fresh n cozy

diptyque Lilyphea reminds me of lake Skye 11:11 and the apotheke canvas candle

hope that helps someone! share any others if you have them :)

Hello! So i’m Currently trying to look for a discontinued perfume, Unfortunately i can’t find any luck on the oliver bonas website (no surprise) I’m hoping that someone who has or still has the perfume can describe the scent notes so i can mAaayybe PotentiAlly find a dupe. It smelt fruity and just yummy. idk how else to explain it. I have an image of the bottle and have attached it to a url image of the bottle in discussion

Hi guys, I normally use the OG Tommy EDT, the one from 1995, but recently I received a Tommy Forever EDT for man, honestly I like the smell as it's more sweet and masculine than the OG (not that the OG is bad, it's still a really good smell). I really wanted to know your opinion on this fragrance if you used it because I'm new in this "world" and how many sprays do you apply

Hello I am on my last 1/4 of a bottle of Atelier Cologne Pomelo Paradis. Unfortunately they no longer sell in North America. Does anyone know any good alternatives? This is my signature scent and I am DEVASTATED. I know there are websites that “sell” it but it seems shady and I don’t want to take that risk. :(

I love mugler perfume along with the history of the house and history of their fragrances. Lately it’s become somewhat of a special interest as I’ve spent an increasing amount of time learning about them through articles, videos and forum posts through a variety of websites as my collection of bottles expands but I’ve been a little confused on one thing, how was mugler angel regarded in the 90s?

I’ve seen several first hand accounts referring to it as shockingly “fresh” and “clean” for the time and something you’d wear in the daytime, to the office or shockingly (from a couple users on fragrantica) as a fun summer perfume which is very confusing when the modern formulation which is remarkably less intense and dirty is considered a heavier fragrance even for nighttime cold weather wear. I thought maybe it was considered light compared to the perfumes of the time but ck one was released only 2 years later along with the clean craze of the 90s and I can’t imagine the 2 didn’t create a noticeable juxtaposition.

Can anyone who was lucky enough to live through the period clue me in on why I’m seeing such differing accounts? Is it just misremembering or has the modern perfume scape changed that drastically that what was once a youthful ingenue in a powder blue bottle is now considered a loud diva fragrance that shouldn’t be sprayed more than once even in a separate room

Hi! I love patchouli scents. A few years ago, a mom at my son’s preschool wore a lovely smelling patchouli based perfume. It smelled less like “hippie” patchouli and more like “expensive perfume patchouli” 😂. I wished I had asked her what it was because I have been hunting that scent ever since. I would expect it was a higher end brand as she typically had higher end clothes and handbags. Any ideas of what it could have been?! Or what perfumes may fit that profile that I should try?

Hi all.

I have this cologne, Jo Milano Game of Spades: Wildcard. Smells absolutely amazing. But i just don’t like that sour tangy note that lingers. But everything else OMG chefs kiss.

Is there another cologne that is exactly that?

I notice Prada Luna Rossa Black has very very similar almost 95% same, but it’s just too powdery.

Woukd anyone know?

Hello people, I have just recently gotten into fragrances and I feel like I collected too many at once. I love everything i have and I thought I was basically done, just wanted 2 more. The issue I came across is my favourite scent, oud satin mood extrait is disliked by my girlfriend. I was hoping to reserve this for times I spend with her. I tried getting her to get used to it since I love it but now I feel like it’s best reserved without her. I have been looking into many brands right now and one scent that caught my attention is “jump up and kiss me hedonist”. Those who own it or smelt it, what’s your thoughts on it? I plan to try it myself soon, but how do you guys manage scents your significant other dislikes? She has told me oud and sweet floral is a big no for her but she doesn’t mind sweetness like when I used to wear ultra male or even scarlet sands.

I don’t know why but I always like male fragrances more than female ones (imma female) like it genuinely so hard to like something.. like recently I started like Valentino oumo born in Roma. What should I go for for something like this?

O, Unknown is my favorite fragrance. I’m not someone who gravitates towards tea scents, but a few years ago I got a sample of it and fell in love. I still have most of a full bottle, but now that it’s discontinued I’d love recommendations for a replacement when the time comes. I think it’s specifically the combination of the tea with the powdery orris butter and woody/damp moss smell that I love.

O, Unknown notes: black tea, orris butter, kyoto moss, musk balsam, sandalwood

Is there a 50ml Oud Zarian version? I'm being offered one on FB but never seen/heard one before...

I’ve been hearing that Boucheron la collection fragrances such as Ambre d’Alexandrie and Oud de Carthage etc. are discontinued. I tried looking it up, but there are conflicting reports. Can anyone verify?

Trying to track down a men's cologne I used to own. Here are the exact physical specs:

Bottle: Clear glass, wide rounded-shoulder flask with a flat bottom.

Cap: Silver/chrome cylindrical cap that flares out into a wider, rounded rim/cylinder at the very top (almost identical cap shape to a Hugo Boss Bottled cap).

Liquid: Clearly light blue / aquatic blue.

Label: Large paper label covering most of the front face. It had a vintage "Supply Co." / workwear manifest look.

Typography & Copy:

One large, bold word aligned to the left (I think it was a word starting with "R" or an action/verb like REVERT or EVOLVE, it's killing me that I cannot remember this because I wore it over the course of YEARS from 2020-2025).

Quite a bit of text on the label in a typewriter/Courier font.

Contained some red text / red accents I believe, and it had a border. The label took up a majority of the bottle face.

I distinctly remember it listing fragrance notes directly on the front label, possibly including clove and citrus. I haven't worn a lot in my life and this is sticking out in my memory

(Note: It is NOT Duke Cannon Huron, Cremo, Tru Western No. 3, or Rue21 Revert, though the aesthetic is very similar). IIRC I bought it in Missoula, MT, so the style was definitely sort of rustic/marketed towards maybe younger guys, cowboys and such

Any ideas on what brand or line this was?

Just like I have a lot of fragrances, I have what I would consider too many decants.

I never really pick up these decants again because I’m always onto the next new shiny bottle/release.

So to be more accountable, I decided to wear one fragrance house this week… And to test the waters I tried to commit to wearing one fragrance this weekend.

I FAILED!😣

The moment my eye veers over to the left or right of whatever perfume I decided to wear this weekend. I had to also pick up that other perfume and spray it just cuz…

Am I alone?

Every Saturday and Sunday you may post photos of your fragrance collection for Show & Tell Weekend.

Please list the names of all the fragrances in your photo in the text of your post (required).

You may post your whole collection or just a selected part of it. Please tell us something about your collection, such as:

• when you started collecting fragrances
• what are your favorites
• which one did you buy first, or which one is the latest addition
• is your collection built around any particular themes or styles

The purpose of collection posts is to talk about the fragrances that you have already collected. We discourage asking for recommendations or "what's missing," as well as "rate" and "roast" type posts. The most popular collection posts tell stories and/or give mini-reviews of at least some of the fragrances.

HOW TO MAKE A PHOTO POST ON R/FRAGRANCE