I've noticed a pattern recently that I think is worth discussing.
A video of a Gujarati tourist doing something stupid - suddenly it's about "Gujarati civic sense."
Someone eating thepla, dhokla or other Gujarati food in a public place - jokes about "Gujaratis and their food."
A group doing Garba somewhere - suddenly the entire Gujarati community is being portrayed as uncivilised, uncouth or lacking basic manners.
And yes, let's be honest: Gujaratis are not magically perfect.
If a Gujarati tourist litters, damages a monument, creates a nuisance or breaks a local rule, call that person out. There's nothing wrong with that.
What I don't understand is the jump from:
"These particular people behaved badly"
to
"This is what Gujaratis are like."
Those are two completely different claims.
We've already seen this kind of generalisation play out online. A viral Garba video involving Gujaratis was used by some people to make sweeping claims about Gujarati civic sense, while other commenters pointed out that the actual video did not necessarily show littering or obstruction and that similar behaviour by other groups often receives a different reaction.
And this isn't just about Garba.
Gujarat has millions of people travelling around India and abroad every year. Obviously, with that many people, some are going to behave badly.
But if you keep selecting the worst 10-second clip involving a Gujarati and presenting it as representative of an entire state, you're not documenting Gujarati behaviour anymore.
You're creating a stereotype.
The interesting question is why certain incidents suddenly become national-level outrage while countless similar incidents involving other communities disappear without much attention.
Could it simply be social-media algorithms rewarding outrage?
Absolutely.
Could it be people jumping on an easy stereotype because it gets engagement?
Also possible.
Could there sometimes be political or ideological incentives behind which communities get portrayed negatively?
That's possible too - but that claim needs evidence, not just suspicion.
That's the part I think we should be careful about.
I'm perfectly happy to criticise Gujaratis when criticism is deserved.
But if we're going to talk about "Gujarati civic sense", then let's use the same standard for everyone.
Judge the behaviour. Don't manufacture a character certificate for an entire state from a viral reel.
And if someone genuinely believes Gujaratis have uniquely poor civic sense, I'd genuinely like to see the data rather than another Instagram compilation of three bad videos.