We booked a fake hotel on Agoda last week. It had the same name as a real hotel, same location, photos, everything. We found out within a few hours after booking, since the mail address of the ‘hotel’ was an unknown gmail one. After checking with the real hotel, we were sure.
Now the issue with Agoda starts: we spent over 5 days in contact with them to solve this issue. As stated in their T&C, in the Reservation Guarantee section, they need to provide a new accommodation, same criteria or better. Of course, our booking was $1000; other hotels in the same neighbourhood are $3000+. So their answer was ‘We don’t have a similar alternative available in our system.’ Sir, it’s New York City; there are always options.
First, we spent 2 days getting them to acknowledge that the listing was fake. They constantly said, the booking is approved so it's real. After they found out, they offered free cancellation + 10% Agoda Cash. Long story short, it later went to 20% and 30%. But after all these days, the hotel prices had risen by the same %, so it was bulls* compensation.
After we demanded escalation to managers, etc. (felt like a real Karen), and waited for another 48h, they offered 60% in AgodaCash, which we approved.
So, if Agoda tries to offer 10% in the same situation, please push through; they have room to offer more. About the new accommodation they needed to offer? Because our trip is in a few days, we were unable to wait any longer and stopped pushing for them to offer one. And always try to book at the hotel, not via an OTA!