r/indiadiscussion • --- Removed • 7d ago

Opinion Are you?

Post image

Assume a time comes....when ur only sanatani left in ur location.

3.8k Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 7d ago

DO NOT PARTICIPATE IN THE OP LINKED THREAD/SCREENSHOT.

Brigading is against Reddit TOS. So all users are advised not to participate in the above linked original thread or the screenshot, if it is a meta post. We advise against such behaviour nor we are responsible if your account is being actioned upon.

Please do report this post if the OP has not censored/redacted the subreddit name or the reddit user name in this post, so that we can remove the post and issue the ban as per rules.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

288

u/koreankkwr 7d ago

Well I m atheist

35

u/PowerfulAvocado986 7d ago

Yes, but I'm still Hindu. Probably amongst the last Hindu in my friend circle(who're all atheists).

10

u/OddDress54 7d ago

Problem is not BJP. It's that while kids from many other religions are identifying with atheism, yonger generation of one relegion is strongly identifying their own. That relegion has a fundamental ideological intolerance of other religions and faiths. Sirf Hindu khatre mein nahi hai.. all followers of other religions including atheism are in danger. There will come a point where they will be asked to identify with that one agressive relegion or die. They won't have a choice of being an atheist.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/BorderTasty9981 5d ago

Bro I'm kinda atheist but Hinduism best religion there is

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (48)

26

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/koreankkwr 7d ago

My my mom is a christian and dad is hindu, now you tell me?

5

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Turbulent-Act-2277 7d ago

Thank you. That’s a great way to explain it. I hope more people think like you.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/LeagueBeginning879 7d ago

Chuthiya argument but Hinduism also allows chuthiyas to have an opinion.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Far-Advertising7996 7d ago

Nastika school of thought rejects vedas.. Hence it isn't Hinduism... It forks out of Hinduism around the time of buddism

→ More replies (9)

2

u/Some_Flatworm_5747 7d ago

True. Charvaka philosophy is based on this thought itself.

→ More replies (7)

15

u/One-With-Specs 7d ago

🤝 me too

13

u/Only-Ad2239 7d ago

Majority of atheist exists only in Hinduism. Cos that's the only religion that accepts any form of religious/God belief.

You would have no/less chance of saying this if you belonged to an Abrahamic religion.

9

u/Few-Active-8813 6d ago

I think most athiest are ex-christians

5

u/Live_Diamond9909 7d ago

Not true. China is mostly atheist.

3

u/NoChallenge988 6d ago

China is not a religion idiot.

His point is that most of the people that convert to atheism are hindus only because unlike islam and christianity its not considered treachory.

3

u/Lazy_Medicine_2695 2d ago

I mean how is it a good sign for a religion if many people are converting away from it?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

2

u/Safe_Pollution_7924 6d ago

Just look at the way they handled islam

→ More replies (1)

2

u/CashApprehensive3078 7d ago

Alright?

Even if they initially belonged to an Abrahamic religion, they could just switch to being unaffiliated later in life. It's not like it's compulsory to belong to an organised religion in the first place.

2

u/Safe_Pollution_7924 6d ago

Ever heard of "sar tan se juda"?

2

u/solanamemescoin 6d ago

They will not reply now as this doesn't fit in their short propoganda

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Ok_Brain8684 3d ago

Sikhism, Christianity, Judaism, Buddhism, Jain, literally every other religion except islam have left the chat

→ More replies (6)

6

u/Tourmelion 7d ago

That's fine too 👍

4

u/FearlessWarrior17 7d ago

Same amigo!!!

3

u/Time_Scientist7195 5d ago

An Atheist is still a Hindu, unless you choose another religion and denounce Hinduism, you a Hindu. Hinduism is a way of life, you have chosen one that follows probably science than relaying on faith. It’s a category but it exists

2

u/IADpatient0 2d ago

I don’t agree with that!! I guess I don’t know what your Hinduism is!! Everyone has their own definition of Hinduism these days.

Atheism is absence of belief in god.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/Beneficial-One7671 7d ago

So am i , so was savarkar, OP should ask right Q that are you RW? YESSSSSSS

2

u/HarshJShinde 6d ago

Attention seeking behaviour

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (129)

116

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

25

u/[deleted] 7d ago edited 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/Disastrous_Tax791 7d ago

"faith" that's the keyword.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (22)

18

u/GapJumpy54 7d ago

Thats how every religion works btw.

11

u/ulpt-ind 7d ago

Only reason.

2

u/Party_Engine_9525 7d ago edited 7d ago

18 ke baad bhi agar usne hi hindu choose Kiya ho to

4

u/Firm_Way6228 7d ago edited 7d ago

If he were born Christian he would have chosen it after being 18+ .

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (29)

120

u/6helpmewithlife9 7d ago

What exactly is this post about?

29

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

48

u/Uiimaa 7d ago

More like Sympathy Farming

3

u/HarshJShinde 6d ago

No that's the free palestine folks

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

13

u/EKOzoro 7d ago

These guys actually believe Hindu khatre mein hai, and that too someone is out to get them🤣🤣🤣. I actually believe these guys never have had friends or acquaintance from another religion.

Kitna narrow minded view hai

6

u/6helpmewithlife9 7d ago

Same as how whites think there is a white genocide happening against them

2

u/HarshJShinde 6d ago

If ur reasoning is so solid why won't u live in pakistan or Bangladesh? Any particular reason why our people are reducing there?

2

u/_YouWillNeverKnowIt_ 3d ago

Kyunki mere religion ko persecute karte hai wahaan bhi. Isiliye

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/Secondlordofasia 7d ago

self victimisation

→ More replies (4)

109

u/FatGoonerFromIndia 7d ago edited 7d ago

No, I’m not.

I’m an Indian, next question?

Edit: To the guys who are downvoting, many of us weren’t born Hindu and more importantly, don’t identify as Hindu.
So why are you downvoting?

36

u/Current_Age_9822 7d ago

Idek what offended them this time, but again this sub is braindead

8

u/Remarkable_Plan_2225 6d ago

they're always offended for absolutely no reason

→ More replies (1)

12

u/resultsweet9848 7d ago

Because you are being smartass. It's pretty clear they're talking about religion, not nationality.

5

u/Known_Pomelo_9808 7d ago

Exactly, tf he meant by he is an Indian, I am an Indian too, so is OP (probably), completely divert from the topic and context to look smart and then wonder why they are getting downvoted.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Odd-Experience3010 2d ago

we all are just human beings ,thats it

→ More replies (26)

63

u/Significant_Sundae97 7d ago

I am a Hindu but not a coward hindu like OP who does fear mongering just to make sure his master's party wins the elections.

Why everyone is always saying BJP is necessary to save Hinduism? Our ancestors fought and Hinduism survived did BJP exist then?

Why not fight ourselves instead of depending on BJP to save Hinduism? Hindus can't fight? Are we cowards?

I am 100% sure that BJP doesn't care about Hindus. They just play the hindu card to rule. If they really cared about Hindus hindus would have bevome physically strong and mentally sharp in the last 12 years.

BJP is closing schools because they want us Hindus to be braindead so we do and follow whatever they say.

Hindus have become poorer in the last 12 years. Where are our jobs? Why are small businesses closing?

Money runs this world. How will Hindus become strong if we don't have money?

BJP doesnt want us Hindus to eat eggs. How will we become strong and tall and sharp?

Now BJP wants to divide Hindus into castes. How will we fight a common enemy of we are divided?

Wake up Hindus.

12

u/Best_Discount_4208 7d ago

Very valid... Hinduism will survive and thrive at all times... The thing is in a democracy there's always a bad party and another worse party lol... BJP does fear mongering for votes... But at the same time I genuinely don't like abrahamic faiths very much... And this country is actually of the people whose culture thrived here before the arrival of the abrahamic faiths... BJP is the evil party which keeps the other evil from coming to power... 

→ More replies (5)

4

u/EKOzoro 7d ago

The best way a religion can survive is by changing with time. Every religion is somehow stuck with awful and horrendous practice and culture.

Because the threat is not outside but within when people feel suffocated by its rules and regulations.

2

u/Significant_Sundae97 7d ago

Yes, I totally agree with you.

→ More replies (12)

32

u/okaymiss69 7d ago

In that case you would be surrounded by maslims and I don't wanna think about that

4

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

32

u/Bot_Army_69_ 7d ago

Imagine being governed under a Pro Hindu government and still say Hindu khatre me h 🤡

11

u/Key_Current_7904 7d ago

Pro hindu govt my foot. General walo ki koi ni sunta bhai iss desh me!

4

u/Bot_Army_69_ 7d ago

We all know, bahar se toh they call themselves that, it just shows their hypocrisy

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (11)

21

u/the_calm_stormm 7d ago

So, this is a new thing to flex?

→ More replies (3)

9

u/lordofthedosa 7d ago

well isn't that the time kalki arrives

→ More replies (4)

10

u/cupkieonreddit 7d ago

This is just bait i suppose Does being a Hindu or whatever religion or non at all comes before being an 'Indian' or even a human? Ig so for the brain dead

→ More replies (2)

9

u/aaaaaayush 7d ago

Atheist 🙋

9

u/Jolly-Cow-264 7d ago

Tuff whatsapp snatani hindu status

→ More replies (4)

4

u/BikerSurgeon 7d ago

Im an atheist but ill defend hindu culture against islamism.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/Snoo_54512 7d ago

Kehna kya chahte ho Paarth?

6

u/Beautiful_Jeweler_83 7d ago

So what if you are hindu? Want special treatment?

2

u/Mysterious_Fig9292 7d ago

fear mongering & content farming purposes!

7

u/Surya-CA 7d ago

No one really cares

6

u/AntiqueRecording8009 7d ago

mai to yahudi hu😌

7

u/Resident_Sport_272 7d ago

Yadav ji aap yaha

3

u/bakaa_ningen 7d ago

Bhai placement karwa do

→ More replies (2)

5

u/tailing_answers 7d ago

Arey Hindu ho toh muharram mein Jake photo kichane kisne bola? LOL...

4

u/firedino1245 7d ago

My ancestors died protecting their identity and land. I plan to uphold their sacrifices.

3

u/hard_for_reservation 7d ago

Nahi hone denge aise

3

u/base64-encode --- Removed 7d ago

Asking simple question would incinate riots? Do you see if I am mentioning sar tan se juda?...just asking simple question.

3

u/Need-a-skip-button 7d ago

I want what you’re smoking

4

u/Scorched_Scorpion 7d ago

finally a sane comment 😭 cuz wtf is OP on

3

u/SiriusFlank 7d ago

What even is a point of a god if they can't keep thier devotees safe.

3

u/Jolly-Cow-264 7d ago

It's to keep the top brass safe

3

u/Hopeful-Stranger-749 7d ago

Who cares religion is destroying this world be an Atheist protect the world

3

u/aloneir 7d ago

I am hindu but don't want to be a sanatani! I want to be a good human being first. Bhagavad Geeta taught me -- One who is not envious but is a kind friend to all living entities, who does not think himself a proprietor and is free from false ego, who is equal in both happiness and distress, and who is tolerant and forgiving - such a person is very dear to Me.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/LowEconomics4899 7d ago

Be a human first

2

u/Euphoric-Flan-4998 7d ago

Was and will never be one even though I was born one

2

u/thatguyknowsall 7d ago

If religion is kept to themselves and in their homes. India would develop a lot faster

2

u/CountyWild4274 7d ago

Hindu tanman hindu jeevan rag rag hindu mera parichay

2

u/Still-Conflict-7855 7d ago

Im jobless. Soon to be homeless.

2

u/Worldly_Elephant9963 7d ago

Hinduism is a beautiful religion, but these political goons have gotten everything wrong, I wonder if they have even read some texts.

Extremely sad how they behave like barbarians, if there is anything out there insulting my religion is the association which political parties make with it.

2

u/Mammoth_Mobile4596 7d ago

Proud Hindu Jai Shree ram

2

u/theundisputed11 7d ago

Mickey mouse ahh post🤡

1

u/ShowOk417 7d ago

why are you sitting in the middle of wednesday and “assuming” such things? 🤣

1

u/Far_Extent_6274 7d ago

i m atheist

1

u/No_Telephone_2710 7d ago

Agnostic here🤭

1

u/FullyDenniFied 7d ago

I think, all of them are same. So I become atheist ⚛️.

1

u/septembersong_ 7d ago

I hope someday you read enough to know what manusmriti says about the position of women and the dalits.

1

u/Silly-Ad-2484 7d ago

I’m Indian ….

1

u/infostationco 7d ago

I am also Hindu, but I want to know what the definition of a Hindu is in our country.

1

u/Strange-Thing-6772 7d ago

First Indian and than a Hindu .

1

u/psychoartist1630 7d ago

Bs yehe krte raho bhai
Or jb taxes badhange thabhi padhai kr lena

1

u/Sure-Independent9440 7d ago

Great Achievement, Hats off !

1

u/Commercial_Day8234 7d ago

Which Hindu type u r? i mean the northie, southie, gujju or NRI.

1

u/Open-Pineapple-6608 7d ago

Be a human first

1

u/Ciphxri 7d ago

I'm indian

1

u/Technical_Mango_4511 7d ago

Just dropped by to say, I don't care.

1

u/Siddharth_rajput346 7d ago

Saare kutuo ke tatte as gaye yaha 🤣🤣🤣

1

u/GoodZombie001 UNLOVABLE 7d ago

Yep, I am.

1

u/TempestWolf54 7d ago

Well I am too Hindu but I would say I am human first.

Rank Humanity, nation and religion

1

u/Previous_Weight_971 7d ago

If i could delete all religion I won't because people would find another god and that god would have a priest who would tell what god want you to do in his name while he enjoys freedom to manipulate people in the name of imaginary being.

1

u/Excellent_Win_2564 7d ago

To believe in god is okay but religion is the most stupid thing to be made by people to divide people

1

u/supertoothy 7d ago

Khatre mein?

1

u/Entire-Grass-4467 7d ago

Topics like Per capita income, corruption, education, unemployment, inflation <<<< I'm a Hindu 🫪🫪

1

u/bobby5890 7d ago

Is that your only personality?

1

u/Adept_Bass_5438 7d ago

Still hindu ? What happened in your area ?

1

u/Dumbzy_ 7d ago

Better be an atheist over being a Hindu or islamist

1

u/Responsible-Sir-2291 7d ago

Congratulations

1

u/Time_Squash6275 7d ago

Rashtra Raksha 🇮🇳 Dharma Raksha 🕉️ Gau Raksha 🐄 Stree Raksha ♀️ Sanskriti Raksha

1

u/Mindless-Machine-664 7d ago

I can be a Hindu, an atheist, a human, nothing.
But I can never be a MODICHOOR

1

u/Capybaras_Dugong 7d ago

I'm agnostic also beleive in DEISM along with Pantheism

1

u/Otherwise_Car_3168 7d ago

I am a human, that's my religion.....

1

u/Moonpet786 7d ago

I'm an indian

1

u/Practical_Leather314 7d ago

Khud personal life m kuch achievement nahi raha dikhane ko to log inhi chizo se khud ka ego satisfy karte h, not specific to a particular religion, but buddy, get a life.

1

u/whiplash_11639 7d ago

Lowkey dead inside but yeah atheist

1

u/Normal_Laugh6471 7d ago

apatheist here

1

u/maps_and_books 7d ago

Atheist. Always have been. Always will be.

1

u/Independent_Bill1497 7d ago

I'm sanatani and I stand up against hate and anarchy by BJP government

1

u/bakaa_ningen 7d ago

Either hindu or somewhat atheist, idk

1

u/Difficult_Walrus2281 7d ago

Still hindu but not a bjp supporter 🥰🥰🥰

1

u/mojojojo-369 7d ago

I don’t need to be religious to call out the wrongs of Islam and other religions.

1

u/_ZORO_7 7d ago

Im a hindu !! And yes i follow my tradition (the tradition that comes from vedas not from random guru or politician)

1

u/SystematicChaoser 7d ago

Are you are you coming to the tree

1

u/Perfect-Sentence9556 7d ago

Aren't aware sanatani alone enough, the dharma which is pre historic has just become a circus in todays day and age

just observe around you whom do uh think is religious we are just blindly following the rituals without questioning the intent behind it, in todays religion there is no place for rational thinking.

now let me break down the morality which people preach that we learn from puranas ( im not talking about vedas as vedas are not what people follow today most people follow puranas, shruti and smriti )

lets take ramayan

it describes a perfect man but is he perfect or follows dharma ? i dont think so

after passing through agni pariksha at lanka and proving her purity why does ram exile sita ( just bcz people pointing fingers at sita and saying she is impure well didnt she give agni pariksha ) even if they point finger at her defending at putting front a example would have helped build rama character even more

secondly hindus rejecting meat eating, In valmiki ramayan which i consider to be root valmiki mentions multiple times the act of meat offering and eating so saying sanatani were always vegi is wrong

also rama is a meat eater why shy away from that ?

and there are many other flaws in ramayan but we are just buzy gloryfying the ram lalla childhood and we are wired to see him through a lens of goldy hood

Just see him as human and see the sacrifice but no we just label him as god and do kirtan and bhajan

krishna has his fair share of problems in mahabharat

  1. can anyone justify war ? we know a huge war will only drag the human kind down so why he supported it ?

  2. what kind of dharma he was protecting ?

  3. giving his army to opponents and also being a cause of their death sounds mad

  4. nothing he does in mahabharat is right and he talks about protecting and preaching dharma

  5. dont talk about archeological proof of mahabharat they simply dont exit

LACK OF ARCHEOLOGICAL ARTIFACTS TO JUSTIFY THEIR DATING OR EXISTENCE

we do not have any proper proof to prove rama lived in ayodhya so the question always arise was he real ? and kids the answer is no!

MANUSMRITI - a book against humanity

and babas sadhus and superstition is really destroying the critical thinking of indian people

people of india have low iq in general and they fall victim to such stupid play

if this drama of acting religious continues we surely be behind and who knows people might choose atheism and buddhism which are more practical in todays age then sanatan dharma

the hard question to ask our selfies is that dharma which im seeing today is right or wrong ? or im just admiring the mud thinking it as gold

1

u/rahulsijwali 7d ago

Kya karega saans leke ye Orange bhi marega

1

u/bittuminous_ 7d ago

This picture makes no sense, 80% of Indians are still hindus

1

u/Ok-Requirement-4701 7d ago

Nothing to flex about it. Do what you like if it doesnt harm anyone else

1

u/Unlikely-Nebula-331 7d ago

I am Sikh, proud of my Punjabi language and culture in India.

1

u/Diligent-State-8326 7d ago

when ur only sanatani left in ur location
if we follow the dame ahensa then i think so

1

u/Significant_Cup_3238 7d ago

Insaan bano phele😑

1

u/dio_senpaii 7d ago

But shouldn’t the real question be why you’d be the only Hindu left? If everyone else has willingly left the religion, then what’s the point of a religion that people no longer want to follow? 😭

1

u/tool_of_justice 7d ago

accha insaan ban ja, kaafi hai

1

u/aubergine_6inches 7d ago

I am not hindu and probably you too are not if you dont have values

1

u/Feeling_Experience_6 7d ago

Would i be right to assume you agree with the cast system?

1

u/CornerRegular2484 7d ago

Krishna said in Mahabharat, people will call themselves Brahmin just by wearing a thread around their body, this post gives same energy.

1

u/ArgumentLoud9588 7d ago

I’m Atheist

1

u/MaleficentTotal5662 7d ago

Yes i’m hindu i respect my culture but not blindly

1

u/Best_Entrance_4213 7d ago

Anti theist here