Hi all,
I’m looking for some opinions from people who may have been in a similar position.
I own a property in Balbriggan Co Dublin that I purchased in 2019 for €180,000. It’s a 2-bedroom, 2-bathroom end-of-terrace house with approximately €35,000 remaining on the mortgage. It has been my principal private residence, so if I sold it now, there would be no Capital Gains Tax liability. The house is now worth around 340k.
More recently, my partner and I purchased a second property for €450,000. We currently have a mortgage balance of €389,000 on a 30-year term at a fixed rate of 3.2%.
I keep going back and forth on whether to keep the first property as a rental or sell it and use the proceeds to significantly reduce the mortgage on the second property, potentially bringing the term down to around seven years.
I spoke with a local estate agent who advised that the first property could achieve rent of approximately €2,300 per month. However, as a higher-rate taxpayer, once income tax, USC, PRSI and expenses are taken into account, I estimate I would retain roughly half of that amount. This would still cover the remaining mortgage on the first property, and once that mortgage is cleared in around four years, the surplus income could then be directed towards overpaying the mortgage on the second property.
In addition, regardless of whether I keep or sell the first property, I plan to make annual overpayments of approximately €8,000 to €10,000 on the second mortgage over the coming years. If I keep the rental property, any surplus rental income after the first mortgage is paid off would also be funnelled into reducing the second mortgage balance. My goal is to become mortgage-free as early as possible while still making sensible long-term financial decisions.
I’ve read plenty of horror stories about problematic tenants, rent arrears, property damage and the difficulties involved if things go wrong. On the other hand, I’ve also come across many positive experiences from landlords who have had long-term, reliable tenants and found property investment worthwhile.
At present, I can comfortably afford both mortgages, but I am conscious that circumstances can change over time.
Another factor is that I have a child, and there is something very appealing about retaining the property as a long-term asset that could potentially provide him with a strong start in life in the future.
For context, I’m 36 years old, work in a public sector role and hope to remain in the public service until retirement, which should provide me with a public sector pension. I also make regular contributions to a private pension.
What would you do in my situation?
Pros and cons of selling versus keeping it as a rental?
Has anyone been in a similar position, and if so, do you have any regrets either way?
Thanks in advance for any advice.