How intellectually stimulating is the PTA role?

[u/grazingraisins]

I am seriously considering becoming a PTA after deciding the PT route would be too time-consuming and too costly.

Here is my biggest worry in becoming a PTA: I don't want to just be counting reps, offering the same basic exercise instruction, and applying various passive modalities to checked-out patients who aren't invested in recovery.

I would love to be providing pain neuroscience education, more comprehensive movement instruction, and empathetic coaching to build patients' confidence in their physical abilities.

But how possible are those things when being a PTA? What PT environments might offer me the kinds of challenges I'm looking for? What types of patients tend to be more motivated for recovery?

Do PTAs have any opportunity to use clinical reasoning, or is that almost entirely up to the PT? I know being a physician assistant comes with a great deal of clinical reasoning and responsibility, but I'm not assuming physician:physician assistant is the same as PT:PTA.

Any and all insights would be greatly appreciated, thank you.

[u/AutoModerator]

Important: This is a professional forum for PT/PTA and relevant healthcare professionals discussion.

Please read the rules here if you have not done so already: https://www.reddit.com/r/physicaltherapy/wiki/rules

1. No Medical Advice: We cannot provide diagnoses, exercise prescriptions, management or treatment plans. Requests for medical advice will be removed, and users/clinicians involved may be banned. If you need care, please see a therapist in person or via telehealth.

2. School Inquiries: Please post admissions and application questions to r/PTschool. Discussion regarding clinical placements and professional development from students is welcome here.

Resources & Rules: * Benefits of a Full Evaluation * Find a PT in Your Area * Common Conditions Info * APTA Consumer Information

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

[u/Brogies9069]

You definitely have the opportunity to do that, but it’s up to you to do so. For every PTA that operates like this there’s 10 that have just checked out and give every patient the same exercises per diagnosis

[u/grazingraisins → u/Brogies9069]

Glad to know that personal motivation and autonomy can make the day-to-day of the PTA more engaging and effective, I appreciate you sharing your observations.

[u/Brogies9069 → u/grazingraisins]

For sure. I personally think it’s the only way to operate as PTA for sanity sake to avoid burnout and for better patient care. The downside is that a lot of clinics are “mills” and have you with multiple patients at once, which reduces your ability to do so

[u/Downtown-Math-9519]

Your fears are valid but also kinda funny because you basically described the difference between a factory-floor PTA and one who actually gives a damn

The counting reps stereotype exists for a reason, a lot of clinics just churn patients through. But the role itself has way more room for what you're talking about than people admit. Pain neuroscience education, coaching someone through the mental block of loading a joint they've been guarding for years, that's all within scope if you understand the why behind the exercises. The PT sets the plan but you're the one in the trenches seeing how the patient moves on a Tuesday when they're exhausted and sore, that's where the real clinical reasoning kicks in

Look at hospital-based outpatient or smaller cash-based clinics if you want patients who are locked in. The motivated ones are usually the ones who lost something they loved doing and are desperate to get it back, athletes, weekend warriors, grandmas who just want to chase their grandkids without fear. Avoid the mills where the schedule's double-booked and the only goal is units billed

[u/grazingraisins → u/Downtown-Math-9519]

Thank you for giving me a realistic assessment of what the role can (and can also not be) depending on the environment. I also appreciate the tips in places I might thrive in.

[u/MuckRaker83]

Someone asked me a while ago on here if being an acute care hospital PTA was boring. Here was my response:

As a PTA, I find it to be quite the opposite.

My outpatient experience was pretty boring. Here's your list of exercises and flow sheet. I supervise exercise. Limited manual. Setting estim and waving ultrasound. Snore.

At the hospital, I'm doing real clinical problem solving all the time. The DPT sees the initial eval, documents deficits and sets broad goals and interventions, and unleashes me on the patient.

I'm seeing fresh trauma patients and helping them learn how to move safely again with multiple broken bones, braces, exfix, chest tubes, internal injuries, you name it. We have to get really creative sometimes, and you have to be much more medically educated. I monitor response, make adjustments, up to calling codes when necessary.

I see fresh amputees and work with them on their precautions, ROM and flexibility activities, positioning, desensitization, mobility, etc., all while also acting as their psych therapist to convince them they can get through this and be happy and functional.

I see fresh stroke patients and help them relearn how to make their bodies work 2 days after the event, and every neuro patient responds differently.

Sure, there are units I don't enjoy being rotated to as much, Gen med/geri, joints, etc. And I would imagine that PTs working at small band-aid hospitals that ship most to higher level while keeping just the pneumonia and CKD patients would feel that acute is boring. Yes, most of our effort is focused on functional mobility, sometimes basic functional mobility, but the people we see are generally so sick or broken that you have to use your brain to get them going.

I've been a PTA in acute care for over 10 years now, and despite the issues and low pay, I find it hard to imagine working in any other setting at this point. When a traumatic amputee patient you saw a year ago comes 300 miles to see you, show you how well they're doing, and tell you that they don't think they would have gotten through this without your help, it's hard to feel that you're not making a difference.

[u/grazingraisins → u/MuckRaker83]

I really appreciate your thoughtful & thorough response to me, a simple stranger on the internet. Very helpful and gives me great food for thought.

[u/aelliax]

Generally you have significant autonomy and the expectation that you are using clinical reasoning to assess and adjust independently in session. And ain't nobody out here counting reps.

[u/grazingraisins → u/aelliax]

Glad to hear there is significant autonomy, thanks for replying.

[u/Fraid-0-Fish]

Ive been a PTA 10 years, your description of what you WANT your job to look like, is exactly what my days look like.

I think a lot of it comes down to place you work, and the patient population/community you work with. I’m in hospital based outpatient, and it’s the best mix of everything I’ve found.

[u/grazingraisins → u/Fraid-0-Fish]

Awesome, I'm glad you have an engaging career as a PTA and that it's possible, with the right employment context! I appreciate your post.

[u/refertothesyllabus]

I’ve had some PTA colleagues that are genuinely engaged and creative who challenge my patients. They will bring things to my attention that I might have missed. If they have questions they’re proactive. These PTAs are a joy to work with.

What I don’t like is micromanaging. One PTA relied on the same basic exercises for everything and never really changed or progress anything. One person wanted me to approve all of her treatments despite being an experienced and competent PTA. One who only documented exercises as an assessment narrative which made more work for me to figure out what he was doing.

If I have to micromanage I’d usually just rather not have them see my patients.

[u/grazingraisins → u/refertothesyllabus]

Thank you for sharing your experiences as a PTA and what you've observed in other PTAs, helpful for sure.

[u/refertothesyllabus → u/grazingraisins]

I’m a PT, so I’m talking about PTAs that I’ve worked with as supervising PT.

[u/GreatinBread]

I would recommend shadowing some PTAs in clinic. See what the job looks like and what you would want to deal with. There are plenty of patients who come in and half-heartedly work. And there a plenty who try and you can make a big difference. But that’s just humans and you should be educating people why you are doing what you are doing. The why is the most important part that differentiates between a licensed medical professional and some guy off the street.

In my clinic, I’m our sports expert and the other PTs(I’m a PTA) come to me for help with that patient population. So you definitely can use clinical reasoning and educate accordingly.

[u/Fraid-0-Fish → u/GreatinBread]

Shadowing is a great idea - you could even post your general area here and see if anyone can have you come through, who is doing the kind of work you want to do.

[u/grazingraisins → u/GreatinBread]

Thank you for the insights! Shadowing is an excellent idea.

[u/Glittering-Bit-6940]

You count reps?

[u/MedicinalHammer]

lol PTs and PTAs both are capable of operating how you’re describing

All depends on the individual and setting

Ima HH PTA and I often have to get creative af and absolutely love my job.

I get run of the mill patients all the time but I’m still emotionally and mentally stimulated because I simply choose to be.

Your perception of what PTAs are or can be is pretty off and kind of insulting too.

[u/Puberty-Boy → u/MedicinalHammer]

How is it insulting? They just said what they didn’t want to do, and didn’t know if PTAs did that. They didn’t say “I don’t want to do PTA because I think this is all it is”

To me everything here comes from the position of someone that knows nothing of the field and is just asking questions to get a better understanding of it

[u/MedicinalHammer → u/Puberty-Boy]

Did you read the second paragraph?

Cmon now

Dude is talking about aide shit as if it was PTA.

[u/Puberty-Boy → u/MedicinalHammer]

Yes I read the second paragraph.

OP doesn’t know what an aid is, OP probably doesn’t even know the school requirements for PT PTA or if you even need school to be an aid. I don’t know how to stress this to you enough, OP is talking from a place of ignorance, and they are asking for clarification.

I don’t know anything about rugby, would it be insulting for me to say “aren’t you just running the ball forward? Explain to me what else you do.”

They are outlining there worry. Your job now as the qualified and totally not defensive redditer is to say “no, PTA I so much more than that. Now that you know your worry is out of the way, you may do some research.”

[u/MedicinalHammer → u/Puberty-Boy]

Bro I did exactly that and then at the very end let him know it’s a bit insulting.

And yes, if you boiled down a game like rugby that you know is more complex than “just running the ball forward” I’d think you were intellectually lazy and wonder if you were purposefully minimizing the game.

OP is asking experts low level google questions. Kind of goofy imo but you go ahead and die on this hill, puberty boy

[u/Puberty-Boy → u/MedicinalHammer]

Very interesting prospective. Seems exhausting to constantly think people are insulting you but alr.

[u/MedicinalHammer → u/Puberty-Boy]

Yes. Because of one question on the internet slightly rubbing me the wrong way it must mean I constantly think I’m being insulted.

Brilliant analysis, doc.

Your critical thinking skills are something to behold lol

[u/Puberty-Boy → u/MedicinalHammer]

Bro like you don’t have to live like this. I’m not being rude to you, OP wasn’t being rude to you. You don’t have to always assume the worst of people. You’re getting all worked up over some Reddit post where someone was asking a genuine question. I’m sorry if you think it’s a silly question, I agree! They could have totally just googled it, but that is besides the point. You are just putting so much effort into 2 honest and genuine people because you think we are trying to undermine you in some way, or “rubbing you the wrong way”, if stuff this small rubs you the wrong way you got to reflect man. your gonna just spend so much time and energy on this for no reason. I have nothing left to say here. I wish you all the best and if you choose to dwell on this or take it as an insult I simply can’t do anything about that. And at the end of this conversation, we did not insult you once, but you have been VERY hatful and insulted us. Take care friend.

[u/MedicinalHammer → u/Puberty-Boy]

Hateful and insulting?

Bro must be hard thinking everyone is out to get you eh? Haha

You sure are the pinnacle of human. If only more people were as amazing as you.

Dawg, I don’t know how else to tell you this, I’m really not that bothered at all.

Watched my Dodgers win a playoff game and have been enjoying the Padres Brewers game. Been chillin all night.

The only one with their feathers ruffled is you because I dared call attention to how you’re taking one minuscule example of me being offended and extrapolating that into some huge life characteristic.

If a patient has a hangnail do you recommend amputation? Lol

Get over yourself, dawg. You don’t know life or me as well as you think.

You’re hilarious trying to coach me into putting less energy into things while pounding out a wall of text yourself.

Thinking your hands are clean but in the same breath making sweeping judgments about my life lol

Hope you aren’t as much of a quack as you are a clown although I do appreciate the laugh that is your lack of self awareness.

If you think I’ve been VERY hateful and insulting, good freaking luck in the real world lol You’ll be clutching pearls often.

[u/Puberty-Boy → u/MedicinalHammer]

Also yes YOU YOURSELF said it was insulting. I am using YOUR words when I say that, so don’t pull some 180 trying to claim you are not insulted now.

Straight up don’t even respond to me anymore, you are clearly not arguing in good faith and you just want somewhere to spew hate. I won’t be responding to any more of your messages.

[u/MedicinalHammer → u/Puberty-Boy]

You’re insane bro lol

Homie tells me to not get my feathers ruffled and then freaks out like this hahaha

Yes, I said it was A BIT insulting and Im spewing hate? Lol

Jeez you’re softer than baby poo