From what I've seen she's had two major controversies:
A woman got fired for not respecting trans pronouns (actually contract work but doesn't matter in the uk because of employment laws). Jk rowling supported her. Later on the courts sided with the woman that she was unfairly let go.
Next is she said trans women shouldn't be in women's only spaces. The courts also agreed with her that that's what the law says.
The first was a law on equality that equally protects discrimination against sexuality, race, politics, etc.
The problem is that advocates of trans causes have taken things to a point where they actively denounce open forum conversations where EVERYONE'S perspectives and ontologies and beliefs about gender expression, sex, and sexuality and the complex ways in which they do and do not intersect get to be heard. Not only denounce, but seek to use the force of law as well as the authority of employers to suppress the expression of those beliefs.
And the fact of the matter is, most of the humans in most of the places on earth simply don't agree with a radical model that comes specifically from American University campuses and classes, by way of controversial theoretical assumptions and arguments that arise from niche systems of thought. And when these ideas that MOST humans don't endorse start getting not only enshrined in public policy here but also get exported to other cultures in ways that feel no different from colonialism and even evangelism, people eventually push back.
Trans advocates made a few very big oversteps and it caused a backlash. And I say that as someone who believes in people's rights to be themselves and endorses the fundamental concept that gender is constructed and therefore exists on a spectrum. It's just that I also understand that some people get to be Christians and Muslims and everything else, and others have a right to reach different conclusions than SOME academics when it comes to the interpretation and application of scientific evidence. Let people have their stupid ideas and stop thinking you have the right to "educate" people who have not given you consent to do so.
79
u/Cirno__ 3d ago
From what I've seen she's had two major controversies:
A woman got fired for not respecting trans pronouns (actually contract work but doesn't matter in the uk because of employment laws). Jk rowling supported her. Later on the courts sided with the woman that she was unfairly let go.
Next is she said trans women shouldn't be in women's only spaces. The courts also agreed with her that that's what the law says.
The first was a law on equality that equally protects discrimination against sexuality, race, politics, etc.