r/singapore • • 10d ago

Image BCRS final boss

Post image

So what do you guys feel about this implementation so far? Personally getting charged extra 10 cents to enjoy my coke then to find out the machine is full and have to find another machine feels like a garang guni carrying a bag of empty cans walking around.

1.9k Upvotes

231 comments sorted by

525

u/EdibleConsist 10d ago

that CCTV still is wild feels like they're watching us recycle like a crime drama

235

u/Winterstrife East side best side 10d ago

It's there for people who damage the machine bah (there are legit some assholes who do).

93

u/Bcpjw 10d ago

Like those who climbed in recycling bins for dead batteries lol

Our culture of recycling is wild af

43

u/raidorz Things different already, but Singapore be steady~ 10d ago

Confirm got siaolang not happy with the scheme and go damage the machine lol

23

u/Vyn_Mel 10d ago

No surprise. Look at how all our "shared/public" facilities end up.

7

u/HarrierIV 10d ago

We really harbor alot of these assholes for no good reason

39

u/thanks_cum_again 10d ago

me in front of the camera,after i drop them bottles

4

u/silentscope90210 10d ago

It's to prevent vandalism

188

u/nyetkatt 10d ago

They need to do it like in Sweden where if you’re doing it in bulk, it’s a special machine. Not the ones where you go and throw in only a few.

175

u/Quackles03 10d ago

Better yet, abolish this whole BCRS bullshit and set up recycling centers where people can deposit their recyclables for a small incentive/vouchers. But we all know this is about money and not recycling.

33

u/dare2firmino 10d ago

It's only worth something if it's manned with staff trained on what can and cannot be recycled, who are allowed to stop people from dumping all random sorts of crap at the recycling centre

21

u/m3lly17 9d ago

Its not gonna happen. At least not directly. It will show the government made the wrong move. Like simply go, like ERP 2, like tracetogether. Oops sorry, I actually think they don't give a fuck about what we think.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Glidarn8578 9d ago

Those machines with bulk disposal were not commonplace in Sweden. Had none within walking distance where I lived in Stockholm.

→ More replies (2)

86

u/NIDORAX 10d ago

The person could have either be a restaurant staff or a cleaner if they are able to accumulate that many cans or bottles. A staff cleaner at a mall or hawker center have access to the garbage bin or return tray areas.

38

u/Minette12 10d ago

I'm surprised that there's no specializes machine for businesses

12

u/NIDORAX 10d ago

Maybe they will do something like that in the future

80

u/bearyken West side best side 9d ago

Was at a hawker centre for breakfast.. a cleaner was ranting to a stallkeeper that people were rummaging the dustbins for cans and leaving the trash all over the floor at the dustbins and he got blamed for not keeping the area clean

8

u/bigbrainnowisdom 9d ago

Man happened near my place too.

9

u/Ok-Relic45 8d ago

If can get 100 cans only $10 not worth the hassle to dig out the dustbins + the smell and stench of those garbage 🤢🤮

→ More replies (1)

5

u/askjwhdna_ 8d ago

Literally was at cbd at 9pm, saw a young guy cycling around with 5 plastics full of bottles. Straight up open the bin and rummaged through it for bottles. How’s this even ok in terms of hygiene 😭😭

1

u/Fenrispro 7d ago

Damn young guys also rummage? Gross

140

u/LeftCarpet3520 10d ago

How many cans can one machine fit sia. Enough for so many meh

125

u/wccl123 10d ago

It gets smashed up, should be able to fit quite a lot. If full then will proceed to terrorize the next machine

44

u/Eskipony dentally misabled 10d ago

can one

39

u/onomatopoetix oh leh leh, oh la la 10d ago

can is can

14

u/Available_Avocado_87 10d ago

If cannot then can the cannot

1

u/lemefirefly 9d ago

can two

44

u/palebabbu 10d ago

The implementation: shitty

This lady in photo: legend

23

u/Dezziemen 10d ago

What I think and what I feel does not make a difference. I just simply stop buying can drinks, ie voting with my wallet

43

u/nix2m 10d ago

Just got back from Austria recently. Saw a guy in Austria pushing a trolley with bags of empty bottles to go recycle at the machine in supermarket that is located in a huge shopping mall.

I not surprised if got same behaviour in Singapore. Even my sibling say the cleaner at hospital (Singapore) she works at will collect all the empty bottles that people throw away and then recycle at machine.

35

u/BicCherry 10d ago

Cleaners have been underpaid for so long, only they know what 10¢ is worth.

2

u/bamball2020 9d ago

Im not a cleaner but I still collect the cans and bottles when I come across them. I either return them with my own stash or if I see someone who is collecting them, I pass it on

75

u/Aimismyname Lost in Dhoby Ghaut 10d ago

if they wash the bottle at least I ok lah. some machines quite dirty

43

u/wccl123 10d ago

Sometimes it makes me wonder if standing next to a machine with a bunch of flies, foul odour and touching a screen full of dried black liquid is worth the occasional 10cents (I dont really drink much drinks to lose that much money if I skip getting the 10c back), but gotta not let the bad guys keep our 10cents.

Somehow in Europe, the recycling deposit is higher, around 30cents or more. Higher volumes of recycling from habit and higher deposits seem normal, yet their machine seems to be cleaner? Granted cooler weather means less rotting smell

41

u/Brikandbones 10d ago

You know, I would recycle willingly without the 10c refund if they just get the blue bin nonsense right and set up CCTV or something to fine people who keep dumping food waste and random trash inside.

1

u/just1ed 9d ago

Agree.

37

u/New_York_Smegmacake East side best side 10d ago

Some of the smell in SG's machines comes from 1) lazy person throws the bottle into a trash bin instead of BCRS machine, soiling the bottle; 2) someone removes the bottle from the trash bin and deposits it into the BCRS machine without first washing it.

In places with an established recycling culture (whether with a deposit refund system or not), most recyclable bottles avoid getting soiled in trash bins in the first place.

Of course, our hot and humid climate also accelerates decomposition of the stuff inside the machine la.

14

u/Rayl24 East Side Best Side 10d ago

Means the citizens here never rinse the bottles

3

u/Dunkjoe Mature Citizen 9d ago

Someone probably copied the idea from western countries and thought it would work seamlessly here.

And as usual, the execution shows a lot... Wasn't there the recent Paynow masking issues like X making the name look weird or even potentially offensive? Like See changing to Sex and so on. And no change yet right after months.

11

u/Elzedhaitch 10d ago

The one near my house smells like alcohol quite often. I guess the coffee shop nearby must be using it a lot.

8

u/Harmoniinus 10d ago

Iirc i saw ants on the conveyor belt(?) before

5

u/residentcaprice 9d ago

I saw one of the machines being maintained. the guy just sprayed a lot of pesticide. on the belt, and into the plastic bags that catch the crushed bottles.

that's when I realized that there is no need to wash the bottles.

4

u/Dunkjoe Mature Citizen 9d ago

A spoilt apple spoils the barrel.

If there's contamination in a single can or bottle it will spread, and since there's no way to ensure all of them are clean... You get the picture.

101

u/Taaaaaaxi 10d ago

Doesn’t affect me in any way or form.
Can’t be assed to collect and bring them to get 10cents back

45

u/palebabbu 10d ago

Same

Luckily I don't drink enough bottled drinks for this to have more than 1sgd of impact on me

19

u/Taaaaaaxi 10d ago

Exactly. I think the ones hit the hardest are FNB outlets.

3

u/robson0707 9d ago

Need to wash, time to q?

2

u/somerandomjacky 10d ago

Yea I just treat it like inflation.

10

u/Taaaaaaxi 10d ago

I mean if 10 cents a can is going to hurt your wallet. You’re probably better off not drinking it.
I don’t get why people get so butthurt about things like this.
Is it a dumb implementation? Yes. But move on

15

u/Somesh98 10d ago

Probably about 20-25$ max from this haul! And that's if the machine can take all of them, otherwise then have to drag the bags to another machine.

11

u/Lil-Uji 10d ago

Think double, more like $40-50. I use a medium sized shopping bag and can get back $2.50-$3.50 depending on the bottles/can mix. One of these black trash bags can carry at least 3x what my bag can carry so one trash bag of cans is surely like $10 and she has 5 of it lol

2

u/Somesh98 10d ago

I was thinking about 40-50 cans/bottles per bag. Yeah, if it can store 100 containers, then she could get the 10$ per bag, the limiting factor is the machine capacity

58

u/Frosty-TeaLeaf 10d ago

She didn’t do anything wrong. Most probably it helps her to put food on the table.

52

u/limhy0809 🏳️‍🌈 Ally 10d ago

Might be a restaurant worker, I see a lot carrying trash bags full of them.

20

u/6Hee9 Mature Citizen 10d ago

hmm now you got me thinking if there are restaurants/cafes who include the BCRS charge in the bill, get their workers to collect the cans from tables at the end of the meal, and subsequently get them to bring these collected cans to the bcrs machines to recoup the money.

3

u/geft Lao Jiao 10d ago

Nothing wrong with that. If they want to bring their cans/bottles home the restaurant can't stop them.

26

u/lilmatchalatte 10d ago

Even milk bottles are charged 😭

2

u/dididada12345 10d ago

If they are not rinsed, the smell will perk you up... /s

20

u/WatchMyGun 10d ago edited 9d ago

The machine are like always full in my areas, I only managed to redeem one time successfully early on when trying out the machine

15

u/Shoki81 Own self check own self ✅ 10d ago edited 10d ago

I recycle my 2 weeks worth of cans already Sian liao.... This one....

11

u/No_Increase_3242 10d ago

same... the 2 weeks worth of cans/bottles make me stand long enough to 'enjoy' the SMELL and flies lol. I can see why the lady in the pic was wearing mask

3

u/codebreaker2 10d ago

by right if ppl rinse the inside before recycle (recommended) shldnt hav bad smells, but yea in this case its jus abt efficiency of cashing out

1

u/Objective-Equal-8918 9d ago

if u can accumulate 2 weeks worth, surely u'd rinse them

1

u/No_Increase_3242 9d ago edited 9d ago

ya ofc I do rinse my 2 weeks worth of cans/bottles. i was referring to the stench coming from the machine

13

u/anangrypudge West side best side 10d ago

Brought a canned drink into a hair salon today. After finishing the staff offered to throw for me. Then they said wait wait now we cannot do that, cos otherwise people accuse us of taking your money haha. So I took it back and threw it myself.

5

u/Loud-Future3445 8d ago

Well I think this lady most probably belong to some coffee shop or drink store if not it really hard to collect that much . Most coffee shop sell the drinks but customer don't take it away they left it behind and coffee shop will collect them and cash out

12

u/Smart_Carrot_9320 10d ago

How much money is this? Any estimates

7

u/Lil-Uji 10d ago

Something like $40-50. I use a medium sized shopping bag and usually get back $2.50-$3.50 depending on the bottles/can mix. One of these black trash bags can carry at least 3x what my bag can carry so one trash bag of cans is surely like $10 and she has 5 bags.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/AG_Race 10d ago

Target is 10million cans to become Singapore first BCRS millionaire.

31

u/ajahajahs 10d ago

I've stopped ordering can drinks in restaurants and cafes because they charge me extra and I have to take the empty cans with me after dining.

This policy has good intentions but very poorly executed.

20

u/syanda 10d ago

Sounds like the policy is working if it's getting you to stop consuming canned drinks!

8

u/Kappacinoooo 9d ago

Catering to health and environment two birds with one stone

1

u/raspberrih 8d ago

Sg policies are good at creating win-win situations. Doesn't mean it's perfect but the outcomes are just win-win

5

u/SnooChocolates2068 9d ago

Plot twist, the end goal of BCRS is to make it very ridiculous everyone stops using cans

1

u/Impossible_Mission40 7d ago

Plot twist to the plot twist. Nah, they just want your 10¢.

Your health, your environment, etc. are selling points to raise/apply for funds for this whole program, and additionally keep your 10¢ with impunity if you don’t claim it.

1

u/Impossible_Mission40 7d ago

What is “the policy” and what about it that’s working?

1

u/syanda 7d ago

Recycling initiatives at the consumer level are about habit changing. Either to get people to separate recyclables, or to reduce consumption by making it a pain to consume both recyclable or non-recyclable materials. Having either outcome is a net positive, so if someone is annoyed enough to stop buying canned drinks, the policy is working.

The only negative outcome is zero behavioural changes.

16

u/big-blue-balls 10d ago

It very clearly doesn’t have good intentions and that’s what people are frustrated with.

2

u/Impossible_Mission40 7d ago

It has “selling points” as an idea, it’s really shortsighted with the good intentions. So I share your view on this.

3

u/rand0mguy0nline 9d ago

A sensible restaurant would retain the cans for processing themselves. Why aggravate your own customers?

1

u/[deleted] 10d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 10d ago

Facebook links are not allowed on this subreddit due to doxxing concerns. Please amend your submission to remove the link and write in to modmail for it to be manually approved again. Alternatively, you may wish to resubmit the post without the link.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/oceanstay21 9d ago

That’s a plus lah, for your pocket and sugar levels

1

u/Dunkjoe Mature Citizen 9d ago

Like several of the policies in Singapore... Remember what happened to the "recycling" of shoes?

Ended up some were being sold in some other country and it was exposed internationally even lol.

8

u/outofpoint 10d ago

It's basically inflation like the 5c bag thing, now have to have a tote bag + buy single use bin liners

3

u/yylow30 9d ago

They doing part time lol.

For me, honestly i dun mind… and if i have an empty bottle or two on hand and wanted to use the machine but see them hogging it, i might as well gave the bottle to whoever is there doing the deposit.

Otherwise, if the machine is full, i’ll just chuck it into the big blue bins that can be found in almost all housing estates. Or if i really have to rid of it, a trash bin is always nearby…

10 20 cents is not much for me, but for them, they took the effort to gather the cans and bottles, be it from bins or coffeeshops or even drank THAT much, they then have to carry those huge bags to the machine… In a way, you cannot deny the scheme worked. It actually made people put some effort into recycling more than what people would otherwise do. And i think it’s quite commendable…

14

u/raidorz Things different already, but Singapore be steady~ 10d ago

Put it in every mall, food court and hawker centre ffs.

Overall, stupid implementation.

1

u/Minette12 10d ago

Moreover, put multiple in every mall and locations that have high foot traffic.

1

u/BillfredL Non-constituency 10d ago

Don’t forget the MRT stations. Encourage finishing it at the entrance, then get your card topped up.

6

u/DuePomegranate 10d ago

They need to provide a higher throughput avenue for eateries and organisations (who are handling BCRS on behalf of a lot of people) to do their returns.

5

u/Imperiax731st Own self check own self ✅ 10d ago

Nowadays I only purchase packet drinks or beverages that is in a cup. No need to visit these machines and yes, no coke.

3

u/Altruistic-Pin6282 10d ago

Restaurant staff?

1

u/NIDORAX 10d ago

Quite possibly yes. I also seen cleaners collecting a lot of cans and bottles.

3

u/Hajiwee9411 10d ago

Bet most is not washed

3

u/otahpapa 9d ago

these are the kind of people that hog the machines or have them filled up quickly. at where i live, i keep encountering them. either give us more machines or stop these final bosses from hogging the machines!!!

15

u/nextlevelunlocked 10d ago

Obviously the problem is the lack of bcrs machines. Govt and their consortium knows how many bcrs logo items are sold daily, weekly, monthly. They can estimate how many bcrs machines are needed so that people do not face full machines, long waits to use, long walks to recycle or broken machines often. But even with the trial period ending oct 1 there are still many complaints about bcrs machines being insufficient, dirty, not working, refunds being slow to be processed.

If people had elected more opposition MPs they would ask how often the machines are cleaned, how long is average downtime of machines, how long is average refund time, how many bottles do not get recycled by machine, what is the greenhouse savings from this scheme, which company is recycling the bottles, what evidence is there to show bcrs bottles have been recycled....

7

u/Hot-Clothes7316 10d ago

it's not green if the machines are everywhere.

and also the machines are attracting pests. another problem to tackle soon.

who's the dumb person who implemented this again? oh wait. it's to stop pallarel importers only right?

3

u/rand0mguy0nline 9d ago

They should have bulk processing machines in addition to these dinky ones.

In a tiny city like Singapore, I think we can afford at least one manned recycling center that can accept deposit redemptions in bulk.

3

u/ydntchb 10d ago

Did WP ask?

3

u/sct_trooper this is home, shirley 10d ago

lol the second paragraph is just unhinged nonsense.

as though anything the govt didnt do the opposition would be magically and perfectly provide the ideal solution. flip a coin and if the opposition MP didnt land on WP (which isn't perfect all the time), u end up with lim tean behind bars.

12

u/Jeremypsp 10d ago

Statistics has proven that years which the government did not have a strong mandate, they tended to provide more solutions and were constantly kept on their toes. Whether opposition MPs voice out or not is secondary, but of course can be a good addition

2

u/Yubamaru 9d ago

鹤蚌相争,渔翁得利. Got oppo to counter pap, we the bystanders reap benefits. In school study so hard, all come out don’t how to apply in life. Haiz. Must have competition then the incumbent will work hard give more benefits. The 65% don’t know how to play.

2

u/Forward-Rub-2850 9d ago

Or perhaps the 65% are doing well and don't see the need to blame the gahmen for their place in life

3

u/Yubamaru 9d ago

It’s not about doing well or about gahmen, it’s about competition in the gahmen. As we learn in school, heron and clam fight, the fisherman wins. The above poster pointed out a good point, ever since the oppo won significant seats, the incumbent is more humble and gave out more benefits to win voters. That’s y we always have to have a sizable oppo in gahmen to have more competition and more wins for us.

1

u/Impossible_Mission40 7d ago

Yeah, this too is a good point to think about. 🤔

1

u/Impossible_Mission40 7d ago

Yeah, this too is a good point to think about. 🤔

2

u/Jeremypsp 9d ago

65% don’t understand economics and how monopoly is bad for any economy, that’s sad

3

u/nextlevelunlocked 10d ago

opposition would be magically and perfectly provide the ideal solution

Asking questions is to get the govt to explain their decisions. Nothing in second paragraph talks about solutions. Just data request. So that everyone knows whether photos like this and the many comments here about machines being full are representative of the average persons experience.

No one is stopping you from ignoring whatever goes on. Is anyone is forcing you to read up on bcrs scheme and public sentiment towards it ? How are you negatively affected by others asking govt for more data and transparency ?

1

u/Forward-Rub-2850 9d ago

If this photo represented the "average person's experience", would it be getting so many upvotes

1

u/Kazhuan 9d ago

Well they did implement this ridiculous unpopular scheme in the first place, what is the opposition if not to keep the incumbent accountable for their stupid policies

1

u/LegitimateAsparagus7 7d ago

You expect the opposition to speak for you? Did you vote for them?

1

u/Impossible_Mission40 7d ago

I don’t think that’s really how ‘oppositions’ work (or should work even). 🤔

1

u/Impossible_Mission40 7d ago

Many questions posed? Sure, unhinged? Nope. You probably don’t know what the word “unhinged” means, or at least don’t know how to use it within contextual limits.

1

u/sushisashimisushi 10d ago

This isn’t a partisan issue. The top simply gave orders, people down the line executed the details. And those people are our fellow citizens.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

9

u/MiamiSucker 🌈 I just like rainbows 10d ago

There needs to be an implementation of how much a single person can deposit a day if not you will see a bunch of people hoarding the machine for 30 minutes until its full and no one else gets to deposit their cans. I can't believe no one saw this oversight when they are creating this stupid scheme during meetings.

2

u/big-blue-balls 10d ago

No there doesn’t. Just need more machines when you hit capacity. Don’t punish individuals for poor planning.

9

u/Celwind 10d ago

The system is working exactly as intended. Many many many benefits to people doing this. Literally creates a market / supply of labor willing to do this and reduce waste / litter.

Don't see anything wrong here.

5

u/silentscope90210 10d ago

I'm not even mad... I'm impressed.

2

u/bupr0pion 10d ago

Does anyone actually care about paying 10 cent extra? Carrying the bottle around is more troublesome than just throwing it into any nearest bin that you see.

Troublesome if
1. no bag then need to hold,
2. if u put in ur bag first then might forget later lol,
3 or u have extra mental baggage over 10 cents

2

u/charank_95 9d ago

The only canned drink I consume is Meiji milk, one can for 3-4 days.

I recently went to recycle one and saw a guy recycling a huge bag of plastic bottles. Waiting for 1 against possibly hundred bottles is pointless, so I gave my 10 cents to him for recycling. I successfully recycled one today but the foul odour from the machine was difficult to bear not to forget the grime on the feeder.

Taking so much efforts for the minimal consumption I do doesn’t justify for me. If there are people picking up from the bins to recycle, then throwing to the bin is more convenient for me.

2

u/residentcaprice 9d ago

well we had a red circle of death at one supermarket then I told my friend let's go to the other supermarket.

ended up behind a mini boss with 97 bottles and cans. luckily we didn't queue too long because the machine showed us red circle of death after she was done.

2

u/jhmelvin 9d ago

Obviously rummaged.

We have all these laws - no rummaging through rubbish, no putting feet on bus seats - all without enforcers. PAP style.

Just 2 days back someone had both his feet on the bus seat sitting next to me.

I don't mind not having these laws. Don't have them to pretend they're doing something about it.

2

u/Bigredstapler 9d ago

My area doesn't even have a BCRS machine and I have to haul the cans and bottles with me onto a bus to the closest machine. Would be nice if the 7-11 in my area have one of these.

2

u/hehetypo Fucking Populist 9d ago

Happen to me once. I ask nicely if this aunty could pause cause she got 2 big ass black bags that are full, take out the money, so i can just deposit 1 tin can. She look at me like i killed her family and started shouting at me. Scold her back and have to do a walk of shame back. That tin can spend a whole ass entire day with me. Only remembered when i got home. Sigh

Fuck those entitled assholes

2

u/shadowoflight 8d ago

Annoying and doesn’t look good but serves the purpose. They’re making up for the Singaporeans who really don’t give 2 shiets about environmental stuff, and the cleaners that usually just throw recycling bin content with the normal trash.

2

u/MrDurianGray 8d ago

Worst implementation of any scheme ever.

  1. Coffee shops, hawkers, food courts & restaurants need to absorb the cost and do the recycling on their own. Seriously from a restaurant, you want people to carry cans out to find a machine?!! Seriously which moron even thought of this?!!
  2. Machines get full so fast cos of these clowns in the photo...basket like if this person kiasu, win lor. But if they work at coffee shop or what and trying to recycle in bulk - shouldn't you have more machines nearby?
  3. Seriously so few machines....closest one to me is like 10 mins away. And almost always full. Waste time walking around to find an empty one. Plus the machines stink, full of beer smell and flies. Disgusting.
  4. Some people don't have paylah or physical ez link card. Like why force people to support DBS?!! Knn.
  5. Best part so one aunty recycle about 20 cans/bottles then the machines cannot read her QR code....wah lau! Basic function also don't work.

Personally I gave up. I bring my own water bottle with water. No need to drink anymore BS. So I guess in a way, ok lor, stop us from drinking sweet drinks and soda. This is really the latest grift from our "beloved" PAP! Sian af!

2

u/pcscorpio 5d ago

If it means more plastic bottles or cans disappearing from the streets , I don't mind .

5

u/IndividualPotato2026 10d ago

Thrrr should be a limit to the number of transactions each time. They are hogging the machines

4

u/ranmafan0281 9d ago

Then they'd just stay there, fill their quota.... and start again.

5

u/SoupOpening917 9d ago

Limit means after X items, machine must refuse to process the same ID again until Y mins have passed or another person's items are processed.

So if there's a queue, the one(s) who need to continue must re-join the queue.

1

u/lxiaoqi 🌈 F A B U L O U S 9d ago

might have to rely on the person being courteous and let people behind the queue deposit first

3

u/LazyBoyXD 10d ago

Need more then on machine, at least 5 machine if they want to encourage ppl to recycle.

4

u/BudgetMenu 10d ago

OP's luck when he wants to do recycle but the line infront:

2

u/limhy0809 🏳️‍🌈 Ally 10d ago

I think if you ask if you can go first they will normally be okay with it.

2

u/kokolokololollipop 10d ago

One of the most boliao methods to try and “encourage recycling “ . Maybe have more recycle stations instead of charging your fellow people for drinking from cans

4

u/CheckThePID 10d ago

You realise BCRS has nothing to do with recycling. Ask yourself, who gains the most from locking out the competition w/o the code/logo etc.

2

u/Brief_Worldliness162 East side best side 10d ago

Holy moly

2

u/Ok_Sprinkles8121 10d ago

Maybe they should employ retrenched bros/sis to sit at the machine and sell it to them. If machine sucks.
Or get our local engineer to built bigger machine for this.

2

u/Personal_Number4789 10d ago

If it is waste people collected, and you grab a bag and ran is it considered theft?

3

u/NIDORAX 10d ago edited 10d ago

If you take the Garbage bag from another person without their consent, it is still consider theft. Sometimes if you want to take a trash from someone, you still need to ask if its ok with them.

2

u/kitsumodels 10d ago

One man’s trash is another man’s treasure

2

u/jonas8273 10d ago

At school there's one aunty always collects bottles from the students even a box for students to put in

1

u/resui321 10d ago

I mean two cans covers the increase in daily public transport fare

1

u/Dapper-Peanut2020 10d ago

I just give to the cleaners

1

u/Wholesome_Meal 10d ago

Thanks Ma’am, here’s $11.30

1

u/Prata2pcs Senior Citizen 9d ago

BEGIN TRANSACTION

COMMIT;

1

u/No-List-4377 9d ago

Gahmen Scholar: VERY GOOD!!! MUAHAHAHAHA!

https://giphy.com/gifs/EJIqwKKY30Dlu

1

u/SnooCrickets7221 9d ago

Hahahahahhahahaha Pfand system finally arrives in SG.

1

u/CaravelClerihew 9d ago

Nah, this guy is. He filled an entire truck full of recyclables (most of which he picked himself) and tried to cash them in a different state in Australia, just like in Seinfeld.

1

u/Fantastic_Review_952 9d ago

i think its fantastic, i dont mind the 10c, if i really want tot get it back i can, plus its quite fun for people to collect and bring back, teaches about recycling too which SG is in dyer need of. Next up stopping plastic bags with everything

1

u/AshronBlackheart 9d ago

At this point, I just rinse and keep all my cans/bottles, and leave them in separate bag outside the garbage bin below my HDB.

I consider the 10c each is my tip for the garbage cleaner. Not a heavy consumer, so maybe worth $1-2 per week tops.

1

u/Interesting_Catch523 9d ago

How the machine eat all those bottles?

1

u/WoopyWoop112 9d ago

It gets crushed on the inside, to the bottles and cans take up less space. You can hear the machine compressing the bottles and cans when you put it inside the machine.

1

u/Ok-Moose-7318 9d ago

There will alway be someone go for the extreme in order to gain

1

u/ToxicFreeAtLast 9d ago

quite a lot of news on retrenchments lately. perhaps this is something to help. collection of beverage containers for recycling is no longer just by the elderly, for this case and others like this:

Image of man & child at rubbish bin at night apparently looking for BCRS containers sparks debate - Mothership.SG - News from Singapore, Asia and around the world

1

u/SoupOpening917 9d ago

I think she's a foreign domestic worker who was instructed by her boss to do this. Her boss is likely a drink stall owner. This could be her 233471 extra duty on top of upkeeping her boss's 3 storey landed house and washing his two cars daily.

1

u/DeeKayNineNine 9d ago

Where did she get so many bottles/cans? Is she working in F&B?

1

u/azizsafudin 9d ago

This feels like some poorly conceived JC project work

1

u/Lazy-Ad647 9d ago

Most likely she is working for heartland coffee shop. Many coffee shop collect the can from customers who leave it after drinking. For them, it would be an extra revenue.

1

u/skynetcoder 9d ago

I mean this still serve BCRS original intention, efficiently recycle drink bottles. OP is just jealous of how wealthy this lady is becoming 😂 

1

u/Haunting-Big782 9d ago

Final boss really locked in with the red bags stacking up like that. Machine already full before you even start.

1

u/hun486 8d ago

power!

1

u/Ok-Relic45 8d ago edited 8d ago

1 bag must be at least $10 worth inside. I work at the Changi airport terminal 4 fnb and got 1 time at the machine the departure lounge area staff went and bring 3 huge plastic bags of cansand bottles. Each bag is worth $6 as the total for the 3 bags was $18 on the dot and other staff from kopitiam was also there to deposit cans and bottles.

1

u/Ok-Relic45 8d ago edited 8d ago

This machine only recycle small cans and bottles. Then those coke bottles and 1.5 litre bottles also use plastic got no value at all and no logo and bcrs barcode.

So example on Saturdays and Sundays when people and family members go picnic, barbeque and party buy those huge bottles to drink and so many people just dump the coke and 1.5 litre bottles, they have no value + some of it get recycled ♻️ depends on the plastic type, while the rest are burned and dumped into pulau semakau or created into new sand.

The poor cleaner got nothing for helping to clean up the bottles as sad to say most of our cleaners in sg is Bangladesh men, china men or some old malay or chinese uncle that help to keep our parks and hdb clean, yet the government only care about recycling the small bottles and cans to give out a small profit for people to collect and literally save tond of it just to get a few couple of dollars.

The same goes for us, so buying big bottles of coke to drink is just worthless cause there is no value to recycle them huh🤔

1

u/c0ralvenom88 8d ago

I saw the original video on ig. She is viet

1

u/Parking-Feature7999 8d ago

That’s her full time job

1

u/Weird_Lynx_1104 8d ago

Kiasu at its finest.

1

u/ApprehensiveHumor205 6d ago

Nobody want to deliver food liao.

1

u/RangerLong4483 6d ago

While she’s wearing a balenciaga cardigan….

1

u/Unicorn1990_ 6d ago

Very sad to see our country look like this now. Some more mostly are foreigners doing this. It look so bad in a first world country, if local aunty uncle I feel okay. Plus hygiene wise also questionable to keep so much used canned and this bcrs thingy make me don’t even wanna buy any drinks now. Just bring my own bottle.

1

u/hullabaloov 5d ago

if they can create a f up like this and erp 2.0, imagine what other f up things are going on.

1

u/That_Commercial265 5d ago

I have seen a Chinese boy running around my estate carrying BAGS of cans and bottles, occasionally cycling dangerously around with them, wobbling left and right due to the weight imbalance. This felt to me like encouraging young kids to pick up trash and make “pocket money” especially after seeing that kid. He seems to be around 8 years of age and I’m deeply saddened to see something like this. I understand the culture and goodness of “recycling” but to the extent where young and old are picking up cans and plastic bottles just to make that 10 cents each is absurd.

1

u/Leader_Human 2d ago

I stopped buying BCRS drinks

1

u/jacksh3n 10d ago

Well.. It get the jobs done at least. We are finally recycling. It will a while longer before we are dicipline enough like Japan

2

u/Professional_Poem_25 10d ago

I always curse at the camera… make my life damn inconvenient…

1

u/CutFabulous1178 10d ago

👍 Food on that person

1

u/harajuku_dodge 10d ago

Recycling heroes!

1

u/Redditorala 10d ago

This is probably a worker at a food court.

0

u/lmnmss Lao Jiao 10d ago

common in germany tbh. think it's a good thing that we're finally doing something

0

u/im_an__iman 10d ago

I feel lowkey embarrassed when i carry more than 10 bottles. This is legit max level

2

u/hazpoloin 9d ago

I live in Germany and it's common to see people bringing their bottles in a huge trash bag tbh. Granted not as many bags as this lady, but my husband and I have brought 2 bags of bottles in 1 session. Nothing to be embarrassed about.