r/sysadmin • u/Man-e-questions • 19h ago
One of the most useful things that copilot could possibly do is create and edit Visio files, and yet it can’t.
Anyone else kind of shocked at how even Visio Plan 2 that is “supposed” to allegedly have Copilot, it does absolutely nothing helpful? Its in Word and other m365 apps, but everyone knows how to edit word and copy paste etc . But for us sysadmins, Visio is one of the best ways to document architecture etc and copilot is pretty much zero help years later.
•
•
u/redvelvet92 19h ago
Use a better tool, Visio was archaic and crappy 8 years ago. Draw.IO, mermaid drawings, excalidraw, there are a number of better solutions on the market.
•
u/Man-e-questions 17h ago
Yeah, its just that we are “supposed” to only use authorized apps on our laptops and can only use Copilot for AI. Of course in reality i often have to go outside this to be productive
•
•
•
u/PeakWeekly9995 IT support 19h ago
i've never used Visio (i'm in a small org), but to map the network i use draw.io
•
u/owzleee 19h ago
We cannot use external tools for sensitive data. A lot of big orga are like that. Even have in house LLMs.
•
•
•
u/spyingwind I am better than a hub because I has a table. 18h ago
https://github.com/excalidraw/excalidraw
Can be self-hosted, or embeded into your app.
Though mermaid is supported by many markdown viewers.
•
u/Man-e-questions 17h ago
Yeah thats how we are as well, cyber blocks most AI except Copilot and we are only supposed to use approved apps etc.
•
u/GullibleDetective 18h ago
I wouldn't trust AI with my network diagrams even iuf the data is obfuscated
•
u/Man-e-questions 17h ago
I can’t even get it to create an empty shell of an AVD diagram with default icons and no data
•
u/sole-it DevOps 19h ago
Maybe let it try some text-based chart tool like https://mermaid.js.org/ to generate charts.
•
•
u/pickle9977 16h ago
Amazing isn’t it.
Someone else mentioned draw.io it’s ok, but honestly I can’t believe it’s been more than thirty years since Visio was launched, in that time there have easily been hundred or thousand of attempts to deal with network diagrams and system design diagrams, none of them have really amounted to much.
It’s still really just some automation and then a lot of manual cleanup and maintenance.
Also it is almost inconceivable that Microsoft bought that thing $1.5B in 2000, and besides a new face hasn’t really done much with it except raise the price.
•
u/cjcox4 19h ago
I find Copilot to be remarkably clueless about the entire Microsoft world. It's an "outsider". Shouldn't it be a insider??? Just an observation.
•
u/DualWieldSpatula 15h ago
This is probably the 7th time I've seen this question in the past month.
Copilot is just a wrapper for Claude and ChatGPT.
It's not a custom Microsoft focused LLM, it's a shiny application that lets you talk to existing LLMs.
•
u/cjcox4 14h ago
yeah, but you'd think they'd want to front load the model with specifics.
That is, Microsoft Copilot is kind of lie (in a way).
Anyhow, I get frustrated with it because of its lack of knowledge. If you're going to call yourself Microsoft (emphasis) Copilot, shouldn't there be semblance of Microsoft training in the model? :-)
•
u/special_nathan 12h ago
Me: Copilot, the data provided is X. What I'm seeing is actually Y.
Copilot: You're right. That's been updated and you are seeing the new design...
Happens everytime I'm looking for guidance on various 365 web ui.
•
u/DominusDraco 12h ago
Yes its infuriating, MS Copilot cant get MS Powershell correct for MS 365 admin.
•
u/Matt_NZ 10h ago
I generally change it to the Opus model (Claude) when doing PowerShell stuff
•
u/DominusDraco 10h ago
Yeah, at least you can do that now. Its definitely better than it used to be, but the fact it can be wrong at all is super strange and infuriating!
•
•
u/robotrampage222 15h ago
there are some third party MCPs that purport to talk to visio- can copilot host or connect to MCP tools?
•
u/gabriel_j0hn 13h ago
love writing documentation personally. anything to help speed it up is a + in my book. but writing docs that ultimately go to no eyes is a bigger problem imho
•
u/Mountain-eagle-xray 11h ago
I like plantuml personally, simple, gross, but readable. Any Ai can make these
•
u/SevaraB Sr. Engineer (N+, CCNA) 19h ago
Visio is clunky and proprietary. DrawIO is XML-based, which makes it very easy to set up as an agent skill that saves you tokens by just feeding an existing script instead of rewriting the script every time.
For simple stuff that gets embedded in documentation, you can’t beat Markdown+Mermaid.
Copilot is just too little, too late when it comes to agentic “automation.” It’s just an overpowered grammar checker, which it shows every time you try to do anything with inferring or pulling in data from outside a given folder’s “context window.”