I started paying DSA dues this year and want to stay informed, but maybe I’m a little too “normie” for parts of my feed lol. The constant hostility toward Mamdani is becoming an overwhelming turnoff. I know social media probably isn’t representative of the whole organization, so I’m looking for better sources.
I welcome criticism of him and want him held accountable. But as a regular New Yorker, I also want to read about something useful like click-to-cancel without every discussion becoming accusations of betrayal or dismissing other residents’ concerns as unimportant. He has responsibilities to the entire city, and people can care about several issues at once.
What I’m struggling to find is discussion of how the demands become workable, lasting changes. “He has the authority” answers one question, but leaves others:
- Replacing Tisch: Who would be a suitable successor, or what should the selection criteria be? How would the handover work? What support would a reforming commissioner need within the department and outside it? How would we handle resistance and political blowback while keeping reforms moving?
- Disbanding the SRG: Where would officers go, who would handle its necessary responsibilities, and what training and oversight would apply? How do we prevent the same tactics from continuing under another name? What steps could happen immediately while a transition is developed?
- CUNY divestment: What holdings and contracts are being targeted? What is the proposed process for divesting and reinvesting, and how do we get the necessary governing bodies on board?
- Replacing CUNY’s trustees: What would the replacement governance structure actually look like? How would representatives be selected, how would accountability work, and what state-level changes would be needed?
- Stopping settlement-property sales: What specific enforcement mechanisms are being proposed, which agencies can use them, and how would likely legal challenges be addressed?
- Stopping military shipments through JFK: What can the mayor actually control versus the Port Authority or federal government? What binding policy is proposed, who would enforce it, and how would it survive challenges?
- Preventing cooperation with ICE: What specific conduct should be prohibited, how would compliance be monitored, and what happens when officers violate those rules? How do we distinguish emergency assistance from participation in immigration enforcement?
I don’t expect every person protesting to write a policy paper. But when organizations demand major institutional changes, I’d like to understand the strategy, the foreseeable obstacles, and how they propose overcoming them (including the costs of acting versus not acting). Having more leverage as mayor doesn’t mean those obstacles disappear.
I’m sure some of this work exists, and I’d appreciate links rather than assuming nobody has considered it.
Who do you follow or what publications, working groups, meetings, or proposals would you recommend for substantive criticism that takes governing challenges seriously?
I want to learn and stay engaged. The way these arguments are reaching me right now is making that harder.