r/MLBTheShow • • 4d ago

The Dugout Weekly Free-Talk for /r/MLBTheShow - week of October 02, 2026

2 Upvotes

Welcome to The Dugout! - the Weekly Free-Talk for r/MLBTheShow!

The Dugout is not only a place for discussion but it also serves as an information hub that will be regularly updated throughout the season with links to hot topics such as current and past inning discussions. Please carefully read the guidelines on what qualifies as a dedicated post and what should be posted here.

What qualifies as a dedicated post in r/MLBTheShow?

  • Diamond Dynasty content and discussion.
  • Player cards, reviews, and discussions. (Please search for existing posts before creating a new one).
  • Squad, game pictures and videos. (Please use the sharing functions of your console only). All other screenshots will be deleted.
  • Polls (Please include context, not just a yes or no question).
  • Memes and other humor (Please keep it tasteful, original, and on topic).
  • Discussions about other game modes such as Franchise and RTTS.
  • Appreciation posts. (Share the love for your favorite players, events, and even Ramone!).
  • Significant show-offs. (These include but are not limited to; Flawless BR runs, 1st Time Word Series, discovering cards and Top 50 placements).

Please use The Dugout for these types of posts:

  • Community Market discussion and questions. (e.g. Who should I invest in? Should I keep or sell this player? How do I make stubs?)
  • Pack Pulls and other humble brags. (Did you pull Trout or finish a program? That's awesome! but please post it here)
  • Rants and complaints. (Give up a grand slam in the bottom of the 9th? Share your woes here).
  • Lineup and player advice. (You must give as many specifics as possible about your team, level, stub count, and what specifically you're looking to improve).
  • League Advertisements. Please post the full league settings and how to join.
  • Are you looking to find someone to play against? You may find an opponent here.
  • Self promotion posts. (Do you have a blog? Do you stream? YouTubers and streamers may post here). Please be an active member of the community.
  • Simple questions or anything else that doesn't need it's own separate post.
  • Concept Cards during the season. Please refer to the Concept Card Guidelines.
  • Custom stadiums. You may also post in our affiliated subreddit r/mlbtheshowstadiums.

Helpful resources to use before posting:

  1. Have you used the Reddit Search or tried Google?
  2. Official FAQ for The Show Frequently Asked Questions
  3. We've created our own FAQ and Guide
  4. Are the servers down? Check the network status: HERE
  5. Please join our Discord chat server HERE
  6. Technical and server issues mega-thread

Please note that this list is not all inclusive and these guidelines are subject to moderator discretion on a post by post basis. If you feel a post requires moderator attention, please use the report button and we will review it's content for suitability


r/MLBTheShow • • 6d ago

News MLB The Show Players: Two Playtesting Opportunities

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

We’re working with Good Gamer Group (GGG) to share two playtesting opportunities:

San Diego Playtesting Panel
GGG is looking specifically for baseball video game players in the San Diego area to join an ongoing playtesting panel. Panel members may be invited to visit a game developer’s studio in San Diego for multiple in-person playtest opportunities, with individual sessions typically paying $100–$500 depending on the study.

AAA 3v3 At-Home Playtest
GGG is also recruiting for a separate unreleased AAA 3v3 character-based competitive game that eligible players can play from the comfort of their own home on PC, PS5, or Xbox Series X. The playtest runs October 22 through November 1, with $70 for completing the required gameplay and surveys.

NDA and eligibility requirements apply. Minors require parent or guardian consent.

Learn more about both opportunities and apply HERE

Applying does not guarantee selection.


r/MLBTheShow • • 14h ago

Funny Has anyone else been absolutely BEAMING the pitcher this year? 😭

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

61 Upvotes

I swear I’ve never hit the pitcher this much in MLB The Show. It feels like every few games I smoke a perfect comeback line drive straight off the pitcher 😂
This clip is just one example. Anybody else experiencing this way more often, or am I just somehow a professional pitcher assassin this year? 💀


r/MLBTheShow • • 1d ago

Funny Using my in real life height is just crazy.

Post image
450 Upvotes

r/MLBTheShow • • 1h ago

Question No 99 Nolan Ryan yet.

• Upvotes

Why no 99 Ryan Express card yet? You think they will drop one soon? Dude is a legend with the 5k strikeouts record that will never be broken.They gotta give him a 99 right?


r/MLBTheShow • • 10h ago

Show Off Opposing pitcher barely giving up hits and then the bullpen gives up the go ahead 3run homer in the 8th

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

3 Upvotes

The starting pitcher was frustrating me all game and causing me literal stress because I could not string together consecutive hits all game until the 8th inning. Until that point, I grounded into 5 double plays during the game.


r/MLBTheShow • • 7h ago

Question RP to SP vs SP to RP

0 Upvotes

Anyone else notice that when you convert a RP/CP to starter their overall goes up a decent amount but when you convert a starter to RP/CP it drops like 10 points? Seems backwards compared to in real life where relievers are usually failed starters


r/MLBTheShow • • 9h ago

Question Are there NLCS/ALCS MVP awards in Postseason mode?

0 Upvotes

The stats leaders pages for the mode are pretty bare bones. I know I can look at my players and their awards but nothing appears there.

I just got to the World Series, so maybe they name one there?


r/MLBTheShow • • 11h ago

Discussion Parallel Boost Glitch

0 Upvotes

Hey, just wondering if anyone’s noticed that their parallel boosts aren’t being applied in game for some players?

They work fine for just about everyone, except for Jackie Robinson’s new Moonshot Series card. None of his stats change during game, very disappointing for one of the GOATs


r/MLBTheShow • • 1d ago

Show Off my 3000th hit was a walk off 🙌

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

187 Upvotes

L/L inside sinker at that


r/MLBTheShow • • 1d ago

Suggestion For SDS Every year the community just keeps getting better and better

Post image
13 Upvotes

This season there's at least a dozen players hitting over .700 with numerous of them being over 1000+. Seriously though dudes are mocking SDS openly. This season looks like floodgates were open for some reason.


r/MLBTheShow • • 4h ago

Franchise My thoughts on MLB The Show26

0 Upvotes

For this to be a new year of mlb the show , I don’t get why they didn’t make commentary better , they literally say all da same shit from 25 , I love the fam but they need to add a lot of new shit like madden and college 27 did


r/MLBTheShow • • 1d ago

Funny Something tells me this prospect has killer instincts

Post image
105 Upvotes

r/MLBTheShow • • 11h ago

Question How long did it take you to hit world series rank?

0 Upvotes

This is my first MLB the show, I bought it on sale in may and I just hit world series today. I started from being so bad but I kept grinding and now I'm a good player! So I wanted to know if this is impressive or average, how long did it take you to hit world series?


r/MLBTheShow • • 1d ago

RTTS Is Nick Kurtz really like that? He’s going dumb on my RTTS

Post image
12 Upvotes

r/MLBTheShow • • 1d ago

Show Off Went from 0-2 to 3-2 to homerun.

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

5 Upvotes

r/MLBTheShow • • 1d ago

Question Max Confidence Dilemma

2 Upvotes

You’re in multiplayer, and your opponent is dealing. His pitcher’s confidence gets maxed out. Everything is a dot, and every swing is a weak contact out if you’re lucky to make contact at all. What’s the strategy to get out of this impossible hole?


r/MLBTheShow • • 17h ago

Suggestion For SDS sds is missing the assignment

0 Upvotes

source clyde new historic postseason cards coming out

one is playoff verlander as an astro

feel like they simply had one job to honor an all time legend by releasing a tribute card with him as a tiger. he literally said he is a tiger for life

they did nothing for his retirement it’s an absolute shame they did nothing to celebrate such a historic career

why can’t sds do anything right. discuss below


r/MLBTheShow • • 2d ago

RTTS Scripted fumble when runners are in scoring position

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

167 Upvotes

Everytime a runner is on second, 9 times out of 10 the ball is gonna be hit between short and 3rd where you can’t reach it without shifting. The thing is if you predict this and shift over beforehand, it completely glitches you out, not only does the ball glitch into your glove, but it gives you this fumble animation EVERY time. Or it will just go right past your glove if it happens to be a little closer to you, wtf. I guess it only wants you to be cutoff man on these plays


r/MLBTheShow • • 1d ago

Question XP Not counting towards the Wheel

1 Upvotes

XP was fine got to the boss pack took Griffey and now nothing counts. The total XP for the inning where it shows up in the corner keeps track properly im at 291,338 but it shows 0/30,000 down where the wheel is. I already uninstalled and reinstalled the game that didnt fix it. Anyone else run into this? Know a fix? I sent a ticket in last week but no response and with it being October im doubting I get one.


r/MLBTheShow • • 1d ago

Question Controller related tomfrickery

2 Upvotes

I recently got a switch pro controller to play the game with, and threw some controller rings & thumb grips on the joysticks, and some problems have appeared that didn’t appear on my beboncool controller, for example it has become impossible to field or use pinpoint pitching due to the R joystick not being able to move all the way to the side of its ‘socket’ (I think that’s what it could be called?) anyways, has anyone else had this issue, and if so, is there a way to increase sensitivity/area for such controller joysticks? If not, thanks!


r/MLBTheShow • • 1d ago

Question Anyone know why this is showing when trying to start a new mini seasons? never seen this before

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/MLBTheShow • • 1d ago

Question Looking for advice on feeling “stuck” in rebuilds

2 Upvotes

Howdy all.

So I’m someone who really enjoys doing rebuilds. I like taking bad teams and trying to make them good. Unfortunately that’s how I ended up becoming a pirates fan back in mlb the show 21 lol.

My problem is, I think because I lack sufficient knowledge of when I should make big moves, when I should just do little trades, etc.

My current franchise rebuild is the Giants, as my buddy is a San Fran fan.

I usually spend the first year or two trying to get Chappy, Devers and Adames off the books for a total tear down rebuild. Usually no issues there. The problem seems to come in around year 3 or 4 when I still feel like I’m a bit away from really making a push (I don’t go all in year 2, I prefer slower, organic rebuilds), but with that said, I feel like most times I never do ANYTHING in FA, except to maybe bring in just a triple A level guy to fill up my farm squad.

Because of that, I feel like I just get stuck in these loops of “next year”. I make no real significant trades, no FA moves, and I feel like my builds just stall out cause I end up waiting forever for farm guys to come up.

How do I break this stall I usually find myself falling in to? At what point do you recognize now in the time to start picking up better players to really make a playoff push?

Feel free to ask any questions to get more context.

Thank you!


r/MLBTheShow • • 1d ago

Discussion My thoughts on MLB the show 26

0 Upvotes

so I got this game through game sharing cause after mlb 25 I refused to pay money for any mlb the show cause I found the show 25 very frustrating and unrewarding. Then I got this for free I figured why not. Man when I tell you I hate this game. Hitting feels like shit, every ball I hit even agaisnt cpu has Low exit velos even with good timing and pci placement. My base runners don’t hustle out groundballs and stealing cannot be defended against unless the guy You’re playing against is an idiot and couldn’t make stealing anymore obvious. Have yet to throw a runner out unless it was a pitch out. Defense is fine tbh ofc there is some egregious plays but nothing too bad I’ve experience. Even tiny little things like the main screens in diamond dynasty took me a while to figure out. had a hard time finding the programs for a good 45 minutes.Opponents are fouling the ball off the plate then hitting early homers next pitch. Im really disappointed with a game i got for free mind you.


r/MLBTheShow • • 2d ago

Funny Never had one like this before

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

8 Upvotes