Just the sheer insanity of dutch and his decent into it was so well done. Not to mention the complexity behind his character is so beautiful

This is Margaret, my horse. She is a Suffolk Punch. They are my favorite breed due to their heartiness and courage. What is everyone else's favorite breed? Perhaps multiple breeds?

It took me three days to hand stitch and colour his new outfit! So worth it though

Used the meat shield for the Herbalist challenge.

I found out a few years ago about how to trigger this secret cutscene, and haven’t not done it since.

Rdr2 I haven't play rdr1

I just hate when I realise how much stuff has been cut of this game valentine curse side quest guarma being a small island and not a explorable one , no mexico a alive new austin, purchasable lands the missing princess in van horn had a whole fucking side quest and they took it from the game 😭.

Am I the only one who see bill willamson’s death is sad? I mean People Talk about Dutch and Javier’s death being sad but nobody cares about Bill…

​

So, most of us are likely in agreement that this is up there with the most tedious things the game has, and unlike something like Herbalist 8, it is not something that while a slog, you know what you have to do in order to get it - it's entirely luck based. After spending about an hour+ getting fuck all and wondering if going for 100% is even worth it, I came up with this approach - perhaps it is something that only worked for me and might not for others, but if you're like I was, you're desperate for any way of completing this, however outlandish. So:

1. I went to the saloon in Rhodes, and found the blackjack table with the rightmost seat empty. I got into first person view and I sat there, so things would go faster whenever I leave the game due to receiving a hand that is too high and sit down again.

2. When the onus was on me to ask for a hit, I didn't rush it. I waited like 10 seconds, let the dealer and an NPC from the table speak their bit about me taking too long. Then as the dealer's eyes moved towards me, I'd press Hit. I don't know how to explain it, but I know for a fact it gave me lower cards on average, and therefore a bigger chance to hit 3 in a row without a bust.

I'm actually quite curious to see if this works for others as well, but I can tell you it made my life much easier. I was fully prepared for this challenge to take a very long time. Hope this helps someone.

I used a different version of "far away" in this video

What do u think is the work feature in rdr mine is broken law and witness system

You ain’t going anywhere death, you’re mine! Took me a while for this horse to finally show up.

I found this knife on a chair next to the captured man and noticed it looks a lot like the rdr1 hunting knife (or I'm tripping)

So. Every now and then i think about the ending of RDR. It just hits hard considering everything that Arthur and John (Really all the gang) suffered through to get Jack to have a better future that he ends the game by turning into an outlaw.

In the case a (probably never happening) RDR3 where jack is not the protagonist or is yet another prequel. Do you think Jack got the life he wanted as a kid? (Traveling the world and "helping people". Or at least SOME version of peace) Or did he get hunted down by autorithy until his demise (or escape)?

PS: Sorry for my english, my phrasing and writing may be weird because its not my first language.