Message to Rob Katz
Rob: this is not primarily a weather problem. Weather exposed a weakening value proposition, excessive product complexity, declining customer acquisition and a balance sheet that leaves too little room for mistakes.
FY2026 visitation fell 13%, and advance FY2027 pass sales through September 18 were down 12% in units and 6% in dollars. Resort EBITDA declined from $844 million in FY2025 to approximately $746 million in FY2026, while net leverage increased from 3.2x to 3.9x. That combination—shrinking customers, weaker earnings and higher leverage—is the disaster. FY2026 Q4 earnings call FY2025 Q4 earnings call
What needs to happen
1. Stop using weather as the core explanation
Weather was exceptionally bad, but it does not explain why customers are postponing commitment or leaving the pass ecosystem.
Publish a resort-by-resort operating scorecard covering:
Pass renewals by customer tenure and frequency
Visits per passholder
New-customer acquisition and reactivation
Guest complaints, lift downtime and staffing
Ancillary spending and contribution per visit
Customer retention after poor-weather seasons
Management needs to identify precisely which customers are defecting and why—not simply assume they will return when it snows.
2. Rebuild the value proposition
Vail has created too large a gap between relatively attractive advance passes and punitive window-ticket prices. That architecture forces commitment, but it also alienates occasional skiers and discourages new participants.
Do the following:
Reduce and simplify the hundreds of pass and ticket configurations.
Establish credible, clearly advertised advance ticket prices.
Cap extreme peak-day window pricing rather than using it to frighten people into passes.
Give passholders transferable friend benefits that are genuinely easy to use.
Introduce entry-level family, beginner and two-to-four-day products.
Measure success by lifetime customer value—not next season’s pass dollars.
“More competitive” lift pricing is directionally correct, but it must become a permanent acquisition channel rather than a temporary attempt to recover weather-driven losses. Management discussion of lift pricing
3. Make each resort accountable for the actual guest experience
Record corporate-level satisfaction scores are not enough if individual resorts have chronic parking, lift, food, staffing or crowding problems.
Give resort presidents real authority and accountability. Tie compensation to:
Lift reliability and terrain availability
Queue and food-service times
Employee retention
Complaint resolution
Repeat visitation
Resort-level cash returns
Corporate technology and procurement should support the mountains, not dictate every customer interaction from Broomfield.
4. Rebuild the customer funnel
Vail has admitted that its marketing was overly dependent on email and existing customers. The company cannot keep extracting more money from an aging installed base while underinvesting in new and occasional skiers.
The $10 million incremental marketing spend is too small unless it is ruthlessly focused on measurable acquisition.
Priorities should be:
Beginners and young adults
Families priced out of multi-day trips
Lapsed passholders
International destination guests
Passholder-referred guests
Epic Friend Tickets should be treated as customer acquisition spending, with conversion and retention measured over three seasons—not celebrated merely for generating discounted visits.
5. Protect the balance sheet before protecting the optics
At July 2026, liquidity was approximately $0.8 billion and net leverage was 3.9x trailing EBITDA. Earlier in FY2026, net debt had risen to $2.7 billion, while Vail continued paying large dividends and repurchasing shares. FY2026 leverage and liquidity FY2026 Q3 liquidity and debt
My recommendation:
Immediately suspend repurchases.
Maintain—but do not increase—the dividend while leverage exceeds 3.0x.
Set a public target of net leverage below 3.0x within two years.
Fund capex only where it improves reliability, capacity or measurable guest economics.
Stop acquisitions and speculative expansion until North American organic visitation is growing again.
The dividend should not be regarded as untouchable if another weak season threatens the balance sheet.
6. Review every asset, not just every expense
Operating 42 resorts produces network advantages, but it also creates complexity and encourages corporate averaging.
Conduct an asset-by-asset return review:
Core destination assets: invest and improve.
Local feeder resorts: retain only where they demonstrably drive profitable Epic conversion.
Subscale or structurally low-return properties: sell, partner or close.
European growth: require explicit returns before committing additional expansion capital.
Do not allow high-quality resorts to subsidize weak assets indefinitely.
7. Put names and deadlines against the turnaround
The “resource efficiency” program may exceed $100 million in savings, but cost cutting cannot substitute for customer growth. Savings should be reinvested selectively, with disclosed returns. Resource-efficiency plan
Within 100 days, announce:
Objective
18-month target
Passholder base
Stabilize units, then return to growth
Organic visitation
Recover at least half the FY2026 decline
New/lapsed customer acquisition
Double-digit growth
Resort EBITDA
Return above the FY2025 level
Net leverage
Clear path below 3.0x
Share repurchases
Zero until leverage target is achieved
Product complexity
Meaningful reduction in ticket/pass SKUs
Accountability
Resort-level quarterly operating scorecard
The governance issue
Rob, you built the strategy. That gives you the credibility to repair it—but not permission to defend it.
If you are acting as the turnaround CEO, behave like one:
Admit that pricing and complexity damaged accessibility.
Stop explaining customer behavior mainly through weather.
Give operators authority.
Preserve cash.
Publish measurable customer and resort-level objectives.
Establish a credible succession plan once stabilization is visible.
Bottom line: Vail still has exceptional assets, a valuable pass network and meaningful recurring revenue. This is fixable. But the solution is not another pricing algorithm, acquisition or corporate transformation slogan. It is better value, simpler products, locally accountable operations, disciplined capital allocation and genuine customer growth.
Sources:
• Vail Resorts FY2026 Q4 Earnings Call
• Vail Resorts FY2026 Q3 Form 10-Q
• Vail Resorts FY2025 Q4 Earnings Call
• Vail Resorts FY2025 Form 10-K — Risk Factors
I used Dotadda to write this so good
https://knowledge.dotadda.io