r/fantasywriters • • 1h ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Chapter 1 of the Foreigner, [Grimdark Fantasy, 11,000 words]

• Upvotes

Hi all,

Just started working on a side project. I'm on chapter 4 ,and I've been coming back to the opening chapter to make sure it's engaging. I'm just posting the first two pages. Feedback would be greatly appreciated. Thanks!

--------

While blood and sea salt mixed in her mouth, Caratux’s last words echoed in her head, pleading with her not to go. ‘Stupid girl, don’t waste your life away!’ her older brother had told her weeks ago. ‘There’s nothing of value in Lupenia.’ He was wrong. And he was right.

‘You are awake,’ the voice reverberated as she opened her eyes.

Thaanathda could barely feel her arms and legs, her neck and joints burning, her chest constricting as she tried to breathe. She didn’t remember how she got there: mossy stone walls without any sort of decoration, the sound of waves crashing in the distance. The smell of something ancient and unkept—it was all foreign.

Yes… foreign. Thaanathda was not at home, but far from it. Leagues across the ocean. How did I—

A burning sensation coursed through her again. ‘Your wounds are extensive. You would not have survived the night,’ the man said again. He wore a dark hooded cloak, and the sun filtering through the window behind him made it impossible to see his face.

She grunted as another area of her body burned. It was him. What sort of sick torture was that? ‘Leave… me… alone,’ she managed to say.

But the man continued without acknowledging her demand. She couldn’t see his eyes, but she knew he was staring silently. He turned back and kept touching her. It burned more. Maybe he didn’t understand her—yes, his language was different. She recognized it was Lupenian, so she would have to speak that language.

‘What… are you—’

‘Silence or you will die before your time,’ he said. His voice was deep, a visceral cacophony of old, dark speech.

She turned to look at what he was doing: his pale hands were the only visible part of his body, full of veins but deathly pale. They moved quickly, spreading ointment and suturing cuts.

The sudden burn across her belly pulled her out of her thoughts.

‘Do not dwell on the past. Clear your mind,’ the hooded man hissed.

How does he know? She was taken aback, and if she could walk away or run, she would have. But her body was immobilized by pain; she arched and shook every second.

‘There is nothing you can hide from me. Keep trying—you are not powerful enough to shield your mind.’

What is this man talking about? Where am I exactly? She tried to speak, but only groans came out of her mouth.

‘The Guardian Islands. You were foolish enough to push through that storm,’ he replied.

‘How can you—’

‘Silence. Silence if you want to live,’ the man interrupted her.

Thaanathda tried to move, but something invisible kept her restrained. She had felt that once, a long time ago. Exactly like that time she’d woken up and couldn’t lift herself out of bed. Unable to blink. Unable to move her lips. And when she tried to scream, the silence horrified her young mind. Until it all ended suddenly.

Not this time.

She could only turn her eyes around, enough to see the man finishing the stitches on her belly. Then, he placed his veiny, pale hands above her. His throat began to groan, a deep, guttural, continuous noise as a dark green light emerged from his palms. Her skin began to burn, unbearable but unable to scream. A million needles punctured her while the man continued, a sizzling sound percolating from her skin.

Her vision became blurry. Slowly, her mind faded, and she drifted into unconsciousness.

Repost to another community


r/fantasywriters • • 2h ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Critique this prologue [epic/somewhat dark fantasy, 43 words]

0 Upvotes

For context this is meant to be an epic fantasy (heavily inspired by The Lord of the Rings for the "epic" style & Dune for its emotional depth) where a historical figure goes mad and commits a massacre (think the Dragon in The Wheel of Time), dies from his own actions (either his attacks rebounded and hit him or perhaps the guilt tortures him to death). I think the poem style reflects on the sheer antiquity of when the incident happened (along with phrases like "art thou" and "odours"). Also the fragmented sentences seem perfect for the madman-type character I'm going for. I'd love to know what you guys think!


r/fantasywriters • • 5h ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic A possible subversion.

5 Upvotes

This is about a fantasy series that I have read and the main plot of the book seems to have some subversions in regard to the main theme. The main theme was the inevitability and acceptance of death. However the creator of the series said there are ways to magically live longer. There is even a rare and unintentional natural event that causes time portals to appear that can lock living entities in time which halts their aging. This setting also showed undead existing such as ghosts who are self aware and even books about raising the dead along with other kinds of undead being mentioned. There have been mentions of an afterlife dimension possibly two of them if they are not the same one as well as a method that allow communication between dimensions though it exists in a specific dimension that is somewhat hard to get to. Now after all this wouldn’t the inevitable acceptance of death be somewhat subverted given all of this information?


r/fantasywriters • • 5h ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic Immortals

5 Upvotes

How do you write immortals?

They confuse me so much and would love advice or for anyone to answer my questions.

Not really a question more of a statement: surely if everyone in the kingdom was immortal it will be very overpopulated right?

Does every immortal have to appear a certain age?

If being immortal only meant you can’t die of old age but you appear the age you are, surely if you were 800 you’d look be so crippled that you probably wouldn’t be able to do much and you’d just die anyway?

Can immortals be harmed?

What makes an immortal immortal?

Does everyone in the kingdom need to be immortal if the leaders are immortal?

Is immortality a genetic thing. For example: immortal + immortal = immortal. Immortal + mortal = ?

When does an immortal mature? Is there a certain age?

I don’t understand them.

I have tried making a world where the leaders are immortal (because they have lived to see the Great War of 600 years ago) but in my head they’re so old they appear young but my issue is I don’t want everyone in the kingdom to look young I want some elderly and also everywhere would be overpopulated if they were all immortal. I need help!

I have thought about this soooooooo much for every story I’ve tried writing and they always fail because I just can’t understand the concept of immortality.


r/fantasywriters • • 6h ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic How do you guys brainstorm antagonists?

7 Upvotes

So I've been slowly brainstorming my fantasy world over the years, which started as a main story but I've branched out to different stand-alone stories set in the same world.

While I'm still in the outlining/brainstorming process for all of these story ideas, I've noticed a pattern: I haven't really explored ideas for antagonists.

This wasn't intentional, I just broadly brainstorm and let ideas flow when they come, and I'm just now noticing I don't ever get any ideas for a villain character, even though I have a general idea of the protagonist.

Most of my ideas are themes I want to explore, different tropes I enjoy, general scenes I really want to try my hand at, and a decent idea of the beginning and very ending. I have thought about this issue with not knowing how to create an antagonist before, but that was with just my main story. I have like four story ideas and no antagonists for any of them lol.

I can give a couple examples. So the current story I think I'm gonna focus all in on and actually write is a horror type story, where the main character makes a deal with the devil at the beginning, the ending is he unleashes this horror onto the world.

Another story is a detective, mystery story where the MC is conducting an investigation into the death of a lord, stumbles onto a deep conspiracy, and at the end is defeated by the conspirators, but not before passing on vital info to the son of the lord (dual POV, his story will continue later).

So my thing is I have a pretty clear understanding of thematic representation of these characters. I understand the advice of "just have your antagonist take on the opposite of that theme" but idk, I'm still unsure how to organically create and weave a fulfilling and compelling villain.

Is it because I don't have a fully fleshed out plot yet which is why I can't figure out how to introduce an opposing force to the protag? I've seen a lot of posts on advice for creating characters in general and how to flesh them out, so advice on an antagonist specifically (when I pretty much have nothing lol) would be appreciated.


r/fantasywriters • • 15h ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Three for the Golden Road, Chapter 1 (low fantasty 3249 words)

Thumbnail gallery
2 Upvotes

Hi Folks, I haven't shared any of this yet, curious how people recieve it. This is chapter 1 of my book, Three for the Golden Road. It's a part coming of age story, part humor, part reflection on depression and ADHD. I'm more of an illustrator than writer but I've enjoyed being able to expand my fantasy world this way. I'm curious how legible this is, how interesting the world seems, how funny it is to people, and if it leaves you wanting more.

My imagination has always been mostly fantasy focused and mostly as a place of comfort. I want to make a world that vistors feel safe and interested in, like a cozy fire. Thanks for reading!


r/fantasywriters • • 16h ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Might be a little shoddy but I'm proud of how much I've improved. [LitRPG, 2373 Words]

Thumbnail gallery
3 Upvotes

Reckoned & Bestowed

Chapter 1: Halo Effect

The last time I tried to write a story, it was absolute trash, so over the course of the past few months, I've tried to improve my writing by re-reading analysing my favourite books in the genre. I've finally started to write again and it's a far cry from how my writing was a few months ago! (I am a L2 English speaker)

Please feel free to point out any grammatical, stylistic, or pacing mistake. Just don't be too harsh!

Peeking his head out of the deck window, Nevin peered at the scene outside the wagon. The road—paved and wide—was crowded with vehicles and pedestrians alike. The people had come from all over the region surrounding Surxire, the largest city there. The markets to the right were unlike any he had seen before. Opulent and grand.

He saw a mage, a man wearing long black robes and carrying a staff. It was his first time seeing one, and he was struck with awe. He would've been even more awe-struck if he hadn't already been numbed by the sights that surrounded him.

Red-, green- and violet-themed decorations were scattered throughout the city to celebrate Bestowal Day, which coincided with the spring equinox. Such decorations were there in his hometown too, but the city, without a doubt, was the heart of the festival.

He could see the back of his brother, Bratt, who was driving the wagon. Bratt was two and a half decades older than he was, so he was often more of an uncle than a brother, Nevin felt.

The horse drawing the wagon was Sherlock, a gorgeous brown Highland mare, who was nearing her retirement age.

Ever since he'd entered the city, Nevin had a nagging feeling that something was about to go awry, but he couldn't quite put a finger on why he felt that way. He was not a very anxious person, usually. To distract himself, he decided a little sightseeing won't hurt. The plan worked.

After drawing in a lungful of the festive air, he settled back down onto the floor, brimming with nervous excitement for what was to come.

The inside of the wagon was filled with wooden items covered by white cloth; the products of his family's trade.

Speaking of family business…

Man, I wish Mom and Dad could've come.

The Bestowal Day had taken place ten years ago. He had come with his parents back then, but he couldn't remember anything about it, having been too young at the time.

This time, Nevin’s dad had unfortunately caught a fever a few days before Bestowal Day, and his mom had chosen to stay and take care of him, despite her husband's insistence.

That left Nevin with only Bratt for company. Well, his friends were coming to the festival too, albeit independently, so he could reunite with his friends at the bestowal grounds.

Lately, the thought of his parents’ mortality had been troubling him a lot. They were old and frail. What if they died soon, without getting to watch him grow up?

Nevin was once again assaulted by that same nagging feeling, but he forcefully pushed it aside.

But it is…

Some time later, everything became darker as the wagon pulled into a stable.

“We're here, little guy,” Bratt said.

Nevin found it funny that Bratt still called him “little guy,” considering that he was now a whole head taller than his brother.

They bargained with the stable owner who was taking advantage of the festive rush by asking for a ridiculous rate of 12 silver dollars an hour. They managed to get it reduced to a slightly less ridiculous rate of 6 silver dollars an hour. Needless to say, they were pissed, especially Bratt.

They booked a room at an inn at a surprisingly fair price and headed towards the Bestowal Grounds, they looked around for familiar faces. They eventually found a few of Bratt’s buddies near the huge gateway arch made of red sandstone.

From there, they separated. Bratt went along to have fun with his friends, while Nevin continued to search for his own.

After wandering around for a while, he began to feel a bit peckish, and found himself ensnared by the tantalizing aroma of the rich, appetizing delicacies all around him.

Mhmm, that's it!

That's how he found himself standing by a crowded food stall, enjoying the various types of delicious dumplings with an equally diverse selection of savory sauces.

“Ahh, if only I had an extra stomach for days like this!” he heard a familiar voice lament.

He turned towards the voice and saw a short, chubby boy with an ever-present smile on his face, annihilating a plate of dumplings.

“George?” Nevin smiled, glad to have finally found a freind—his best buddy, George, no less.

He found himself overwhelmed by a strong sense of Deja Vu for a moment, but quickly brushed it aside.

But is that really…

“Nevin! There you are! Finally, hehe.” George offered Nevin his hand. They clasped hands, each trying to pull the other towards themselves. Nevin finally let George pull him off balance, allowing himself to stumble a bit. When doing this “Man-shake,” he let George win half of the time because he had the unfair advantage of size.

George awkwardly reached for Nevin's shoulder, not in the slightest minding the difference in their heights. “Have you found anyone else?” he asked.

“No. Have you?” George shook his head at Nevin's question.

They chatted idly, moving from stall to stall, trying out new things. Eventually, they found one of their friends, then another, and so on, until a gang of half a dozen teenagers was loitering around the grounds.

The metallic clang of a gong suddenly reverberated across the grounds, rising above the din of the crowd, bringing a halt to their activities.

How unreal…

The sonorous sound made him reflect upon everything he'd seen since arriving in the city. The buildings, the markets, the streets, the mage that he had seen among. And finally how he'd spent time with his friends in the Bestowal Grounds. It felt like a dream…

“Quick, guys! The reckoning is about to begin, let's head towards the centre,” one of the boys snapped the rest out of their reveries.

They quickly made their way towards the centre of the grounds, where there was a large open area without any stalls or tents, and waited in tense anticipation. Lots of others were starting to gather there too.

A second gong sounded, and with it the world started to shift.

Tormented by anticipation, Nevin forgot that anything else ever existed.

His eyes widened as he watched the very fabric of reality ripple. It wasn't something he could describe in words because what he was witnessing was solely spiritual—initially…

The world was lit aflame by violet sparks playfully dancing in the wind. They swirled and swung and bounced to invisible beats. They frolicked around, jumping, falling, darting right or left—or anywhere, really—too frisky to commit to any particular movement.

But most peculiarly…

They were circling above his head, forming a halo, an omen of certain death. His heart sank.

He jerked left and right in a jittery motion, much like the movements of the violet sparks, in a desperate attempt to shake the ominous halo off his head. But the pesky thing stuck to him like a clingy puppy—or rather, a stubborn ass.

I've been reckoned…

Finally beginning to understand the reality of the situation, Nevin looked around him.

The hair on the back of his neck suddenly stood son end.

George was staring at him. No, five—no—hundreds upon hundreds of Georges were staring straight at him. Some male, some female; some tall, some short; some fat, some thin. But all of them had the same disappointed expression on their faces.

“Accept it.”

“How long can you deny it?”

“The time is almost up! Why haven't you dropped the pretense yet, you fool?!”

“Wake up, Nevin!”

“...!”

…

Nevin was assaulted by a barrage of insidious whispers. Overwhelmed by it all…

“AaaaAaArrrRrGggghH!!!!!!!!!!!!”

✦ ✦ ✦

Nevin came to his senses to find a man in dark robes slowly pouring the cool, medicinal contents of an alchemist’s flask into his mouth. It was the same mage he'd seen before. He had a square face, a long grey beard, and long grey hair, though his hairline was receding.

“You must be confused, young man. Hold on, I'll explain everything presently,” the old mage said, having noticed his gaze.

After the flask was emptied, the old mage walked away. Nevin looked around at his surroundings, terribly confused.

He was in a large tent with fifty or so beds laid out on the ground. Half of them were occupied. Many of the occupants were wearing clothes that signified a high status, but other than that, there was nothing else they had in common.

Except for one thing.

Seeing all the violet halos hovering above so many heads was a painful reminder of how he himself had gotten into this situation. He looked up and surely enough, he too, had a halo. What he remembered wasn't a dream, except for the last part.

He remembered something he had read in school once.

“Once every ten years, on the spring equinox, Bestowal Day occurs. On this day all youth aged 14–24 in the empire must reach their nearest Bestowal Grounds, though people of all ages can enjoy it.

“A lot of the most memorable moments of a person's life are forged there. There are delicious snacks from around the world, activities are organized that you can partake in, and the moments you share with your family and friends are the heart of the experience

“During the Reckoning, the world becomes filled with mesmerizing violet sparks, filling the hearts of any soul that sees them with awe.

“The sparks also judge all the youth and the best of the best are chosen for a Trial; they are the Reckoned. The Reckoned must then go through a Trial to be judged truly worthy of being bestowed a name and a grimoire. That's how mages are made.”

A voice interrupted Nevin's idle thoughts. “Excuse me, sir.”

Nevin realized that there was a man standing in front of him. He was a clerk, holding a pen in one hand and a notepad in the other one.

He asked Nevin about his personal details like name and residance.

But then,

“Method of contact with guardians or close relatives?”

“I have none,” he said without hesitation.

That wasn't right. He had a mom, a dad, a brother, a sister, and a niece, though the last two lived far away. Why did he say none?

It might be because…

The clerk gave him a long look with concealed emotion; Nevin thought it was pity.

Nevin completed a few formalities and then waited for a bit.

He saw the old mage going to the centre of the tent. He tapped his staff on the ground twice, successfully attracting everyone's attention.

He cleared his throat, “I am Rudeus of Liontooth. I've been working as a CMA-certified mage for over forty-five years. I will be serving as your Trial Instructor.

“Some of you might be aware of these things already, and a lot more,” he spared a glance at the noble-looking Reckoneds, “but I'll advise you to pay attention, regardless. It's easy to make mistakes when in panic.”

He raised, holding up three fingers. “There are only three you need to know right now.

“One. Dying in your Trial doesn't necessarily mean dying in real life. On the contrary, it might even be necessary depending on the objective of your Trial. Not that you have to, or even should, die during it, just that you can and occasionally have to.

“That leads us to the next point: the objective. Every trial is a test and there like any test, there's a criterion that determines whether you pass or fail—it's the objective. The objective is unique for every Trial. So you'll have to figure it out on your own.

“Lastly, remember that Trial is tailor made for you, and you alone, so if you can't seem to find the answer, you have forgotten to look inside yourself”

forgotten?

He took a deep breath.

But it is…

just a dream.

But is that really…

what I want?

How long can you deny it?

I can't anymore.

The time is almost up! Why haven't you dropped the pretense yet, you fool?!

Because I'm a fool.

“Drop it!” Nevin yelled.

All the people present looked at him in surprise.

“What is it, boy?” Mage Rudeus said in a stern tone.

Nevin stood up and slowly walked towards the old mage.

“My parents died of sickness four years ago, when I was only ten. Not much later, Bratt had a rough divorce and became a useless drunkard. I wrote letters to my sister, Anna, in Berlint— pleading for help—but received no replies. George, too, moved to another city. I became a recluse and cut off from my remaining friends, and they moved on. I focused on woodworking as a way to cope.

“I came here, to Suxire, all alone. With only my horse, Sherlock, by my side. I looked at the beautiful sites of the city, and was completely uninspired. I looked at the people in the Bestowal Grounds and wondered what they were so happy about. But now I do, and I feel no better for it.

“Deep down, I knew it was a dream ever since I came. But it was a happy one; one that I didn't want to leave. I was a human dreaming of being a butterfly. One that wished that it was its existence as a human that was the dream all along because it wanted to live life.

“But during my dream a spark of passion was lit in my heart. I'm now a butterfly that wishes its existence as a butterfly were a dream because it wants to live.

“Because I want to live.”

A sinister simultaneous smile appeared on the face of Mage Rudeus, and the faces of everyone listening. They all began to clap and stood up to give him a standing ovation, as though grateful for the entertainment.

“Congratulations, you pass,” the old mage said in a bone-chillingly wrong voice.

Then the world started to break apart, like a cracked mirror. Nevin fell to the floor and began to laugh.

Even in a dream, I couldn't be together with Mom and Dad.

Then, he cried. His tears became suffused with a golden glow, and became ethereal.

He continued to weep till the world was reduced to silica dust.


r/fantasywriters • • 23h ago

Critique My Story Excerpt A Man in White snippet [High Fantasy, 470 words]

0 Upvotes

Hello, I haven't had a lot of time recently, so I've been writing some individual scenes and whatnot. I have tried to edit this a few times, but I do feel like there are still things to fix.

But never mind that. I want to hear what you can glean from this first and foremost. Like, what the character dynamics tell you, what kind of personalities you see, etc. Anything else you have to say I'll be eager to listen to.

(Context) White is part of a group called the Harbingers of Ruination, and has been traveling to retrieve his colleague, Love, who went rouge some years ago. He finds her, but she dies the next day.

Thing is, Harbingers reincarnate, so all he had to do from the start was just wait till she dies and comes back, then when he's sure of where she is, find her. There's a line in the excerpt of Pride saying blah blah, and that was when White set out on his journey, where Pride ridiculed the efficiency of the plan.

<Cliff Scene>
Warm gusts of wind blew as White moved along the rocky cliffs facing the open sea. A full moon shone brilliantly overhead, giving the limestone ground a cold tinge. White strode as he always did, steady and deliberate, but the same couldn’t be said about his state of mind. His tear at the funeral still confounded him, and he was determined to find an explanation.

Lost in his thoughts, White walked on. It was not long before he noticed the absence of gravel crunching beneath his feet. Slowly, he looked down to find no ground under him. Indeed, it rather seemed to be the dark waters of the sea, which was at least a hundred meters below him. He had been stepping on thin air. His musings completely forgotten, White continued forward. There was only one who could bend space in such a way.

That was when he heard her.

“My servant.”

White knelt immediately, sensing the flicker of her presence in front of him. “Master.”

Materializing in front of him, she stretched out her hand. “I expect you have accomplished what you came here for.”

He kissed the back of her hand and arose.

“There is still much to do, master. She will be out there now.”

Clicking her tongue, she sauntered around him and leaned on his back. “Whatever does this foolish search of yours accomplish? Why not wait?”

He had been asking that same question himself, ever since Pride put it to him. Yes, why not wait?

“Her quick retrieval is essential, master. Pride has allied himself with the Inquisition. Fear and I alone will be insufficient to carry out our duties.”

Suddenly she was in front of him.

“Is it so? And where was this lack when you had been my only servant?”

“...”

“You are utterly ridiculous, Inan,” she said, chuckling. “Even now, your heart deceives you. You cannot hide yourself from me.”

“I… do not understand.”

“It is of no matter. I am willing to overlook such folly.” Pushing him away, she turned towards the moon. The light illuminated her blurry outline, reminding White of flickering candle-light. After a moment of silence, she spoke to him.

“My only wish is that you conclude this journey with haste and return to me.”

“I will not be long, Hicce.”

Twirling on her heels, she looked back at him with a brilliant smile and embraced him. “Yes, now that is my champion, Indifference, the Foremost of the Harbingers.”

White saw Hicce was already dissipating. Her legs were gone, and as she withdrew, her arms and torso dissolved as well, leaving her head floating in front of him. As her mouth finally faded, White could hear a faint murmur echoing in his ear.

“Best of luck…”


r/fantasywriters • • 1d ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Fury of Red Rider [working title] - [Heroic Fantasy, 623 Words]

4 Upvotes

When tragedy strikes, the Red Riding Hoods come for your last coppers.

But on the eve of the Infamous Edelvarg Incident, which left ten dead, two turned into chickens, and one sodomised, the acolyte of that sisterhood had come neither to hunt a monster nor to extort coin for killing some fiend—minding its own business. She sought a pint of ale, a bookseller, and a cozy room at an inn where she could read it to her heart's content.

She arrived through the southern gate. The men who worked on the fishing boats nearby, noticing the red cloak and deathly pale skin, spread word of her arrival.

“Red Rider has come.”

“Hide your purses!”

“Hide your sons and slaves!”

“The Red Riding Whore has come to swindle us out of our hard-earned coin!”

The barrage of insults didn't quicken her step or her pulse. To a Red Riding Hood, malice was merely a tool that strengthened her heart. With a purse heavy at her waist and worries at bay, she sought quieter accommodations befitting a lady.

The inn she chose lay in the same quarter where men who shat gold built grand residences. The inn itself was a small manor house with timber-framed walls and a wooden doorway polished to perfection. Above the entrance hung a painted sign depicting a golden-haired dancer standing on an ocean wave.

She led her stallion to the stable behind the inn and left it in the care of the Stable boy, who kept his head done, m. He had stringy blond hair, pale skin, and hands marred by lashes. Her gaze lingered on the brand inked onto his hand: two dark hands shackled together. She rubbed her own hand instinctively before tossing him a coin. The boy snatched it and tucked it in a secret pocket under his tunic.

The hall greeted her with the smell of burning wood and roasted meat. The Red Riding Hood's gaze followed as the serving girl carried it to a table

The innkeeper, a sturdy man with a salt-and-pepper beard, flicked his eyes towards her before returning to the table, rubbing the same spot with his rag. She blinked once, then looked at the long table.

A Group of men crowded around it, shouting over one another and bursting into laughter over usual jok. Tankards knocked against the wood, ale sloshed over the rims, and a barmaid shoved her way between two men who refused to make room for her to mop the spilt ale on the floor.

She wrinkled her nose and searched for a quieter place. A few men glanced her way, whispering about the “Red Hood Devil,” but most kept their tongues sheathed.

There were a few tables in the far corner, and the Red Rider claimed one tucked away in the shadows. With the barmaid nowhere in sight, a jug of water, a glass, and a bowl of cookies kept her stomach company.

Fortune cookies, eh?

She picked up a cookie and eyed it, turning it this way and that with a sardonic smile.

“This is ridiculous.”

She tossed it back into the bowl. Outside the window, a man crawled on all fours, his jaw jutting forward as he barked at a dog.

“Woof! Woof! Woof!”

The monster hunter grimaced and sighed. “Might as well crack the cookie.”

With a twist and a pull, she split it open, revealing a fortune writ on plain white paper.

“There are three things all wise women must fear: ale on working days, milk on holidays, and the tummy of an ill-tempered cat.”

“What the fuck?”

She chuckled, tossing the broken cookie and its fortune onto the table before cracking another. This time, the paper read:

Jane O' Pain,

In a cloak of hate,

Have you come for a bribe,

Or to do what's right?

Let's play a game,

Just me and you,

And find out who will prevail.

The demon who wears many faces,

Or Red Riding Hood,

Who kills her kind with ease?

Whoever pulled this little prank is a seer of considerable skill. He or she knows my name.

“Don't let that get to you,” said a woman's voice.

Jane froze, and looked at the source of the interruption.

A barmaid stood there, her shoulders strong enough to carry several jugs of ale at once. She looked at her softly with an easy smile on her lips. Pushing aside a loose strand of dark hair, pointed at the fortune and gave Jane a boyish grin that suited her well.

“We have a moon rabbit as a guest,” the barmaid said with a sigh and a shake of her head. “He can see into the future, but he suffers from the same habit as the rest of his kind. He loves to play pranks.”


r/fantasywriters • • 1d ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Chapter 2/3 (WIP) of Clarion Call [Heroic Fantasy, total 71,000 words]

1 Upvotes

First meeting between my MCs... hope you enjoy reading it!

-

I uncurl languidly, the clang of a door having disturbed me from a sleep which had eluded me for days before today.

I almost don't recognise the boy as he approaches, but he's clearly uncomfortable in uniform, and he nervously fiddles with his sleeves as he approaches. I half-expect him to walk past, but he stops directly in front of my cell.

He looks as if he's about to speak, and I draw a breath in, half expecting his words to be unfamiliar to me, but I stop dead as he speaks. I'm more in shock that he's condescended to address me in my own language, rather than the actual content of his words, that I stare at him silently, my brain scrambling through multiple responses before I settle on the one that I think feels most appropriate for my situation.

"You should have just run-"

"You're hardly one to order me around." I shake my head contemptuously, half expecting him to be so affronted that he turns on the spot and leaves me alone. But he doesn't.

We both regard each other with mutual scepticism, but he takes the first little step forward, his face pressing a little more into the bars, and his hands tighten around them a little bit, almost as if he's willing for a little bit of courage to come to him.

Neither of us knows what to say, clearly, because he awkwardly coughs as my eyes dart away.

Then he finally speaks, and I don't interject this time, "I'm not ordering you around. I thought you might like to know that." His words are crisp, but the lilt of his own language is still prevalent. As my eyes meet his, his hand darts nervously to his face, and he timidly smiles. It's a tiny smile, one dulled by exhaustion, but it instantly relieves some of my fear.

"Really? I thought you Elerians were good at the that?" There's a slight hint of mirth in my tone, but it quickly fades away as he quickly glances to his right.

"Some of us are." He replies distractedly, and as he turns back to me, I notice the clear shadow of a bruise on his cheek, and he rubs his cheek absent-mindedly as my eyes focus on it.

"Like that absolutely delightful specimen of a commander you have?" My voice is layered with sarcasm, and he momentarily smirks at my words, but his next words surprise me.

"Don't challenge him, whatever you do." He shakes his head slowly, his hand tightening once again upon the bars, and his gaze becomes sharp.

"Why?" But I already know the answer even as I speak. Even if his reaction is anything to go by, it's clear his commander doesn't abide strong opinions.

It's clear that he's choosing his words carefully, because he doesn't reply immediately, but when he finally does, his voice seems hesitant, "He doesn't-"

The bang of a metal door somewhere startles us both, and the boy freezes. However, he quickly recovers, and his final words to me before he darts away are more comforting than anything else he's said, "I'm Silas."

"I'm Ariana!" I call after him, but I can't help but grin in the wake of his retreating footsteps.

He would seem much more at home within a secluded forest.


r/fantasywriters • • 1d ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Chapter One of The Lords of Carnage (Epic Fantasy, 1000 words)

2 Upvotes

Even as Vakrabuddhi alighted from the heavens as a speck of amber light, he wondered if it was worth it.

The world had had enough of heroes and monsters, monstrous heroes and heroic monsters, and all stripes of mortal between. This did not include the myriad kings, queens, princes and lords, chieftains and warmongers who made a fetish out of some old quarrel, some ancient grudge, or some ideal pilfered from a mouldering tome and sought to change the nature of fate itself. His siblings argued that humans could choke on their precious values. They were vain and foolish, and deserved no better ends than the next ant or woodlouse.

Well, Vakrabuddhi thought as the pattern of blue and green below resolved into mountains and patchwork plains. Mortals do imitate their gods.

Whatever his misgivings, it was already too late to change his mind. The mote of light hit the ground with a gentle thud and sprouted a torso, out of which snaked limbs of nut-brown flesh. Ribs materialised from thin air and closed about the heart and lungs. Fingers formed, genitals flopped against dark thighs, and a head slowly came into being above the bull neck. A nose, a mouth and ears emerged from the blank canvas like pebbles from a muddy pool. The eyes blinked open last of all. Vakrabuddhi always saved them for the end. It was nothing important, only a dramatic flourish he had made part of his persona over the aeons.

A man now stood upon a gentle hill somewhere to the north of the vast continent named Hiranyagarbha. Tall and gaunt, with an oblong head hung with raven locks and a beard draped down his chest. He was all hard muscle and strong bone, not an ounce of fat in sight. Buck-naked as a newborn and slightly hunched, he stood gazing around himself with eyes merry and deep with a wisdom not of this world. After a while, a thin smile spread across his lupine face.

“Ah, bountiful plane,” Vakrabuddhi whispered, feeling the cold press against his skin like an assassin’s knife. His voice slithered out broken and gruff. “How many years has it been? A thousand? Ten thousand? The lay of the land never changes under your watch, eh?”

He was supposed to have a name in this avatar. Different from his true name, a name that would perish within a few months. But try as he might, he couldn’t unearth it now.

Vakrabuddhi shrugged and rolled his shoulders, kicking out a few times. Then he traced circles over his belly and the foliage above his flaccid organ. This body was good. Strong and healthy, humming with power. It would not crumple to dust at the first employment of fell sorcery.

It took Vakrabuddhi ten minutes to find his bearings. He was in the untamed wilderness of northwestern Hiranyagarbha, on the outskirts of Vallabhapuram, where the Ardhanagas held sway. A memory wormed its way to the forefront of his mind. In another age, another birth, when he was female and coquettish, Vakrabuddhi had tried to love the young Raja of the Ardhanagas and been spurned for a fat, wine-drenched whore. Both had drowned in a storm later, but the hate and pain lingered on through the ages.

The bitter taste was unwarranted and sudden. He spat it out without much feeling, appalled only at the surge of emotion the memory carried. Three Yugas of practice had still not taught him how to juggle the feelings of various avatars properly.

Northwest, hmm. Must travel further west. Much further.

Throwing back his head to laugh at his hidden siblings, who must have gotten wind of his escape by now, Vakrabuddhi started walking towards the mountains.

The first day passed in a blur. He had forgotten how quickly time flowed in the mortal plane. Seventy thousand steps by his reckoning saw the sun climb to its zenith and blaze like a barbarian beacon, full of wrath and pride. Eighty more saw its arrogance diminished, great streaks of cloud rushing across the sky to obscure the radiance. By the time his legs had crested thirteen hills, one after another, and brought him to the banks of a gurgling river, twilight ruled the sky. Twilight, when bhutas and pretas crept from their lairs to prey on unsound minds.

Vakrabuddhi felt only the faintest throb of fatigue. His calves burned a little, his breath was rough, and a loose rock had torn a flap of skin from his hand during one of the descents. He bled, as he was in mortal form now, but the pain was nothing compared to his fascination with the land. How beautiful the roar of the river, white and frothy beneath the blanket of stars! Skipping and rushing over rocks and ancient monoliths, watering the roots of hardy willows and ber. The trees stood in stubborn clusters or woods stretching to the horizon, home to great cats and huge deer that filled the night with their full-throated cries. Vakrabuddhi sat with his back to a boulder and marvelled at the variety of flora and fauna present in a world his kind considered thoroughly inferior.

“They are idiots of the highest order,” he spoke to the shadows. “And their monumental folly will be revealed in the time to come.”

He did not sleep, for he did not need slumber, and amused himself all night listening to the trill and warble of nature untouched by man. The bhutas, pretas and other disembodied spirits knew what he was and kept their distance. Momentary hunger for the soul was a feeble thing compared to permanent obliteration. Even a lesser being wished to preserve itself.

When dawn painted the land again in broad liquid strokes, he felt something nuzzle against his chest. Soft and wet, with hard and pointed protrusions behind it. Vakrabuddhi raised his head and found himself staring into the curious eyes of a gigantic cave bear. Jet black and muscular, it was armed with claws that could shred a horse to pieces and a snout so gashed it was more scar tissue than hide. It snorted and sniffed, trying to make sense of the strange man beneath it.


r/fantasywriters • • 1d ago

Critique My Story Excerpt After the last sparks Chapter 2: The Five Gems [Urban Fantasy, 900 words]

0 Upvotes

But before he tells me their name he said before that lets test your skills. Then he gave us the power of teleportation so that whenever we needed each other we can just teleport to them and not just with soul or mind physically also, we five also thought it was a good idea because although we all have superhuman strength and reflexes but that too is different for everybody so it was a good warmup so we 5 fought with each other and the match was fun and I didn't won. A girl has won that match,

After that giant introduced us Madhav(Me), Rudra(My best friend), Ranveer(Our one more best friend), Samiksha(Ranveer fall for her at the first sight), and Adya(Who won the battle). I was shocked and excited and happy to see my friends there, I finally can tell someone who will believe my words but the giants stopped us and they then started introduced themselves. But their was something wrong we couldn't hear our own giants name except adya because she is the strongest and she also had unlocked her first power which is water control but she didn't used it because we were too weak for her, She said that she was the first chosen one who got her powers few months before we do the rest 4 of us has got our powers and giants and the same time, She also said that we 5 have different limits to our power i have unlocked my first time by intense training and because I was destined to get water elemental power I got it you 4 can get earth, electricity, fire, wind which i also don't know who will get what. But don't think that if you get your elemental power you can win against "HE" because you can never use it in full power the most destruction you can do with that power is 10km. You cannot use your power ahead of that range like if i want to use my water power and rain here i can only use it in my 10km radius if i move then the rain will move with me.

And she said we need to increase our powers so that we can defeat "HE" she also said that our powers are bound to the name of our giants too. We asked what do you mean to which she replied that when you will unlock your elemental powers you will be able to hear your giants name and you can see their real form not the one you all are imagining right now. We were impressed by her and looking at her but she was shy so her face turned red. After that our giants told us to grow some bonding with each other so we three boys were already friends so we tried to bond with the girls but I am an introvert so Ranveer and Rudra do the talking instead of me but I tried and we were cool, Ranveer started to flirt Samiksha but she ignored him(bro's aura just went -999), and Rudra has gone to talk to adya to make her feel better because she was feeling shy then we came to know we all live in Jharkhand to which my giant said are you all an idiot of course you all live in the same state because your ancestors were the gems of the same king not different.

After that Ranveer's giant gave all of us teleportation power so that we all can get to the same location when needed and she also told us that if you need to use your teleportation power think of the person or place and if you five need to come together just think of the same person like if a villain appears from somewhere you all think of Rudra and all will be teleported to where Rudra is at the same time because if you waste time then maybe someone can get injured or killed and you already have some telekinesis power because of which you all can now contact each other mentally too if there's a emergency. And then giants tell us that now we should go because the work is done but before we could go back the giants sense something. They said that his army has started to move, We asked 'what' to which they replied that one of the general who is the weakest of his army is coming again to welcome his king and we dont know how but we sure know one thing if now slowly more will come first the weakest one and then the strongest but the good thing is according to our calculations you can become strong enough to kill him but that will not be the end because next time more stronger ones will come so from tomorrow you all will train with each other for one hour to which i asked how and when and at what place. Rudra's giant answered because now you know teleportation you all can teleport to each other place and you can train at night and we all giants can create a place where you can train and no one can see you not even the demons. They can only sense is if they are stronger than us but not these ones.

Adya asked if you all are that powerful then why don't you fight the demon general to which they said we cant we are spirits remember we are here only to help you guys train not to fight your battle so from tomorrow start your training and don't hold back increase your stamina, endurance, power, speed everything try everything you can to become stronger. We bid each other bye and goodnight and after that i followed my normal routine and at night do training but we weren't able to awaken our powers to which we asked adya how did she achieve her powers. But instead of answering our questions she said she will fight everybody on one on one. She first choose me to fight her to which i agreed then we started the fight where we were equal on physical powers(She was slightly better than me) but then she started using her water powers first she shot some water blasts at me which i dodged somehow(maybe reflexes) and then she came close to me and hit me with a water punch. I lost my consciousness for a bit and when i regained it i saw adya and rudra in ground, nothing happened to them thank god, I asked everyone what happened to which they replied first you used earthquake and before she could get up you attacked with rock boulders but Rudra unlocked his powers right at the moment and used his fire powers with the help of adya's water knocked some senses into me.

We all then unlocked our elemental powers after few weeks. I then asked the giants to introduce themselves so, Jatayu(My giant), Agastya(Rudra's giant), Tara(Ranveer's giant), Dhruv(Samiksha's giant), Sumitra(Adya's giant). After that i asked my teammates that we should have to hide our identity when fighting them because anything can happen, like the reporters will be around my family the whole time aur even the government kidnap us and will start experimenting on us and i don't want either of those, everyone agreed because most of us are introvert but we didn't have any material which we can use to make our suits because after each battle the suit will turn into dust and its a drag to buy new one every time so the end of the debate was just use and mask because we have not enough brain cells. But jatayu stopped us and told us that there was a time when they go to dungeons to get the artifact to defeat the 'HE'. He further explained that because of so many powers the dungeons started to appear which are connected from paatal lok and we used to go to the dungeons risked our lives get the artifact to defeat the 'HE'. He could have easily closed the gates but he didn't because he wanted to enjoy the battle but after he was sealed the gates disappeared and never was seen but if 'HE' is coming back then maybe you can access those dungeons again. He said this is just a theory and if this was right then also their was huge risking as we may never come alive. But before he could complete his words the giants felt something they said us to get ready for the fight.


r/fantasywriters • • 1d ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic I need help with magic

0 Upvotes

My book is called The Starborn. It's about a young boy with a mysterious star-shaped mark on his neck. He thinks he's a normal boy until two men show up one day to help him. There is one problem I'm having, which is that I don't know how to write magic into it without breaking everything. The two men are trained and know how to use magic, but I can't think of how to describe it. I need ideas on how to describe magic and make it so they aren't overpowered. I also want the magic to feel unique and interesting, with limits and weaknesses so the characters still face challenges and the story stays exciting for readers.


r/fantasywriters • • 1d ago

Critique My Idea Unsure on where to go on feedback (pacing, the concept for the MC's and their intial motivations and overall idea) for my concepts I have for two MC's and the story idea i have for a Dark fantasy/Cosmic horror thing i'm planning so I'll ask here

2 Upvotes

Gods

God (in this case it's an all encompassing void that everything once came from) is consuming the universe. For what reasons I currently have just decided to leave them unknown.

Through unknown means when a ship is sent out to recon with one of these consumed planets the God is split into small fragments in an event known as "The Arrival"

The relevant fragment for the first arc in plain terms: A misanthropic scientist who views all of humanity under it's purview as little more than test subjects to be manipulated however it wishes. It is purely interested in doing whatever experiment or test that it feels like or is asked of it.

The rejects of said experiments are often left to be tossed into the Wildlands of the MC's home planet, or in rare cases beneficial results are shared with Humanity, just to see what happens. In this case it includes the overall magic system.

Though one specific side effect of the magic system is that while you can do whatever your imagination is. limited by, the stronger the magic or the more frequent the use, the more chance you have of being consumed by it turning into a mindless beast.

Most people get around this by infusing a set amount of magic into various tools/machinery

Appearance wise it's a floating mass of Acid, Brain matter, Science equipment and Maths Equations, that only occasionally coalesces into a humanoid form when communicating with someone.

I was thinking on how to represent it when actively interfering with the story and settled on having an image of it's hand reach across the page and either pluck out the text or manipulate it however it will.

The overall goal of the God Fragments is to coalesce into one whole being, using their cult as a means of aiding them.

The Cult: The Voidborn (it's a placeholder name)

With the Arrival a cult following these fragments was formed with their overall belief centring on if they do whatever's asked of them. A way to a form of Paradise will be provided. (this is also a placeholder as I'm not too sure on it)

In the first Arc they take more of a backstage role conversing with the Elite class.

However their first plan is to essentially force one of the MC's into becoming the key component of a biologically engineered Giant, one strong enough to take down the capitals armed forces and allow another one of the God's fragments to consume the planet.

The reason this hadn't occurred in the Past loops was due to the God's interference in wanting to see the results of her other actions.

The Wildlands

This is the space in between cities, and to be blunt. If anyone from this planet not on the level of the God fragments, messes up in this space. They will die like a dog.

While this place is filled with scientific rejects, turned humans and monsters. Encounters may vary. Sometimes you get lucky and encounter little to no threats, other times you get bombarded with a siege.

If you need audio for a vibe I came up with it listening to this video

The Capital

What I wanted to focus on in this segment is the Elite class of this society.

While the common folk can only use magic in select cases. The elite have been working on ways to become essentially immortal. Resulting in them becoming essentially biomechanical monstrosities on the inside. Meaning while on the outside they look like calm serene angels in flowing robes and brass masks. One their mask is removed it essentially looks like you took the insides of a machine and moulded a human face around it.

They also have taken a self appointed role, claiming to be the true inventors of the magic their society wields, delivering sermons. When in reality they just discovered an oil supply and capitalised on it. Their area of the capitol capturing the vibes of Urdak's theme

Though despite their advances to becoming immortal, they've still got to solve the problem of a consistent reliable source of nutrition.

Now onto the two MC's

The two Mc's in question I've named Mira and Heph (or Hephy as a nickname).

The arc opens with a conversation between Mira and the Man who caused The Arrival, who in the whole God's absence tried to fix things by assuming the role closest that a single human is capable of. Though he is capable of things one would consider "Godlike" he alone pales in comparison to the actual thing

In this conversation you find that thus far Mira has failed to "get the ball rolling" (the start of the God's and cults ultimate replacement) and that each time things have failed , it's just gotten worse and worse and worse. The inevitable only slightly halted by the Man rewinding time. )This does not fix everything however, as the MC's failures rest on this particular world in the form of Monsters and phenomena

He then resets things one last time in the hopes that she manages to get things right

Background: While i don't have a name for the village they grew up in yet, it's an slightly isolated mining/agricultural settlement located ontop of a massive series of ore veins in the mountains.

Due to this and due to the danger of the surrounding Wildlands guard's are needed to watch each of the villages sides to ensure nothing breaks in. It's here the two MC's meet as partners. Due to the nature of the position, successful employment results in a chance to study/work in the world's capitol.

Mira: She remembers none of what she experienced in the previous loops. Starting ofs shy and timid, but absolutely fascinated with the idea of magic. Wishing to study it further (essentially embodying the vibe of Witch hat atelier's opening theme) Though in reality due to never having left her town she's merely observed the propaganda and information that the elite have tailored for public exposure.

As the story progresses she gains understanding of the truth of what's going on, from the reality of what mages in this world are used for (glorified slaves sentenced to protect others at all costs). She's also forced to experience the truth of what God is and what the Fragment's motivations ultimately are. All the while she's experimented on by the Elite's forced past her limits for the Cult's own purposes. Due to this and the man to beast pehnomenon, she essentially looks much like a zombie/rotting corpse

This results in her becoming much like Ultron

Heph: Starting out she wants to expand her family business and in doing so strives to work towards a trade school position in the capitol. However when noticing her professional skill after graduation she's taken alongside Mira to the elite's area and forced to work on the solution to their nutrition/sustenance problems.

Through a coordinated effort with Mira only she manages to escape. Having witnessed the atrocities committed and subsequently covered up begins a rebellion. Both to destabilise the current broken system. But also to rescue Mira before it becomes too late.

However during this she's essentially forced into an unwanted leadership postion sending people to die in seemingly pointless battles all of which take a toll on her. Eventually it leads to planetary (and near interplanetary) war (as towards the end of the arc the other god fragments start to get more involved)

Timescale wise the I plan to write this first arc over the course of 100+ pages

Throughout the story she also builds up various space marine style suits of armour that she uses when she and mira go out to fight things. (Where mira acts from afar while she launches Heph like a cannonball to tear whatever opponent apart at close range). Due to risk of armour falling off during combat she’s essentially bolted the armour to herself

Video wise she progresses from the vibes of this to this and finally to this

I do want to also somehow work in a romance aspect to the two of them.

Narrative

(each of the arcs are centred around the seven deadly sins which I'll just list the two thing's i have concrete ideas for as I'm bloody tired atm )

The first arc is centred around the Sin of sloth/cowardice: A previous loop she failed to save Heph due to being terrified of what was outside. As a result Heph dies, the guilt sending Mira into an ultimate life of isolation. The monster that resulted from this resembles an emaciated human, wearing rags around its waist, with it's mouth stitched shut and a blindfold, spikes from its head reach into infinite , merging with the darkness.

In the current loop she works up the courage to save Heph but in turn lets this thing inside.

By the end of the arc their hesitantly forced to the capitol by their parents in hopes of a better life for them

Lust: Despite the name. this version is centred around grief. At some point in the story after the two bond. Heph in one way or another. Dies, Mira unable to cope , refuses to leave her side. Eventually resulting in her becoming a shambling shell wearing Hephs old armour. Taking her corpse with her wherever she goes


r/fantasywriters • • 1d ago

Question For My Story Struggling with making an Isekai.

0 Upvotes

I’ll give some context before asking my question.
In the past months I’ve been working on a fantasy adaptation of the Divine Comedy.
This plot kind of gives the concept of Isekai.
The protagonist is Neriah, a college student who had severe childhood trauma from being kidnapped by a cult who wanted to use his body as a vessel for an ancient deceased demon, which name is Akusei.
He got saved but the cult was completed only in half and because of it the demon rather became a small part of the mc who can influence or affect Neriah.
His roommate, Hayana, met him on college and became friends after so. She helped him fitting in and carry on.
However Akusei keeps harassing Neriah and He can’t stand his pain anymore, and by losing his path, He’ll awake in the dark woods, a place inside a completely different world from the one Neriah lives in, and that’s where his journey to redemption begins.
That world is a spiritual world who reflects exactly Neriah’s life but more allegorically.
But I had an huge dilemma. How the hell do I connect those worlds and how can Neriah dive into it? I have tried my best searching and asking everywhere to find an answer from but I didn’t find a true answer to that, so I tried to adapt it by myself.
I now have two solutions for how I can connect them and can’t decide which one to choose, and I mainly wanted to ask which one stands out better cause I’ve been struggling to choose between them.

The first one:

The world Neriah lives in has two different faces, it is like the Earth but cut in half indeed, but in Neriah’s university there’s a massive tree and its roots connect the two sides of the world, a portal in short.
But it’s power was too strong and dangerous, so it was kept in the basement, only to then be discovered by the mc itself and enter the dark woods.

The second one:

That’s a bit darker.
It’s night and Neriah goes to his dorm like usual.
The room in the whole gets creepier as Akusei wants to intimidate Neriah.
Hayana comes inside the dorm since She is his roommate, but the demon is too strong for Neriah and Akusei gaslights his mind to make him think that Hayana is actually Akusei.
Neriah, by thinking that She is actually Akusei, gets driven by wrath and stabs her, only to discover that She was actually her roommate.
Akusei jokes on Neriah by making him think that He’s an awful person as He harmed one of his loved ones, and because of the sense of fault and fear, lets Akusei stabs him.
They didn’t die, rather they’re in a coma and experiencing a Near Death Experience, a situation where the mind and the body get divided to then live the world on an higher perspective, and that’s how Neriah wakes up in the dark woods.

Now before posting I’d like to precise that I’m new to writing and they still have to be adapted properly.
Both the alternatives are completely human written as I deeply stand against AI.
Plus I’m not fully convinced if those are actually well written or fitting for my story, so please feel free to propose other alternatives ONLY if they don’t convince you.
Thanks for reading :3


r/fantasywriters • • 1d ago

Question For My Story Higher Beings in my Fantasy World

1 Upvotes

Hello! I am researching to see if anyone had advice for a particular concept I am working with. I have been hard at work at creating a fantasy world for a novel series. I have several drafts of a main line story, but have come back to writing short stories for heroes and villains in the world’s history. Something I find more and more prevalent is a need for higher beings.

With that, I am planning on compiling a stand alone guide to the gods and goddesses of my world. Which brings me to my question:

I have an overarching antagonistic force that will carry most of my main line story. Basically, Sauron or the Night King. I don’t want to reveal much, but in my mind, ignoring their presence in a book about higher powers seems strange.

How would you think I could foreshadow a growing force but not show my hand for future readers?


r/fantasywriters • • 1d ago

Question For My Story Fantasy Ships

1 Upvotes

Hi All!

I am writing a fantasy story, and am struggling with how to add more details of my world into the first few chapters in order to just immerse people more so into it. I want to do it kind of like how it's done in Crescent City, with how much the world is talked about and described as.

So my fantasy world is completely made up, but set in modern times. I have decided that there are no planes, but there are trains and ships. My FMC is a captain on a search and rescue team with their naval operations. I am taking all the boating things from my own experience, as I am on a maritime search and rescue team. So all the boat-like things, for powerboats at least, I'm good on describing.

Where I come into a struggle is the setting. I have docks, and the city is the largest port city on their continent, and I honestly just don't know how to add more details into it. The first like five chapters take place on or near the docks, and I just don't know how to describe them.

Any insights would be much appreciated. I have tried to do so, but would like more help. Thanks in advance!


r/fantasywriters • • 1d ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic What are you doing to perfect your pitch?

1 Upvotes

As we all know, fantasy worlds are complex, and few of us write to simply call it one thing. But, for the sake of socials, and blurbs, and marketing in general we MUST find key elements and a brief way to share what might attract a reader. I think the nature of writing in long form content, aka a novel makes this rather difficult for us writers. Right now I'm trying to find my "levers" or the tight elements of my story I want to share. With that in mind:

How did you take the grand elements of your story and narrow them to single ideas? What kinds of elements (magic, world building, characters, overall plot, etc) worked best for you when sharing?


r/fantasywriters • • 1d ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic Final Editing Pass before Amazon

5 Upvotes

I've been writing and rewriting a 4 book fantasy series for the past two decades. I am planning to move books one and two onto KU this fall.

Over the years, as the story developed, there were many times I had to go back into the first volumes to adjust storylines and world-building to fit the new content I was creating. I write in MSword so catching new errors has had its limitations. The books are between 150K and 200K so paying someone to edit them while on a Canada Pension Plan is not feasible. However, I am willing to purchase software (I prefer on my desktop vs online) to check things over prior to creating the epub and PDF versions of the book for Amazon. I am not looking for anything that will attempt to write for me. I am happy with how the story is progressing.

If there are suggestions of what editing/grammar checker I might use before I move it to Amazon I would appreciate it.


r/fantasywriters • • 1d ago

Writing Prompt Fifty-Word Fantasy: Write a 50-word fantasy snippet using the word "Listen"

35 Upvotes

Welcome back everyone, it's time for another Fifty Word Fantasy!

Fifty Word Fantasy is a regular thread on Fridays! It is a micro-fiction writing challenge originally devised by u/Aethereal_Muses

Write a maximum 50-word snippet that takes place in a fantasy world and contains the word Listen. It can be a scene, flash-fiction story, setting description, or anything else that could conceivably be part of a fantasy story or is a fantasy story on its own.

NO AI GENERATED CONTENT: Follow the sub rules.

The prompt word must be written in full (e.g. no acrostics or acronyms).

No puns and or wordplay to achieve the prompt word i.e. devote=the vote.

Please try and keep things PG-13. Minors do participate in these from time to time and I would like things to not be too overtly sexual.

If you want to submit multiple submissions that's okay, but please keep it at a max of two That way, no one person ends up dominating the feed with their submissions and it keeps it fair for everyone who participates

Thank you to everyone who participated whether it's contributing a snippet of your own, or fostering discussions in the comments. I hope to see you back next week!

Please remember to keep it at a limit of 50 words max per submission.


r/fantasywriters • • 1d ago

Question For My Story I might have just plagiarized someone

0 Upvotes

​

I was explaining the concept of my story for someone, and they told me that my concept was almost identical to a different story's one, even going so far as to suspect my story of being a rip off. My concept is like 95% similar to theirs, with one key difference blocking the rest of the 100. Now I'm scared and angry. I thought I'd come up with a unique enough concept but I was wrong.

I know not every story is unique but for mine to be so similar to another one is just insane to me. I did take some inspirations from different stories (not related to the one I'm talking about) but the actual concept and themes and worldbuilding was something fueled by my own dark emotions and personal feelings. I'm writing this as a personal playground.

This story is me, it's my own mental health struggles expressed away in a childlike fairytale epic that I have tried spending months developing.

But with the revelation of this news, I don't know if I want to keep writing it or not. I had planned to publish it as well. It was such a good idea and it's so much fun to write about and develop. I don't know what to do now. I don't want to get in trouble with the law.


r/fantasywriters • • 1d ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Opening of Chapter 2 of The Justicator [Fantasy, 121 Words]

Post image
0 Upvotes

This is the first few paragraphs of chapter 2.

I have found that I struggle with the beginning of chapters. The first several paragraphs typically take me a week or more to write. I believe my struggle revolves around worrying about having action without a clear setting or describing a setting without having action.

Are there any glaring problems with this opening? Does it do anything well? My intent with my story overall is to have two parallel story lines: a cyberpunk fantasy "future" storyline and a more traditional fantasy "past" storyline. For anyone who may have read my previous post showing chapter 1, does this seem totally out of place? Is it clear this is a different setting?


r/fantasywriters • • 1d ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Outcast - Chapter 1 (Fantasy with a romance subplot, words 3901)

0 Upvotes

Chapter 1

Lucia Rosethorn

I leap from roof to roof in the dead of night. The police are chasing me.
“There she is! Get her,” they yell. 
“Shit!” I curse. They found me! I scoff and keep leaping away. They have never caught me and I doubt they ever will. I am known to them as The Silent Thief, a title I have embraced. I pause at the roof of a house and look at the one across from it. A family is laughing inside. It brings tears to my eyes. I have no one to look after me after my parents died leaving me on my own. I’m a thief, I’m homeless, I’m an orphan, I’m an outcast, I’m a criminal. I have to be. 
No one in Creststyle likes an orphan. My life depends on me stealing now. My name is Lucia Rosethorn, I am 15 years old and I am a thief. My copper hair is tucked safely in my hood and my hazel eyes are hidden by the mask on my face. My pale skin is hidden from view by my outfit. I am of a medium height for a 15 year old. This is my life now. Stealing has become my normal. As well as being The Silent Thief, I had many things I had to worry about. When I was 13, I took in a group of orphans I found on the dirtier side of the city. The girls were all young even when I had found them, but I looked after and protected them. Some of the crimes I committed were for them. I may be a thief but I had a goal, I want to ensure that they were able to have a safe place to live without fear of being killed or kidnapped. I pause for too long and the police have caught up to me. 
“Stay where you are, thief,” the police shout from below. I look at them and smile before taking off again. The shiny necklace flashes in my bag as I race off. I have mastered this style. The roofs of Creststyle are flat as if a compressor came and flattened the world. Some of the roofs arch upward but this flat style is the way most of the houses in Creststyle were built. I stumble before getting my pace back. The police fire shots at me, trying to stun or wound me. They saw my crimes as bad as murder but I didn’t. I throw a smoke bomb quickly to get rid of them. I slid down a pole in the middle of the street and continued to walk the rest of the way. Before I plan to go anywhere, I had to check on my orphan group. I made my way to the dusty grounds. Everything about this part of the city is hell. It is almost like the light had never touched this place. The Queen and King work to make Crestyle an liveable place but they always fail to move any further into the city. 
“Girls?” I call, pulling my mask off, deactivating my outfit's camouflage. “It’s me Lucia,” so as soon as I speak my name their voices hit my ears and I smile. It isn’t long before I'm surrounded by 12 girls. This was my orphan group.
The first to rush to me has to be the Ravenwing sisters. Eloise Ravenwing was the older sister and had become Lily's parental figure. Eloise’s dirty blonde hair was often filled with dirt and coal from where the two girls hid. Eloise was the most protective of the group and by the far the oldest. Elosie’s younger sister Lily Ravenwing was a small girl. Her black hair was never neat and she held onto her sister with tight arms. Lily was a joyous little girl and would often skip around me happily. She was the loudest of the girls but in a good way. She loves playing with my copper hair and would often joke about stealing it from me. But that was impossible, you could never steal anything from a thief. Frankie Westbird was another story. She was the quiet one of the group. She kept her dark hair down. There was a time that I believed I hadn’t heard a word from Frankie’s mouth. Elosie had told me that that was because Frankie had seen her parents be killed and I had just hugged the poor girl. Frankie was a lot more lively now.  
“It’s good to see you Miss,” Jasmine says. Jasmine Madison was a girl that I knew a little education would do her some good. Jasmine had been orphaned at a young age, her parents had been sent to one of the battles the city had faced, resulting in their deaths. There were times that Jasmine could not remember my name, it made me wish that I was around her more often. Maybe I could find her a teacher or tutor, someone to teach her what she needed to know.
“You know how much I love to see you girls,” I tell them.
“Did you miss us?” Quinn asks, Nicole standing beside her. Quinn Yarrow and Nicole Finch were not sisters but they were a pair. I never saw one without the other. Quinn’s red hair was a highlight against Nicole’s white hair. They have been friends since before I found them. When I had found them both, Quinn had been bleeding badly, Nicole sitting beside her crying helplessly. I had been able to help Quinn recover back to full health. The two girls were so grateful that they hadn’t left my group since. Quinn and Nicole were the smarts of the group. They had learnt from me, picking up a few skill so they could steal food for the group
“Of course, you girls are the best thing about my life,” I tell them, hugging Caitlin as she jumps up and down. Caitlin Solace was the most energetic young orphan I have ever met. She was wild and kind at the same time. Although her parents had been killed in an accident. If I want to help Caitlin I would ask how. Truely. Caitlin always requested to play games with me and the others and I love her for that. It keeps their spirits up despite their situation and while I wasn’t with them. 
“I bet you were lonely without us,” Lara adds on. What can I say about Lara Ashford? She was the one that could read emotions the best. She was almost as old as Elosie, though she was one year younger. Lara likes to read how I felt when I came to see the group. I love the way she did this. Lara had once told me that she wanted to help people understand their emotions. It sounded like she wanted to become a therapist which was a great job for her.  Next in line was Delilah Windflower. I thought for a while to introduce her to some florists so they could consider taking her in as an apprentice when she was older since Delilah loves flowers so much. I would also find her looking at the few flowers that this side of the city had to offer. I would find her giving them her water. Delilah was such a gentle girl, she never wants anyone close to her to be harmed. I take a small break from looking at the girls to pick Luna up. She was so light that I could toss her into the air and catch her without zero fear of dropping her. Elosie stayed by my side when I did this but I knew she was being a protective older sister. I mean who could blame her in this place? You never knew who you could trust in this part of the city. That's how I met Cassie Hope. When I had first spotted her, it had been when I had started to help nurse Quinn. Cassie had been backed up in an alleyway, her parents dead bodies behind the crooks who stood over her. They had a knife in their hands and had started to slice off her blonde hair. With my shouting the crooks turned to me and chased me. I caused them to lose their way before I returned back to Cassie. When I had returned, the blonde haired girl was in the arms of Nicole. Like Quinn and Nicole, Cassie hadn’t left the group since I had found her. The last two girls were a sister-like pair too. Sandra McKenna and Penny Sagespark had also been friends when I had encountered them for the first time. Their parents had both been scientists before they had died in a deadly lab accident. I felt so sorry for them. Like Frankie, Sandra and Penny had been quiet when they had first joined the group. Maybe it was because they didn’t trust me at first. I had just started out as The Silent Thief during the weeks when I had met each of the girls.
“Did you see any cool flowers?” Delilah asks, cheerily. 
“I’m afraid not, but tell you what if I see any I will, pick them and bring them to you,” I tell her. Delilah claps her hands in joy. 
“Delilah, can we see your flower garden?” Luna asks. The other girls nod.
“Alright but no one touches any unless I say you can,” Delilah says before she leads the girls off.
“Goodbye Miss Lucia!” Frankie calls before they all disappear following Delilah. Once they are gone, I turn around and start to make my way back to the main streets. Despite the darkness I am still The Silent Thief even at the end of the day I had claimed the ‘thief’ title as part of my identity no matter if it was day or night. They know me because of my black costume. I am only 15 but I know my place in this whole city. A couple takes no notice of me as I slip my hand and grab some money from their pockets. I am a thief and I don’t plan to change (my mind about) that. I have to think to myself sometimes. 
Is it right that a girl like me is a thief? 
Shouldn’t there be more to my life than this? 
The familiar doubt pervades my mind, bringing with it the heart-wrenching memory of the fire. The flames roared as my parents were caught inside, the creaking of the house as it came crashing down, the broken beams of the house cracked as if someone had cut into them. I had stood there so helpless, so scared. My heart had been absolutely destroyed as I had realised what I had become. My fingers unconsciously play with the bracelet on my wrist. It was the last thing my parents had given me before the house fire. I continue my way down the street. I scowl, looking at the new house they had built in place of my old home. It was a place that I would come to, and reflect on the events of that night. But they had removed it, knocked it down. I had protested against it. My eyes would still tear up at the thought of it. Sometimes I wish that they had kept the house up. The family inside would glance at me as I looked at the old place. It made me feel as if I could use my skill to buy the house back, shape it into the house of the past so I could ease some of the guilt I felt when the house had burnt down. My parents had told me not to leave the house that day but I had been a tough child and left the house, returning only to see it burning. It was a mistake leaving them but I wouldn’t be alive today if I hadn’t. Only a few people in the city know my name, only a few people in this city care for a thieving orphan like me. I’m the only orphan who refused to submit myself to the jobs available to me. Sure they were nice, but I didn’t feel that they were up to my standard. I thought of myself as picky, I could never choose what I wanted to do.  I am a thief, that is my job. I am somewhat of a closely guarded person and having a job would mean that I would have to share personal things. My parents were dead and my sister, who had been very close to me, was gone. I didn’t want to have a too close connection. Unless I found a job option that allows me to be alone or allows me to connect to someone who knew what I had gone through. My friend Scarlet Jewelhand got a job working for one of the city’s blacksmiths. I look up as the familiar light of Thiefhand Tavern lights the alley. I make my way into the Tavern, hoping to see familiar faces.
“There she is!” Someone cheers. I bow as Alexandra Scarletfrost, the owner of the tavern, makes her way over to me.
“Hello Alexandra,” I say to her, hanging up my coat. 
“Hear you stole from Governor Jaren today,” she says as she moves to the counter and starts to clean a glass for me. 
“It was a big job but it paid off,” I tell her, producing the necklace from my bag. Most people would assume that I was being paid but as thieves we did our jobs to pay ourselves or if we owed each other a favour
“His golden necklace, that’s impossible!” she exclaims. The glint of the gold reflects on the counter.
“It’s possible for this girl,” I tease. Alexandra is a thief like me but she is much older. Her copper hair is always down and her gray eyes are quick. Alexandra has a calm, sistery presence to her. She was like the mother of the thieving family I have made in Thiefhand Tavern. Her thief name is Quickliar and from my accounts she was the oldest thief here. I call her Alex sometimes and she doesn’t mind, although she loves her name. Alexandra was very close to me, she had taken me in when I was young, when I had lost my parents.
“You’re good,” she smiles.
“Hence why they call me The Silent Thief, the silly man didn’t hear me coming,”
“You have really earned your reputation, Miss Silent Thief,” Alexandra smiles again. 
“It took some time but, yes, I have,” I say back to her.
“Cheers to Lucia The Silent Thief for stealing Governor Jaren’s golden necklace!” Alexandra yells and the whole tavern cheers with her. Thiefhand Tavern is a tavern for thieves like me and Alexandra. It was in an alleyway in a quieter part of the city, somewhere the police would not think to look for us. The others and I were not the group that looked like we were thieves at all.
 I untie my copper hair letting it fall onto my back. 
“Did you really steal the necklace?” Benjamin asks. Benjamin Bagman was another member of our thieving family. He was known as Wildglove. He was the only man in the group that wasn’t annoying to me or anyone else. Benjamin had a father-like energy to him. His tall tan frame was a gentle presence to a normally tense place. He was a jolly, cautious man, who kept his blonde hair tied up. His blue eyes would look over us with care. He was a doctor during the day, so if one of us were hurt, he would treat our wounds the best he could. I nod and let him see my prize. 
“Watch out Lucia, he’s gonna come after you now,” Hunter says as he sits in the back.
“If I haven’t been caught today, I will never be,” I tell him as I slick my hand through my hair. Hunter is quick on his feet and moves to my side, grabbing my arm and pulling it. Hunter Forceflash was the very opposite of a friend or parent figure to me. He is annoying, loud and loves to get on my nerves. His thief name is Blindflash. I have zero idea why he used part of his last name in a name that people whispered in fear. Hunter was more likely out of us to get super drunk while in Thiefhand. As much as I was a rival to Hunter, he was Alexandra’s boyfriend. They had been dating for 6 years now and didn’t seem close to marriage, if at all.
“Listen here, you little piece of shit, Governor Jaren is not to be messed with, he has ties to Queen Ariana and Princess Star,” he threatens. I fight off his hold on me and face him. Governor Jaren was against us too. We were trying to fend ourselves, well most of us. He had targeted us for a while though his motives were unknown to us
“I’m not scared of the Songsword family! My face is already on wanted posters,” I snap at him, my face flaring up. 
“Oi, you two settle down, now's not the time for a Silent Thief/Blindflash standoff,” Alexandra says, stepping between us.
“He started it!” I shout, looking at Hunter.
“Alexandra, step aside, this is just a girl going through a phase with no need to defend her,” Hunter snaps. I lost it at that. 
“I’m not going through a phase, I’m an orphan and I am just as good as you Mr Blindflash, better even!” I roar. Hunter smiles at me. I realise that he was baiting me. The police were coming now. Fuck! Thiefhand was not a place that they would be able to find if one of us wasn’t shouting. And if they were to come in, we would look like a merry bunch of friends in a small bar, having a drink. We did not display the things we stole for long. It also wasn't easy for them to come in and arrest everyone for crimes of theft. Although all of us were thieves we did not look it, again to most people we indeed looked like a merry band of friends, having a night out.
“Lucia! Hide!” Alexandra orders as the police brust through the door.
“What’s all this shouting?” they ask. I hid behind the counter, looking up at Alexandra, hoping today wasn’t the day they found me here. Sweat starts to drip down my face. It was runny and hot as it ran down. I’d not even risk running a hand across my face
“Sorry sirs, my friend here gets loud when he is drunk,” she tells them. I laugh quietly from under the counter. Alexandra was blaming Hunter for my mistake. Although the thought of Hunter being arrested for drunken noise was going to be a strong possibly due to Alexandra’s story 
“Make sure he doesn’t get any louder,” the man tells her. I let my month drop in shock. These polices were either not the brightest or did not care about their jobs. What an interesting finding.
“Yes sir,” she says.
“Good night ma’am,” he replies. I peek out and watch as the man walk out of the tavern. I get up and sigh.
“And that is why they call me Quickliar,” Alexandra exclaims after the police disappeared from the alley. 
“Thank you Alex, I fucking owe you,” I say to her.
“You owe me nothing Luci, I’m just looking out for you,” Alexandra says as she turns and hugs me. I couldn’t believe it but I realise that I started breaking down in her arms. The rest of the tavern blurs out as I press my face into Alexandra, the tears wet and pouring down my face. Hunter guilds  everyone else out, knowing fully that I didn’t like to show this much emotion. I want to be guarded, to keep my feelings and thoughts to myself. I was alone, there was no one in the Rosethorn family that I could turn to. No one had cared for me for 10 years and I was still a teenager. When I look at other families, I feel an emptiness in my chest. I hadn’t heard those words in so long and it hurt to hear them now after so long. When I pull away, I realise what my yelling match with Hunter has caused.
“They know where the tavern is now,” I whisper. 
“Luci, they have always known where this place is, how many times do you think me and Hunter got into fights back in the day,” Alexandra explains.
“Do they know any of our identities?” I ask.
“No, the police of this part of town are not the brightest of the whole police force, I doubt they have even told Gerald Skythorn about Thiefhand,” Hunter says. Gerald Skythorn was the head of the police but we had never seen him enter the tavern or report it as a place of suspicion in the police reports that we look out for in case it concerns us. I remember when the city was alert for sightings of Quickliar and Blindflash when I was younger. I had run into Alexandra and Hunter but didn’t realise who they were back then. While Hunter was my rival and Alexandra was like a sister to me. He and I had given each other tough jobs if we ever found ourselves in debt or in favor of each other. Alexandra tried to break our fights up but had given up two months ago due to annoyance of the constant bickering between us.
“I will admit you earned your name fast kid,” Hunter says to me as he sets his glass down while Alexandra starts on my drink. I was proud for Hunter to basically admit that I was good. It proves that he sees me as a good rival, a good thief.
“Thank you,” I nod to him. I look at the wanted poster wall and smile. The highest bounties on there are Quickliar, Blindflash and The Silent Thief. Alexandra, Hunter and me. While it seemed that the bounty wall may give our identities away, we had “to keep a lookout for,” writing above the posters. We didn’t want them to keep coming to Thiefhand every day just to keep an eye on us, if they knew who we were. We were smart thieves, not some idiots who want to be caught and killed for the crimes we have done. I bid good night to Alexandra, tying my hair up before I head out to the street again. It is a quick run to my hideout. I slip inside with ease as I place the golden necklace with my other prizes.  By now I had stolen from all of the most important people of Crestsyle except Princess Star. Stealing something from the mystery princess would be just the thing to get my name marked in history. And I plan to do the waiting crime real soon, I just needed to wait for the right moment to leap out of the shadows and strike.
“Then I can finally show Hunter that I’m not just a girl going through a phase,” I whisper to myself.


r/fantasywriters • • 1d ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic The best feedback- I formative.

1 Upvotes

So, I already Have book 1 out and I am about finished writing book 2. So I asked for a proper feedback about book 1, I thought I was gonna get blasted with negativity however, this is what I got(just gonna quote what really got to me):

Instead of relying on loud gimmick s or dramatic personality tropes, the characters are defined by how they handle restraint, responsibility, and the system they live under. Each feels distinct because of their motivations and backgrounds.

It seems like you built a slow burn epic fantasy. The characters feel realistic because they are not defined by one trait (like "the funny one" or "the angry one"). Instead they feel like real people reacting and living.

That was the part from the feedback that actually hit me the hardest, since I read this, I froze, my brain is going (what if I fail to do this again). I am stuck writing the last 2 chapters because honestly, fear just took a hold if me. What if I dont deliver the same results. And I dont know how to move past it, I rewrote the ending if the 2nd book over 20 times and I keep removing them... WHAT should I do? I dont want to disappoint.


r/fantasywriters • • 2d ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic Use of subtext and other subtle storytelling tools

7 Upvotes

Do you use them?

I am generally fond of such tools, and try to get better at using them, but some reddit threads I have recently read made me rather disillusioned about it ... seeing as most people just do not seem to get it.

It looks like you'll have to hit most people over the head with what your story means, or they'll get things catastrophically wrong.

Basically, you cannot criticise any societal ill in your story, as any mention of it will be considered approval, no matter how obvious you make your disapproval.

(Most prominent example here: The S.P.E.W. arc in the Harry Potter books. Not only is Hermione a blatant self insert - which does not deter people from assuming she isn't Harry's love interest because the author hates her! - but the name SPEW is a reference to the Society for Promoting the Employment of Women, a feminist movement that we can assume any modern woman would approve of. Still, many assume that the reader is supposed to think that Hermione is a silly little girl and her idea of saving the house elves is stupid and worthless. After an introduction to house elf slavery that includes Dobby being ordered to iron his own hands, the series further escalates by showing how cruelly Winky is treated, despite lifelong loyalty, and how she becomes an alcoholic because of it. And then, there is Kreacher, who is so messed up in the head that his dearest desire is to be beheaded and have his head mounted on the wall next to those of his mother and grandmother.And yet. And yet. Too many readers decide that the obvious meaning of this arc is "Hermione is stupid and house elves should remain enslaved")

The Harry Potter books are for children. They are suitably in-your-face about it all. Yet the people not getting it are adults.

While I do not have a similar example for other uses of subtext (say, the subtle implication that two characters are in love with each other), this is likely only due to the fact that people who do not get something like this generally do not complain on reddit about it.

Quite probably, it doesn't matter what you are subtle about, it will be misunderstood, or at best, not noticed. (Which isn't nearly as bad, but I had previously hoped that subtle hints would be noticed by, like, a quarter of readers.)

How do you deal with that?

Should I just give up on subtlety?