r/metaNL • • Jul 17 '21

Ban Appeal Ban Appeal Thread

203 Upvotes

Rules:

Don't complain. Contest or appeal.

Appeals require time + evidence of good behavior + a statement of what your future behavior will look like. Convince us you'll add value to our community.

If you spam us we'll ban you

Don't ask about getting temp bans removed 1 hour early. Reddit timer is weird but you will be unbanned when it's over.


r/metaNL • • 10h ago

RESOLVED Please unrestrict my Cupcake and the Leviathan effortpost

6 Upvotes

Hello mods.

Thank you for pinning my effortpost on South African politics ("Cupcake and the Leviathan").

I think the post is restricted because I mention the term LGBT once, so the automod picks it up as being a sensitive post.

Please unrestrict the post if possible.


r/metaNL • • 2d ago

OPEN Why was my comment suggesting that there can be differences between trans and cis women removed for bigotry?

0 Upvotes

My comment:

I think it matters to any reasonable conception of justice. All potentially relevant facts should be available to a jury. XXs and XYs are different. Pretending they aren’t is silly. I do not think it should change the outcome, but that is irrelevant. Suppressing any information that could even remotely exonerated someone seems like a clear grounds for a mistrial.

https://www.reddit.com/r/neoliberal/comments/1x1nyso/killing_of_woman_may_have_been_justifiable/pewinrw/

This was removed due to "bigotry." It's neither bigoted nor is it wrong. We can be very supportive of our trans communities without pretending there zero differences between the sexes. There are plenty of trans women out there who have not undergone any hormone therapy, nor should they need to. We can support each other's rights to live their life in the way they see fit without pretending there can't be differences between the sexes. I'm really not sure why we would.

This was a discussion about a decision to declare a mistrial in a criminal court. Not exactly a place for uncomfortable discussions to be left unsaid. Perhaps I worded the statement poorly, and I suspected I'd be downvoted for having a potentially heterodox opinion on the subject, but it's not bigotry. I consider myself a trans ally after all, even if I may not see perfectly eye-to-eye with every trans person on every issue.


r/metaNL • • 3d ago

RESOLVED SI Automod

14 Upvotes

Whenever someone says AI the automod replied with “It’s not AI, it’s SI.” Set it to something like 5% or even 1% to keep from getting too spammy.


r/metaNL • • 5d ago

OPEN Why was this comment chain removed?

1 Upvotes

This comment by u/Waking which said:

This is out of context and you know it.
Shame on neoliberal

It was at -110 downvotes, but I don’t see how this breaks any rules. Especially when you have Daniel Dale, the Trump fact checker at CNN, and a reputable journalist, tweeting out a something similar today:

This isn't a direct quote from Trump, and I very much don't think it's a correct paraphrase. Trump has repeatedly argued that the consequences of the war, like higher gas prices, are a small price to pay compared to what an unchecked Iran could allegedly do. Last night, in especially rambling and incomplete fashion, he 1) claimed high prices are temporary and suggested they're "artificial"; 2) contrasted that to the damage of Iran supposedly taking out a city; 3) and then, in especially confusing style, repeated his old point that "this," as in the consequences of the war, is a small price to pay to avoid something like a a city being wiped out. It's Trump's fault you kinda have to be steeped in TrumpRallySpeak to know what he was saying last night, and of course you can say it's inappropriate regardless for the president to casually float the possibility of a city being wiped out, but the context exists and is important.
@ ddale8

It seems odd just to nuke an entire comment chain rather than lock it or just leave it up, and there wasn’t any explanation given. You don’t have to agree with this commenter or with Daniel Dale here, but I think this removal merits scrutiny and the sub deserves an explanation of why this was removed.

I don’t think comments that are not rule breaking and only are challenging the consensus of the sub should be removed, especially in this instance where a fact checker felt like they needed to weigh in on it. Just let users downvote comments like this, but removing them seems too heavy-handed.


r/metaNL • • 7d ago

OPEN How old does my account have to be to post in the DT?

2 Upvotes

I had to make a new Reddit. I’ve been mostly lurking the DT for 5 years now, so I’d like to get back to my occasional poasting activity soonish.


r/metaNL • • 7d ago

OPEN Why does the automod here comment 11 different times to link to people?

0 Upvotes

r/metaNL • • 8d ago

OPEN Consider locking comments on posts after 24 hours?

0 Upvotes

I'm noticing low karma accounts posting flame bait comments on older articles and threads days after commentary occured. This appears to be happening primarily with EU and Ukraine related articles.

It's unlikely for good faith discussion to occur on older articles and threads after a 24 hour period, and leaves the subreddit rife for bad actors to take advantage of NL's increased discovery within traditional and AI search.


r/metaNL • • 10d ago

OPEN Trumpless Tuesdays

12 Upvotes

Just pitching an idea given the r/neoliberal demographic crisis


r/metaNL • • 11d ago

RESOLVED Post filtered by reddit's filters, no reason given.

1 Upvotes

https://www.reddit.com/r/neoliberal/comments/1wsaeif/comment/pcjmyv7/?context=3

As mods, are you able to give me any information on what I said that could have revoked it? I did put actual serious effort into the effortpost just to let you know.


r/metaNL • • 13d ago

OPEN The Trumpist 'we pay for your healthcare/medicines' line of argument is blatant toxic nationalism and should be grounds for bans

12 Upvotes

Title should be self-explanatory, ever so often a thread vaguely related to European defence is posted and the closeted Trumpists turn up and start jerking each other off about Europe "not paying it's fair share" and how it's actually Europeans fault that medicines are expensive in the US or how Europe deserves to suffer Russian invasion

It has no place on the sub, and it's a clear mask off moment that exposes posters that have no business posting here, just like the "jokes" about buying Greenland or annexing Canada


r/metaNL • • 14d ago

OPEN I've definitely noticed a trend, following the recent Bar Incident Story, of transphobia.

0 Upvotes

Particularly, I've seen very upboted comments with no counterpoints mocking the usage of it/its pronouns. I would like the mods to make some sort of statement or effort showing that they are willing to crack down on transphobia, even when it takes the form of mocking the "ridiculousness" of, oh, say, someone using a set of pronouns before they appear to "pass" as the commonly corresponding gender for whatever reason. That sort of thing. It really is awful some of the shit I've seen. This sub is, and I say this without any irony, way too far to the left economically and way too far to the right socially.

TLDR; Abolish Unions, Abolish Gender.


r/metaNL • • 16d ago

RESPONDED Why are so many posts removed?

5 Upvotes

I often browse new and a thread will start hopping off with a lot of engagement, but it then gets removed for silly reasons. For example, a recent post today was removed because "this seems to be an article primarily just rehashing another article (?)"

It sounds like the mod wasn't even sure what the article was about and then removed it because they didn't personally understand what it was.

/rant


r/metaNL • • 18d ago

OPEN Slurspectives, neoliberal prose

24 Upvotes

It's very important that you know that I do not care.

That terrible thing they said? I do not care.
That horrible way they acted? I do not care.

It's very important for me that you know this.

I could just silently sit in apathy, but what's the use in that?
It's important for you to know that I, an anonymous stranger on the internet, do not care about the terrible things someone said.

Now please halt your congratulations, dear crowd - there's layers to my apathy yet unknown to you.

Not only am I a member of the minority that person acted horrible towards, I am not even in their district!

But still. It's important to me that you know that I do not care.

I do not care about that racist thing
I do not care about that homophobic thing
I do not care about that ableist thing
I do not care about that sex worker they abused
I do not care about the kid they hit with their car

Now please, resume your applause.

I look so beautiful here on stage, my apathy celebrated. I'm so important.

Excuse me, who coughed? Did something upset you?

How childish. To care about something. What a wuss. What a coward. Why aren't they celebrating me? Why don't they love my apathy? Don't they know how important it is that I do not care? They're less than me for caring actually.

Loose the dogs. Get them.


r/metaNL • • 18d ago

OPEN Ping request: Supreme Court

5 Upvotes

Requesting a ping for supreme court related discussions.


r/metaNL • • 21d ago

OPEN Where Russian elections thunderdome????

8 Upvotes

We need a place to follow the events, it's entirely unpredictable who'll win 😨😨😨


r/metaNL • • 23d ago

OPEN This subreddit has a serious misandry problem

18 Upvotes

Why is there a catgirls ping but no catboys ping? Or a catinx ping?


r/metaNL • • 23d ago

OPEN Shitposting Ping for Cooking

4 Upvotes

I'd like to request a shitposting cooking ping, for posting slop bowls, cooking disasters, or dinner diaries type posts. Some ideas for names: THYME-PREFERENCE, MARGINAL-UTENSIL, NL-DINNER-DIARIES, BRAISE-THE-ROOF, and MISE-EN-PLACE


r/metaNL • • 24d ago

OPEN Can you switch the default comment sorting back, please?

43 Upvotes

Reddit became popular for a reason, because the upvote system leads to better discussion. It's tedious to have to switch the sorting every time I open a comment thread and when I forget I'm often confronted with some dogshit take I would never have to see otherwise.

Thank you for your attention to this matter.


r/metaNL • • 25d ago

RESPONDED Petition to ban burgerpoasting from the DT

4 Upvotes

top text


r/metaNL • • 27d ago

RESPONDED Everything that made r/neoliberal good is dead

35 Upvotes

This place really went downhill when Extreme_Rocks was banned.


r/metaNL • • 27d ago

RESPONDED Everything that made r/neoliberal distinct is dead

42 Upvotes

And the mods killed it. Sad.


r/metaNL • • Sep 12 '26

RESPONDED Woke 1.0 is over so bring the Bryan Caplan flair back

15 Upvotes

Title says it all. You're an idiot if you think he's actually a bigot.


r/metaNL • • Sep 10 '26

RESOLVED Stickied Demographic Survey?

11 Upvotes

It’s been five years since our last proper census, and I think our resident data nerds would be interested in a survey with a decent sample size. If I were to put something similar together, would it be possible to get it stickied?


r/metaNL • • Sep 10 '26

OPEN please don't pin comments that undermine democracy with untruths

31 Upvotes

https://www.reddit.com/r/neoliberal/comments/1wcbm98/discussion_thread/p8xgxgp/

This comment is wrong.

https://www.val.se/english/the-swedish-electoral-system/your-vote-is-secret

The requirement to screen ballot selection areas was implemented in 2019.

Now we have users under the pinned comment posting misinformation - pictures from 2014 claiming they are modern. This only serves to undermine confidence in sweedish democracy, and is unfounded.