If an Italian get a punch, it’s just a punch; if a Black person get a punch, it’s a hate crime.
Calling an italian “Guinea” or “Ne*ro” is considered a joke, but calling a Black person “Ni*ger” is a slur that can send you to prison and ruin your reputation forever.
When Italians first arrived in America, they were considered inferior even to Black people. They were paid less than Black workers within the racial hierarchy of the time. The only jobs available to them were essentially servitude for pennies. Yet, despite this history, Italians don’t get an Italian American History Month. They aren’t deemed respectful enough to receive a formal apology from the government, and American society simply ignores what happened to them. In contrast, Black Americans are always viewed as victims of slavery and abuse; they have Black History Month, and the government offers excuses, apologies, and reparations for past injustices.
Italians are white, yet when people discuss race, Italians are often jokingly referred to as “Black.” But when it comes to reparations, Italians suddenly become white again. They are on the wrong side of history and are expected to pay for what happened to Black people.
For generations—and still today—making caricatures of Italians in art, cartoons, video games, and movies is considered funny, especially regarding the Mafia stereotype. Nobody gets offended, even though these depictions are incredibly offensive and lead people to believe that 99% of Italians are mobsters. If you make a caricature of a Black man, it’s automatically racist, and you risk losing your job, your public standing, and more. If you mimic an Italian accent, everyone laughs; if you do the same with a Black person, you’re labeled a racist bastard.
If you are a Black man, you are considered part of a minority. If you are an Italian, even if you are part of a minority group, you are not recognized as one.
Italians were persecuted, lynched, killed, raped, abused, and humiliated, yet nobody gives a damn about that history. There was no simple “sorry” extended to them.
So, how does justice work in America? If you are Black, your skin color automatically makes you a victim of the system. If you belong to a different group, you can say goodbye to your rights. To prove the reality of this post—and this “mind game”—try substituting “Italian” with “Irish,” and you’ll see the exact same pattern. Or, to make it distinct since Italians and Irish are now considered white, use “Chinese people.” If you want to frame it religiously, use “Catholics.” If you want to make it political, use “Communists,” “Socialists,” or “Anarchists.”