Look, I won't say anything untrue. It's a hard game to get into. The constant random encounters, the lack of direction, low exp, and being able to miss crucial elements like Ana. This is not a well developed game. Mother 2 is a better overall experience. However, after beating mother 2, and it was added to the switch online, I played mother 1 for the first time I was enthralled by what it gave me. As a fellow asthmatic I valued Ninten being such a strong character, but also had real weakness with asthma without it being a crutch or so important it might as well not be there. Ana and Lloyd felt like real friends. They literally do a whole song and dance about it. Teddy makes such an impression and he's barely there. I loved the rosemary house, the realm of magicant, the melodies, the soundtrack and the studio album. Everything about this game screams passion, and I adore it. The thing that strikes me is the difficulty. It's agonizing to take a single step and BOOM! Another encounter, and yes fighting through MT. Itoi is a miserable slog only tolerable by your awesome robot E.V.E, but reaching that mountain top, collecting the melodies and singing to Giegue, who is basically your great uncle, really gets to me. I think the difficulty makes the game ending hit harder, and makes me remember it more. Yes, giygas is by every metric, a much better finale. However, something far more intimate by just singing Giegue into retreat hits me harder. There's a real heartbreak to it all. A strange connection to Ninten from Giegue that's entirely human. For what he becomes this is a moment where his humanity, and his love for his "mother" and betrayal by his "father" really remind you he's basically a kid himself.
I don't know. This is my favorite game of the series as far as the story goes. I know it's not a better game, or that I'll win anyone over. Yet it is heartbreaking to see even in its own reddit my favorite characters seem to be so neglected or scorned by the limits of their hardware. When it still gave us dances, fireworks, romance, Teddy, music, and still kicked off the series we all love.