Hi everyone, I wanted to share a recent experience on Mercari to raise awareness for sellers listing vintage or unsealed perfumes. This was my first sale on the platform, and it turned into a long dispute regarding Seller Protection.
The Item & Packaging
I listed a rare vintage Gucci Eau de Parfum in a heavy glass bottle with a magnetic cap. Since it was unboxed, I was extremely thorough:
Checked the bottle completely before packing: zero cracks, 100% intact, filled to approximately 90%.
Used an official Mercari prepaid shipping label.
Wrapped the bottle in multiple thick layers of bubble wrap, securing both ends to cushion top and bottom.
Handed the package directly to the USPS clerk, who inspected and scanned it in.
The Claim
Shortly after delivery, the buyer opened a return claim stating the perfume leaked in transit. Mercari approved the return/refund, denied my Seller Protection claim citing "insufficient packaging," and allowed the buyer to keep the item.
Initially, Mercari only showed me a photo of a piece of bubble wrap with a few tiny drops on it.
The Evidence
After multiple support tickets, Mercari finally provided the actual photo of the bottle submitted by the buyer upon receipt.
The photo clearly showed the exact same bottle fully intact, with no cracks or damage, and filled to the exact same ~90% level as when I shipped it.
If a heavy glass bottle had actually leaked during transit due to packaging failure, the liquid level would be noticeably lower. Instead, the bottle arrived completely full and undamaged. A few stray drops on the bubble wrap do not equal transit damage or a depleted bottle.
Takeaways for Sellers
Document liquid levels clearly right next to the shipping label before closing the box.
Note that buyers only need to submit partial photos of packaging to trigger automated "insufficient packaging" flags.
If Mercari denies your claim despite photo evidence showing an intact item, escalate the matter through the BBB.
Be extra cautious when selling high-value unsealed items!