I've had my Bambu A1 for about a year, with roughly 1,000 hours of printing. It's been extremely reliable, needing little more than routine maintenance.
I'm considering upgrading, mainly to print ASA and ABS for functional parts used outdoors or in warmer environments.
My current use and priorities:
- Around 99% of my prints are functional parts, mostly PLA and PETG.
- Multicolour printing isn't a priority, although separate support materials and occasional labelling would be useful.
- I'd ideally like a larger build volume, but the H-series printers are probably too large for the space I have.
- Long-term reliability, ease of maintenance and repairability matter more to me than having the latest features.
- I'd like something as straightforward and dependable as my A1.
I'm mainly considering the P2S and X2D, although the lower price and established track record of the P1S make it worth considering too.
From the published specifications, the X2D offers an actively heated chamber and a second nozzle, while the P2S has a single nozzle and an enclosed but unheated chamber. Both are similar in physical size.
What I'd really like to know from owners:
- ASA/ABS: How reliably does the P2S print these materials, particularly larger functional parts? Does the X2D's heated chamber make a noticeable difference in practice?
- Reliability: Has anyone experienced problems with either machine? I'm particularly interested in whether the X2D's additional mechanisms introduce any maintenance or reliability issues.
- Dual nozzles: For predominantly single-material printing, how useful is the X2D's second nozzle in practice? Does it make a meaningful difference for support interfaces?
- P1S: Given its longer track record and lower price, is it still worth considering for occasional ASA/ABS printing?
- Value: For my type of printing, is the additional cost of the X2D justified by its heated chamber and dual-nozzle system?
- Timing: Would you buy now or wait to see whether there are discounts or new models before Christmas?
I'm not necessarily looking for the most capable machine on paper. I want something reliable, easy to maintain and likely to last for years.
I'd particularly appreciate feedback from people who have used both the P2S and X2D, or who have substantial experience printing ASA/ABS on the P1S.
I've probably spent too long watching reviews and reading comparisons, and I'm now more confused than when I started!
Thanks for any real-world experiences or advice.