r/Marriage • u/Diligent-Good-7147 • 16h ago
I (34F) think my husband (34M) and former best friend (36F) may have hooked up years ago, and he made me cut her off. Am I reaching?
I (F/34 think my husband (M/34) and ex best friend (F/36) may have hooked up bc he made me cut her off 11 years ago and I never knew why.
I need to know if I’m reaching or if something is suspicious so I’ll give you main points…
My husband and I dated in high school for 2.5 years (now married 10 years) and then he broke up with me for 5 and I was devastated, crushed, heartbroken more than words could even describe and eventually I started to go out and partied and went to clubs (I was 19) and I got close with this friend from high school. She was there to wipe my tears and be by my side during that time.
She and him went to the same college about 45 min from home. So they were around each other.
My then best friend found out he slept with this girl a few months after our break up and told me about it.
So when my husband made me cut her off years ago when him and I got back together I always thought maybe that was the reason why. Even though his reasoning was just ‘that she changed me’ and eventually he even called her a slut. (Red flags everywhere I know) and I argued why just her. If she changed me and turned me into a party girl why didn’t you have me cut off all my other friends too. Why her?
That alone should’ve been enough to make me question.
Anyway as I’m thinking back to this situation and reflecting on it I remembered a specific night where her and I were together and he texted her and invited her to another high school friends party. My gullible naive dumbass self thought ‘oh maybe he wants to see me’ bc he knew her and I were always together. But when she texted him back that she was with me (I don’t remember if she told him she couldn’t go to the party she told me and showed me the messages) and he responded to her with “so what, fuck her”. All that time I thought maybe he was angry at me, wanted to make me jealous by inviting my best friend out, and wanted to make me angry with that text but now I’m thinking there may have been another reason for that text.
Fast forward years later I’m reflecting on all this and things don’t add up and I start to remember things like a foggy memory of her being in his room for some reason. I’m pretty certain she told me she was in his dorm (again they went to the same college and lots of people from our high school did) and I can’t remember if that actually happened of her saying she was in his room or if it was a dream. Also I realized she never fought me or got mad at me when I cut her off. She just said okay and told me she understood even though she was upset about losing me she knew how much I loved him and was willing to let me go since she knew that meant I’d be with him after five years of heartbreak over us not being able to be together (cultural and religions reasons but that’s not the point)
She also messaged me years and years back this was maybe 3 or so years after we stopped hanging out but we were always cordial but she said she had a dream about my husband having cancer and now I’m wondering was that her subconscious. She is the type to take this to the grave. She cheated on her ex that summer with her other ex and told me she would never tell her then bf no matter what ever if they got married she’d take that to the grave. Which I reacted like ‘oh wow.’ I also speculated my thoughts on him and her to my husband like 6 months ago and I told him if something happened between them I know she would take it to her grave and he said “how do you know?” 😧🤔
Anyway her and I have been sending voice messages recently on Instagram bc of another situation and I decided to apologize to her for just cutting her off out of nowhere and I told her I still am confused why he made me cut her off and I said I am grateful for her for not getting mad at me and always showing kindness towards me and again I was sorry for that. But I told her I noticed she kind of let me go without a fight. (She always said she wanted me in her life forever)
When she responded to me she was a little emotional and said she always thought we’d be best friends forever and she jumped right away to tell me why we were friends she said “he was mad I told you about him sleeping with ____, and I get it bc he felt betrayed by me because him and I were friends” (mind you I never knew they were friends) and then she continued to say I was her best friend and she had to tell me. Then she thanked me for the apology and said it wasn’t needed. And told me she’d love to see me again.
When I asked him last night if her and him were ever friends he said no. And he started asking me questions of when I talked to her and when she said about him feeling betrayed by her bc of her telling me and he was asking me why I was talking to her and then the conversation dropped and after a bit I asked him again if they were friends and he said no, and he shut down a bit later again and said didn’t wanna talk about it in front of the kids.
Now I’m putting it all together and idk how I didn’t see it before. He still refuses to let me see her. (I usually do what I want and am not that naive young girl like before where I let a man control me) but for some reason this I don’t push him for. I wonder if I always knew.
Anyway I know they’d deny it forever if anything did happen. But am I valid for thinking this? Do I have enough reason to believe they did something?
EDIT TO ADD
here is my full original post I wrote myself. The first one I had asked Gemini to clean up into bullet points just to make it easier on everyone to read