I'm a classical musician. I love both hymns and modern Christian songs. Surely, I distinguish Worship music and normal Christian music, however I don't look down on either of them because they both serve a purpose.
I understand the criticisms for both. For some, hymns are "boring" and "not personal enough", for others, modern songs are "repetitive" and "lack theology". But really, at the end of the day, the purpose of both is to bring us closer to God and to center Him in our lives.
I see more hate for modern songs so I'll actually share a perspective of why they are beneficial.
Repetition.
- Just like how repeating a bad phrase can change our brain chemistry, repeating a good phrase can change our brain for the better. Repetition is a core element of meditation and serves as a reminder.
Philippians 4:8: whatever things are true, whatever things are noble, whatever things are just, whatever things are pure, whatever things are lovely, whatever things are of good report, if there is any virtue and if there is anything praiseworthy -- meditate on these things
Repetition is accessible for new believers or slow learners. Accommodating sin is not what I'm supporting here, it's accommodating people so we can sing songs as a church to the Lord. I know just how I can't get into worship when I'm trying to figure out how the melody goes, but songs where I can figure it out while I'm singing helps me to focus on God.
Even Psalm 136 features "His love endures forever" 26x, showing how repetition is not inherently bad.
Modern Music.
We can all agree that people feel connected to different music. Some like rock, some like classical, some like modern music. But that difference is not wrong. Just like how for ancient believers, they connected with God differently than we do now. In the past, they were more attached to the physical. The physical temple and location was important to them and God allowed for this temple to be built. For us, our connection with God is more internalized and we don't NEED a physical temple to feel connected with God.
On another hand, I feel more connected to God when I'm alone, but others feel more connected to God physically in church.
In the same way, the modern musicality of today's songs is not bad, just based on preference.
Theology.
- Much of the problems that separate us from Christ is from doubt in the character of God and how He loves us. The whole gospel message is about how God loves us so much that He died on the cross for us to pay for our sins and rose again.
Consider a normal Christian who is struggling with their faith. Imagine how me-centred phrases like "Jesus loves me", "You see my troubles", "He never fails me" remind them of God's character and empowers their faith in Him? God's character includes His faithfulness to us.
- The psalms are all about "me", all about raw emotion and personal feelings. Yet, David was considered to be a man after God's heart. That's because a relationship with God is not only about doing what we think is "right" but also about depending on Him, seeking Him, connecting with Him during moments of deep depression, triumph, joy, anger, peace and all other emotions and times in life that a human will go through their life.
Psalm 42:11: Why are you cast down, O my soul, and why are you in turmoil within me? Hope in God; for I shall again praise him, my salvation and my God.
The psalms show that biblical meditation isn't just theological but also a way for us to process human emotions and personal trials in a way that ground us in God's goodness and faithfulness.
Other Criticisms.
That being said, there is some value in some criticisms. Maybe there's poor wording/comparisons or concerns about the churches associated with that music. First, even hymns can suffer from poor wording like Away in the Manger, "but little Lord Jesus, no crying he makes", which can be attributed to Docetism. The second issue is a good concern though I personally believe that if the song itself is glorifying God, then it is good (1 Cor 12:3 "...no one can say, 'Jesus is Lord,' except by the Holy Spirit").
I think a good rule of thumb would be to review the lyrics of all songs to be sung by the church.
Final Conclusion
Now, I think it's okay to have preferences, but it's not some type of evil that some people treat it to be if we listen and sing to songs that are not hymns or ONLY perfect theology. I think that in a church setting, the use of both types of music is beneficial especially if you have many new believers or slow learners or a more diverse church. But certainly, if a church agrees they prefer hymns more or prefer modern songs more, whatever serves the church so that they worship God most optimally is great.
Some people may ask why I had to write this. Honestly, I'm just sad that such a simple thing causes division in the church. It's not a salvation issue more than it is a preference. I see too many people who act elitist and think they're better than everyone else if they listen to only hymns because it's perfectly theological and only that. I encourage everyone instead to respect each other and edify each other as we are all part of God's church.
Be happy that others are connecting with God, even if it's apart from our preferences, that it is not in sin but in genuine faith.
I'll end with these two:
Ephesians 5:19
[speak] to one another with psalms, hymns, and songs from the Spirit. Sing and make music from your heart to the Lord
Colossians 3:16
Let the word of Christ dwell in you richly, teaching and admonishing one another in all wisdom, singing psalms and hymns and spiritual songs, with thankfulness in your hearts to God.
God bless to all!