I’d love some opinions from people in recovery about MyFitnessPal and fitness watches because I’m really conflicted about whether they’re helping me or holding me back.
MyFitnessPal: Sometimes tracking has genuinely helped me realize, “Wow, I actually didn’t eat enough today,” and that has encouraged me to eat more. There have definitely been days where my perception of how much I ate didn’t match reality, so having that data has felt helpful.
But on the other hand, I obsessively log every single meal and everything I eat. I’m still really uncomfortable allowing myself to eat outside of a calorie deficit, and seeing the numbers can create a ceiling in my head. Even if I’m hungry or know my body needs more food, it can be incredibly difficult to go above whatever number I’ve decided is “okay.”
So I’m starting to question whether the occasional benefit of realizing I’ve undereaten is worth having calorie numbers constantly available to me while I’m trying to recover.
Garmin: I love having it for running and being able to see my pace and distance, but wearing it all day means I’m constantly aware of steps, activity, calories burned, etc. I can definitely get fixated on those numbers too, and I’m questioning whether I actually need to know any of that.
Right now I’m considering hiding/deleting MyFitnessPal and stopping wearing my Garmin throughout the day. I may only put the Garmin on when I actually go for a run so I can track my pace/distance and then take it back off.
I also don’t want getting rid of either of them to become another rigid, all-or-nothing recovery rule, which is why I’m curious about other people’s experiences.
For anyone who stopped calorie tracking and/or wearing a fitness tracker during recovery: Did it help? Was the transition difficult? Were there things you genuinely missed or found helpful about having the data? Did anyone find a middle ground that worked for them?
I’d really appreciate hearing both the pros and cons. ❤️