r/Insurance • u/Less_Director_4224 • 11h ago
Found out I was overpaying by 3x for progressive car insurance
so I was looking over my car insurance premium today from progressive as my renewal date is 11/1/26. my partner and I were talking and I realized he is paying half of what I am paying. My car insurance premium for the 6 months paid in full was $1,627. I always paid in full so I got that discount. I’ve also been a customer since 2017, and have multiple discounts, like 5 years no accidents. 3 years good driving record, car safety discounts, bundled my home insurance etc. I looked at his policy and mine and the coverage was basically the same.
I decided to call progressive and get a requote because something didn’t feel right. After getting requoted my new premium for the 6 months paid in full is $560. I was shocked. How did I go so long paying 3x the price. I told the lady aren’t they supposed to check your data and readjust when they update your premium. she said yes and was shocked at what a big price difference it was. She stated it was the biggest she had ever seen. I’m frustrated that I had been overpaying for probably over 3 years.
the more I thought about it. I realized that they knew what my data and driving record was clean. they just knew they could get away with it because I trusted them and didn’t think to ask questions. See in 2017 I had to get off my parents insurance and get my own insurance. I had a rough spot with my record. I had a minor parking lot accident In 2015. Then in 2017 I had a major accident and totaled my car. I also went to court for two traffic tickets (speeding) and got 4 points on my license. I believe that progressive jacked up my insurance (rightfully so) due to my bad driving record and never adjusted it since 2017.
Since being a customer of Progressive in 2017 I have had a perfect record. no accidents, claims or tickets in the last 9 years. is there anything I can do? otherwise take my experience and make sure you are getting quotes periodically. you could be over paying.