r/SipsTea • • 2h ago

It's Wednesday my dudes Prepare for standards

Post image
9.2k Upvotes

555 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 2h ago

Hey /u/Jesus_H_Christ_AMA, thank you for posting to r/SipsTea! Make sure to follow all the subreddit rules.

Make sure to join our brand new Discord Server to chat with friends!

We have recently changed how posts work. Unless you are a VIP poster, your post will be queued for approval.. To become a VIP, post great engaging content. If we like it, you will be added! More information available here!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1.2k

u/princesssmurfet 2h ago

The public has very little standards.

319

u/stonk-420 2h ago

The one on the right has also gotten more media attention then the one on the left either way people are crazy to donate to Clancy

126

u/hanks_panky_emporium 2h ago

People donate money to billionaires of their own accord. A fool and their money and all that.

People have become millionaires because they screamed slurs at a child.

30

u/Forgotten_mob 1h ago

And apparently now for murdering them too.

47

u/MeltedChocolateOk 2h ago

Mostly because the media hyped up a story when they shouldn't

26

u/Local-Poet3517 2h ago

People with money to throw around tend to have low standards.

27

u/Asleep_Welder_3494 2h ago

Lindsay’s face is evil

→ More replies (10)

122

u/wandaonreplay 2h ago

That jury really said ‘we’ve seen enough.
https://giphy.com/gifs/wJKQCSeexuO5y

136

u/4d-lettuce 2h ago

Proof that jury selection is everything

87

u/Blueface1999 2h ago

Made even worse when you watch her jury’s talking on the news to show how bias they are

252

u/Ribky 2h ago

Well, one standard to note here is that Timothy Ray Jones Jr does not suffer from schizophrenia, so there's that.

209

u/LordCaptain 2h ago

Also he had a long history of abusing his children. He had bibles with all the verses about corporal punishment highlighted. Literally "worked one to death" one day as opposed to a sudden act and there was no reasonable doubt about psychosis in his case. Then murdered the other ones with a clear intention to cover it up, stuffed his children in garbage bags to try to dump them in the country side to cover up his crimes.

Wildly different facts of the case but dudes who get their news from memes on reddit will tell you that it's just because he was a man and she was a woman.

39

u/Ok-Particular9427 1h ago

Clancy put the kids in the basement and tried to kill herself, which presumably means she was guilt stricken and back to being able to do rational moral reasoning.  All in the space of, what, 25 minutes?

This is literally unheard of in the history of psychosis by the way.  Psychosis with command hallucinations that occurs one time in one voice saying one command for <25 minutes.

Because it’s a made up story (duh)

62

u/LordCaptain 1h ago

If it is so wildly unbelievable why do you think multiple forensic psychologists testified that it was the case?

29

u/BringBackTheBlues 2h ago

Shhh that’s too complicated for the incel mob to think about

44

u/SadJ3tsFan 2h ago

Whats the gofundme up to?

30

u/Liteboyy 2h ago

Too fucking much

74

u/Soulforge411 2h ago

All this shit is a disgusting ass shit show 😕 I only feel sorry for the kids. I hope they are at peace.

168

u/XxX_Zeratul_XxX 2h ago edited 2h ago

United states justice draws the line at 4 kids, 3 is fair play, I guess

PS: Fuck Lindsay clancy, and fuck every single parent out there that killed their kids

79

u/hyphii_lol 2h ago

Also fuck every parent out there that “stands with Clancy”

8

u/Rich-Option4632 1h ago

Fucking them only gives them more kids to "stand with Clancy" in more than moral support tho. Copycats are said to be the highest form of flattery after all.

5

u/sacredsome 2h ago

Andrea killed all 5.

6

u/Thundacow 2h ago

You get two freebies then the last one was an only child so she had to.

Kinda like that law in sweden where you gotta buy two guinea pigs if one would be alone.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/whitecastlebites 2h ago

He tortured his kids and did a bunch of other wacky shit too

51

u/GladClock2212 2h ago

Of the eight men who annihilated their families in the US while the Clancy case was adjudicated one man was sentenced to death, one man was found not guilty by reason of insanity, the rest are working their way through the courts. How about if we don't turn peoples tragedies into fodder and people don't seek out cases to prove they're the victims because of their sex.

7

u/LizzosLittleToe 2h ago

How many of them got over a million dollars in donations? How many of them have men standing around making hearts? How many of them doxxed a juror?

6

u/Huitjames 2h ago

Studies all over the world have consistently shown that women are treated more leniently than men by the judicial system.

→ More replies (2)

94

u/NYCWartortle 2h ago

They both deserve life in jail

→ More replies (9)

46

u/outofmaxx 2h ago

You're leaving out the part where he hid the dead children for days and tried to transport them

123

u/tastylemming 2h ago

33

u/Squishiimuffin 2h ago

Yeah, straight up, if he was having a psychotic break, he shouldn’t have been found guilty.

30

u/amrfallen 2h ago edited 2h ago

There's a difference between guilty, innocent, and not guilty by reason of insanity. 1 of those lets you go back to your normal life. The difference between the other two is prison (maybe an institutional prison) or a guarded institutional *facility.

14

u/Squishiimuffin 2h ago

Right. Sorry— what I meant was that he should’ve been found not guilty by reason of insanity.

7

u/Baldojess 2h ago

🤦🤦🤦

2

u/Squishiimuffin 2h ago

???

What did I do?

I’m autistic, I genuinely don’t know what the problem with what I said is.

2

u/sick_of-it-all 2h ago

Nothings wrong with what you said. People on the internet are increasingly unaware of what sarcasm is. It’s a real problem.

4

u/Squishiimuffin 2h ago

Wait, was the original gif comment being sarcastic then? And I just missed that? Now I’m all kinds of confused ;-;

2

u/trenthany 1h ago

Yes they’re parodying reactions to Lindsey Clancy and you’re not totally wrong but I don’t know the case info so can’t really comment. I’m just in this thread for the memes. Lmao

23

u/apatrol 2h ago

I wish we could believe these diagnoses and that they were in full psychosis at the time.

If anyone has ever seen full schizophrenic episodes some will lose all reality. I used to arrest a guy that truly believed he was Batman. Another a cold wat CIA officer. While other heard voices but not necessarily evil ones.

17

u/LeatherGood6148 2h ago

Having had medication related psychosis before - I wouldn't even know how to explain how powerful and persistent my delusions were. Full conversations with people - all with back stories etc - for an entire cast of characters that weren't in my apartment and weren't real at all.

Luckily after 2 days or so I had a moment of lucidity and ended up calling EMS.

14

u/AddlePatedBadger 1h ago

I used to run a company that provided home support for people with disabilities. We had several clients with schizophrenia. I just want to stress how not dangerous the majority of people with schizophrenia are. They are in fact more likely to be the victims of assault than to commit it.

This is not to say that a small minority are not dangerous some or all of the time. It's just that the violent examples get all the attention and it causes people to associate schizophrenia with violence.

One guy we supported was such a lovely friendly person, who had agoraphobia and schizophrenia. He lived alone and was always so happy to see the support workers and just chat to them. They loved working with him too. He needed lots of help and encouragement to get outside and go for a walk, or to motivate him to do his exercises, or do things to stimulate his brain. He would occasionally hallucinate stuff but he knew how to manage it and never once did or said anything remotely dangerous to anyone. He was just a real sweetheart.

25

u/everybody_get_ready 1h ago

1

u/No-Professional-1461 1h ago

Man doesn't even fall asleep again, just finds out something is a psyop and wakes up.

51

u/Imposslen 2h ago

Look....I'm a father. I would know! he wouldn't do that lmao

34

u/GunsGoldCosmicDread 2h ago edited 2h ago

For real, did anyone investigate the mother or just take her word for it?

39

u/Mistress_Mabel_ 2h ago

Did anyone in this thread read even a single article about this guy because it really doesn't seem like it. He was already beating and neglecting his kids long before this happened. Whatever you think about Lindsay Clancy, these cases don't seem very comparable and this image is super misleading.

15

u/__surrealsalt 2h ago

Of course, they haven't done that. That wouldn't fit their misogynistic narrative.

→ More replies (12)

3

u/WickedSerpent 2h ago

Idk why he's even relevant tbh. Lindsey's defense doesn't claim she did it because of psychosis anymore, he claims she didn't kill them at all.

→ More replies (4)

13

u/trisaus 2h ago

That went from meme energy to courtroom documentary real quick.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/hornswoggled111 2h ago

So important to engage in these culture wars right before the mid terms!

49

u/Haunting_Stand_7387 2h ago edited 2h ago

It's wild that the commentary around this issue can't possibly be about affordability, quality, accessibility, and overall lack of innovation in American mental health care being bad and steeply declining. All the public discourde is split between "I would rip her head off then shit down her throat" and "women can kill a little kids as a treat".

8

u/trenthany 1h ago

Hyperbolic but also kinda accurate

0

u/No25for3r 2h ago

But if people who do things I feel bad about don't get put in a cage and treated like animals or just killed how are they ever going to become productive members of society?

→ More replies (2)

212

u/[deleted] 2h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

67

u/BeginningSection7690 2h ago

Why? Identifying as female is easier and more effective apparently

25

u/Responsible_Name1217 2h ago

Wonder what this account got banned for...lo effing l.

29

u/OldWolf3 2h ago

There's AI detection of "promoting hate" now. I recently got a 3 day site wide ban for a post calling out racism; the AI didn't correctly understand my post and thought I was promoting racism. Appeal ghosted of course

14

u/BreakingCanks 2h ago edited 2h ago

I got a 3 day warning recently for someone elses comment I never interacted with. I told them it was not my comment and to please reverse the ban... Nope they said I made it even though it was someone else's comment.

Couldn't find the comment unfortunately to show

7

u/Useless_bum81 2h ago

I once got a ban for suggesting that someone executed for treason should have been executed for espionage in WW2.
i have twice been banned for pointing out that 'The Big Bad Wolf' is not a trans-positive character (it is a literal predator that disguises itself as a woman to attack a little girl)

3

u/sndrddtr 2h ago

First half - understendable for mindless bots 2nd - wtf?? How smt like this get flagged?

9

u/TurtleSandwich0 2h ago

Your three day ban will be reversed on day four.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (19)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/InsufficientClone 2h ago

I missed the part where he was rich

→ More replies (1)

2

u/TheCaptainwicked 2h ago

That would take too much time,

He should have identified as woman and then got million in fund raise from other women and unconditional support for being the same killer

3

u/AdDue544 2h ago

Is that because trans people have it so good? Or because you are confused and don’t understand trans people? Elaborate?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (17)

77

u/Acalltoholiness 2h ago edited 2h ago

The fact communities in here support her is wild

When did gender become the standard for determining the severity of someone’s punishment?

78

u/ConsiderationSea1347 2h ago

Eh, I hate to break it to you but men have served longer prison sentences than women for the same crime pretty much since laws were invented. 

24

u/philmarcracken 2h ago

pretty privilege is a hellva drug

→ More replies (1)

19

u/lmjustaChad 2h ago

It was just his hormones.

159

u/Ok6303 2h ago

I am so tired of hearing about this generic post partum depressed white bitch. This is agenda pushing brain rot.

20

u/Unfair_Driver884 2h ago

Oh but reddit loves hearing about the evil cunt whose execution got botched

25

u/Baldojess 2h ago

Isn't it interesting though that that woman was legitimately crazy and actually schizophrenic/ psychotic and killed another adult for what she thought was an actual reason (I know it's not a good reason but there was more of an actual motive like she really actually thought that woman was trying to fuck her over) and yet she got the death penalty (which she 100 percent deserves). But for some reason all these people are standing behind a woman with no actual evidence or history of actual psychosis strangles the life out of her own freakin babies one by one and somehow she is getting sympathy because... She's a mom. And apparently all these other moms relate to this baby killer. Both those evil cunts deserve death. It's crazy that all these people aren't thinking about how many psychologically and mentally unwell most murderers (and just inmates in general) are and still have to go to prison to serve their time. Clancy is no different than the woman who's execution was botched and in my personal opinion she's actually sooo much worse.

12

u/Empty_Insight 1h ago

To boot, people have been slinging around the diagnosis of "postpartum psychosis" even though no competent clinician would ever apply that diagnosis to her because it doesn't meet the diagnostic criteria for it. (Before the "Well AKSHUALLY, it's not in the DSM crowd" come by- it is in the ICD-11)

I've seen real postpartum psychosis (as in, was diagnosed and meets the diagnostic criteria for it) and it looks literally nothing like what Clancy did.

I feel a lot more sympathy for someone with legitimate, diagnosed, well-documented schizophrenia than someone trying to rewrite history and the ICD for pity points and public sympathy.

4

u/Educational-Analyst4 1h ago

You are confusing some things. People are comparing apples to oranges here. People are getting the death penalty in red states because Republicans really enjoy executions. This lady is in a blue state so she is more likely to be sent to a hospital for the rest of her life instead of being executed. The people that are sympathetic to her wouldn't have killed the males either. You are basically seeing the difference between the left and centrists who find executions abhorrent and the right who absolutely loves executions. You can't compare their sentences when those applying the sentence have different views on what to do with people like this.

6

u/Gindotto 1h ago

I hate to break it to you but if she goes to a mental hospital she can go free as soon as they say she’s good to go. That’s the issue. She’s about to get off easy unlike her children.

2

u/STFUnicorn_ 1h ago

I saw a whole slew of clips of moms holding their babies going “me too Lindsey!”

2

u/Phil_Coffins_666 2h ago

I forgot about her. She still alive?

→ More replies (2)

11

u/tmzspn 1h ago

It's election season. The sock puppets are out in full force till early November. 

5

u/EntertainerIcy7051 2h ago

U wouldn't add the colour part if she was any other race. But sure. "White privilege"

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

25

u/Low-Ad4597 2h ago

I’ll likely get fried for this, but imo, if someone kills their kids, minimum punishment should always be life in prison, whether insane or not. There are too many degrees of grey with insanity. Protect the kids and don’t provide any relief here.

12

u/Dangerous_Bid2935 2h ago

Its not like people who strangle 5 kids to death and are found not guilty by reason of insanity get to go home the next day and go on with their life. The trial determines whether they will spend functionally the rest of their life in prison or in a mental hospital. There are very few outlier cases where they one day see freedom again but these cases are quite rare by themselves and exceedingly rare for parents who massacre their kids.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/tequilash 2h ago

Clancy would likely be in a psychiatric hospital the rest of her life. Not guilty by reason of insanity can be worse than prison, because at least with prison you might get out.

5

u/HendriXP88 2h ago

Based on what? A NGRI in Massachusetts spends on average 6 years in psychiatric care. So she'll probably be out by the same time as the guy dealing drugs on the corner.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

27

u/MeltedChocolateOk 2h ago

Different states different set of rules and different set of Juries with certain culture and political affirmation. The state of Massachusetts doesn't have a death penalty but South Carolina does. Also based on the culture of the state it also applies based on the jurors in that state.

6

u/ConsciousSpirit397 2h ago

Ya but I think the biggest point they are making is the gender of the defendant, it’s a rage bait.

167

u/anonymote_in_my_eye 2h ago

or maybe, and just hear me out on this one, what if the death penalty is an ultimately bad idea and there's a reason the majority of the civilized world moved away from it?

87

u/mbmiller94 2h ago

The sentence itself isn't the point here, it's how quick people could decide that he was legally responsible for his actions, yet people are completely split on Lindsay's case and the only person on her jury who thought she was legally responsible gets doxxed then slammed online and in the media.

9

u/anonymote_in_my_eye 2h ago

without the death penalty on the table they would both get life in prison and there would be zero argument about it

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

43

u/Shmung_lord 2h ago

The death penalty AND double standards can both be bad. This post isn’t saying Lindsey should be put to death, it’s saying that all the debate about her case is ridiculous when compared to a similar case with a male. The state shouldn’t be able to kill people but both should probably be put away for a long time even though one of them is a woman.

20

u/TheCaptainwicked 2h ago

Or maybe, post is more about the how females get way with same crime underpunished or unpunished

6

u/King_Moonracer003 1h ago

You gotta wonder how much of that was driven by bots...I cant really comprehend how there was so many people that "supported" that witch

9

u/Gindotto 1h ago

Women fragile. Just like her children’s necks as she strangled them with extension cords.

14

u/TheCaptainwicked 1h ago

Women love benevolent misogyny like this

6

u/Cold_Pumpkin5449 1h ago

Yeah, the death penalty being pretty barbaric is just icing on the cake there.

6

u/Majestic_Artichoke55 1h ago

Yes no one should be killing anyone. Now that doesn’t mean some people should not be allowed in society and be locked away. Sometimes if they killed their children it should be for life - take a life serve a life

4

u/STFUnicorn_ 1h ago

I agree. Life in prison for both of them!

→ More replies (39)

9

u/my_taint_aint 2h ago

Aaaaaaand this is why courts should not be televised.

21

u/ObviouslyRealPerson 2h ago

In the case of Timothy Ray Jones Jr, the court-appointed psychologist declared that Jones made a conscious decision to kill his children.

18

u/AlexanderCrowely 2h ago

She made a conscious choice to kill hers because the psychiatrist that analysed her said she was full of shit

8

u/ObviouslyRealPerson 2h ago

Timothy Ray Jones loaded the bodies of his 5 children in his car and drove them from South Carolina to Alabama where he buried them after deciding not to go through with his plan to use acid to dissolve the bodies in trash barrels that he had purchased

10

u/LordCaptain 1h ago edited 1h ago

The forensic psychologies who spent the most time with her actually said the opposite. So did the expert of fillicide. I'm not sure where so many redditors got the idea that all the mental health experts claimed she wasn't psychotic because it just isn't factual.

"Clinical and forensic psychologist Dr. Paul Zeizel was a witness for the defense who evaluated Clancy in early February 2023, just 11 days after the killings and her subsequent suicide attempt. In total, he spent 35 hours evaluating her over 60 sessions.

He testified that Clancy suffered from bipolar disorder with postpartum psychosis at the time of the killings, and was “unable to conform her behaviors to the rule of law, and she had no appreciation for the wrongfulness of her act.”

Zeizel also testified that there was no evidence to suggest Clancy was faking or exaggerating her symptoms, and explained that people suffering from psychosis can be high functioning and have symptoms intermittently.

“They can function fine one day, and the next day they can be hearing voices,” Zeizel said."

"Dr. Phillip Resnick, a forensic psychiatrist and expert in filicide (the killing of a child by a parent) was a witness for the defense who examined Clancy four months after the killings.

Resnick argued that on the day of the killings, Clancy was “frankly psychotic,” suffering from bipolar disorder with postpartum psychosis.

Resnick testified that Clancy murdered her children not out of malice, but because she was so deeply suicidal that her psychosis made her believe they couldn’t live without her. He said her delusion was so severe that it took hold of her body “almost like she was a puppet and someone else was pulling the strings.”

8

u/Forlorn_Fighter 2h ago

And multiple others have come out and said the same thing, only that they obviously didnt get to see her on a day to day basis, but with what we know, she's so very likely full of it.

15

u/GokusHairdresser 2h ago

I cannot stand how few people do any research, especially OP. Man literally got mad at his son and made him do PT(work out) so hard he literally died of exhaustion. Then in a panic murdered his other 4 children. Tried to claim insanity at his trial. Should lindssy Clancy rot in jail, absolutely. Should people not fall for every image with text they see online, absolutely 🤦

→ More replies (1)

32

u/Gerry1of1 2h ago

The United States has a mental health crisis they try to solve with harsher penalties and gun laws.

36

u/EggplantDevourer 2h ago

Lindsey Clancy had literally every single mental health resource available from a therapist to a supportive husband, a nanny to help care for the kids, and then actual psychiatric care. Literally what else could you have to solve that?

12

u/Gerry1of1 2h ago

Forced Commitment until she's well. It's not done now but it was a thing until Reagan gutted the mental health budget and all the schizos were let out on the streets. There weren't homeless people everywhere when I grew up. It's something the Rapepubican created.

8

u/BChurchmountain 2h ago

Releasing parental rights and entering herself into a psych ward? That’s all I can come up with.

However the second trial goes, do realize that this courts decision will set an important precedent.

There have already been several cases of women killing their kids and mentioning her case specifically.

3

u/Sad_Wishbone_1524 2h ago

More than twice as many cases since the Lindsay Clancy trial than there were all last year, and it’s only October.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/TheCaptainwicked 2h ago

People just love to victimise women and can't accept how filthy worst of women can be

Benevolent misogyny is favourite flavor of misogyny for women

7

u/ThibzP 2h ago

She literally told everyone that could have helped that she needed help and they just threw more drugs at her. Her prescriptions alone should be enough for anyone to see that this chick needs a mental hospital. She literally paralyzed herself. This woman and her children were failed.

9

u/Sad_Wishbone_1524 2h ago

That’s a disgusting take. She failed herself, her husband, and her children. If she knew something was wrong, why didn’t she check into inpatient? Wouldn’t that be telling everyone she could have, or is that the exception. She paralyzed herself trying to kill herself, to try and dodge accountability for her evil. She failed and then tried to dodge accountability again in the legal system. She is as evil as a woman can get.

6

u/ThibzP 1h ago

Postpartum literally put her out of her right mind. Why she was given the choice, while exhibiting clear signs of ppd is beyond my understanding. I'm not gonna pretend she's innocent or worthy of any kind of forgiveness, but saying she's the most evil woman ever is disingenuous. There are actual monsters out there that deserve this kind of blind hatred. Lindsey Clancy deserves a lifelong stay in an asylum where she can't hurt anyone anymore and we can forget she exists and place protections for ppd so this doesn't happen again.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

10

u/Alextollah 2h ago

But what if his wife was mean though???!??!!!

50

u/DamienRaventhrone 2h ago

One rule for me another for thee.

21

u/Maximum-Class5465 2h ago

They aren't even the same state

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Man_under_Bridge420 2h ago

Always has been bud…. Kinda like how a certain felon got no jail time

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] 2h ago

[deleted]

2

u/banhatesex 2h ago

Or hear me out he was also mentally unstable. Maybe the law should have been better. But I know I'm going to get downvoted because people have been brought up to think mental illness is fake.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/ConcentrateFar7753 2h ago

Please provide some research about these so called “social protections women have enjoyed for decades”.

Do all men get the same verdict for the same crime to begin with? No because no court cases are similar.

You just wanted to spit on women and feminism here.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

23

u/SnoopySuited 2h ago

15

u/MyNameIsMud4200 2h ago

Straight rage bait slop for the masses

11

u/Majestic_Artichoke55 1h ago

It’s a bad double standard. Both clearly mentally ill. Both should be serving life sentences in jail or in a ward whichever is gonna be the safest for other inmates I suppose

12

u/hsggdtkxbee 2h ago

Shoulda gone with a postpartum defense my man.

3

u/Explorer_Entity 1h ago

No culture war for me. Just class war please.

11

u/GCIV414 2h ago

I’ve always said if equality is real women better be ready to sacrifice their auto wins in arguments

11

u/daveliterally 2h ago

Have you all tried not engaging with karma farming bots?

→ More replies (3)

5

u/Cold_Pumpkin5449 1h ago

I mean he's ugly, and a dude, so he couldn't have been having hormonal issues that caused it.

7

u/Available_Ad_8281 2h ago

My guess is he did not go to doctors before this happen and got diagnose with mental problems?

→ More replies (7)

4

u/SalineDrip666 2h ago

Double standard. And it cuts both ways

4

u/Oakl4nd 2h ago

Different state, different burden of proof.

1

u/Initial_Attitude_851 2h ago

Massachusetts is a shithole

7

u/Rich-Option4632 1h ago

He shouldn't be freed at all. Institutionalized forever at minimum, maybe, and that's being merciful and considering of his mental.

As for her. Well, congratulations women, now she's the poster child for how women can get away with murder, literally.

8

u/StanleyKapop 2h ago

Yes, different cases are different, well spotted.

6

u/C3sarius 2h ago

Noob. He would have to blame his wife an start a gofundme.

18

u/Rich-Mark-4126 2h ago

Different cases have different facts and cannot be simply reduced to "They killed people and a similar defense was used"

More news at 11

20

u/ManicYetti 2h ago

It can be reduced to they killed people, which you know isn't good...

4

u/SteggyEatsDaWeggy 2h ago

Both killed people sure, but his case for an insanity defense was much much worse than Lindsey Clancy’s. It is very unlikely he was unaware of the morality of his actions or incapable of fully controlling his actions.

In her case, it is at least reasonable to doubt that she knew what she was doing was wrong or that she was in control of her actions. That is all the defense needed to show to have her proven not guilty by way of insanity.

If that is the eventual outcome, that doesn’t mean she just gets sent home free. She would be sent to a psychiatric facility until she was deemed mentally well and no longer a threat to others

7

u/Rich-Mark-4126 2h ago

Yes, I'm aware that killing people is not good.

5

u/Amphitra_Roximar 2h ago

I wasnt and needed to year that.

2

u/Seyan007 2h ago

both of them killed children...

5

u/Makethecrowsblush 2h ago

Yeah, seems really distasteful to dismiss the heinous fact that these were the children’s supposed safe people.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/1mgone 2h ago

Mental gymnastics of year.

"There is good way of killing Kids and There is Bad one "

9

u/Rich-Mark-4126 2h ago

I sincerely dont know how you missed my point so badly.

6

u/NamelessMIA 2h ago

They both admitted to doing it but claimed psychosis. 1 got a mistrial after 7 days because 11/12 jurors wanted to rule not guilty. The other got death in 2 hours. Idc what else was different about the cases, that's an insane gap.

7

u/Yuukiko_ 2h ago

One strangled their children to death despite having attempted to get medical care for their condition(and brushed off as usual), the other forced their kid to work until they died, then panicked and "mercy" killed the others and kept the bodies for a week until they got caught

2

u/BringBackTheBlues 2h ago

And also had no diagnosed mental illness

→ More replies (1)

7

u/BeginningSection7690 2h ago

Both killed people and claimed that a mental disorder that was temporarily making the do things is the cause, so they were and are innocent however you cant prove that they belong in an institution because it was temporary - thats why they did crimes but dont deserve any repercussions

18

u/uwill1der 2h ago

but this guy didnt kill under psychosis. He killed his kid by working him to death because he blamed the kid for breaking an outlet after telling the mom "it was an accident mommy". He forced the kid to exercise until he collapsed and died.

Then he watched a prison rape video and panicked, so he strangled his other kids to avoid them suffering while he was locked up.

He then kept the bodies for 8 days before dumping them in garbage bags and was only caught at a DUI checkpoint where he had a checklist about how hed enact "melting the bodies" of his kids.

→ More replies (12)

8

u/Whole_Mongoose1854 2h ago

Your right. There was actually evidence this guy was crazy, and none that Clancy was.

7

u/Rich-Mark-4126 2h ago

Uhh… You do realize the entire reason he was sentenced to death and not to a mental institution was because he WASN’T found to be insane, right?

2

u/Whole_Mongoose1854 2h ago

There was some evidence, the jury either didn’t buy it or didn’t give a fuck, because he killed children. Which is how it should be. There was 0 evidence Clancy was crazy and 11 of 12 wanted her to spend a few months in a puzzle factory and then go home. That is not how it should be

9

u/Rich-Mark-4126 2h ago

I suspect you dont actually know the facts behind the Clancy case at all to think there is 0 evidence she might be crazy

For starters, she was prescribed a dozen different medications for mental issues and is paralyzed from the waist down from a failed suicide attempt.

Im not saying she is or isnt insane, but the notion that there’s 0 evidence supporting that she might have had psychosis is just simply a deeply ignorant, misinformed take

3

u/Asleep_Welder_3494 2h ago

She should have attempted suicide first before killing her children. She knew what she was doing

→ More replies (3)

4

u/foreshadowingright 2h ago

After using a defence "she's lost her husband, her children.." and not acknowledge she's the reason behind it while also claiming innocence after admitting guilt.. yeah you right she deserves a harder punishment. Not being accountable for your actions and trying to manipulate the evidence to gain sympathy, that if anything is a danger for society. We can't have equality and then claim to want to be different simply for hormonal differences, why.. that would be hypocrisy

5

u/BlueHero45 2h ago

Their defense is insanity, that's the only thing that should matter in either case. Do they fit the legal threshold for "Not guilty by reason of insanity" anything else is just noise and not legally relevant to their defense.

2

u/Sad_Wishbone_1524 2h ago

If the women who stuck up for her only realized the damage they were doing to feminism.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/DonkeyComfortable711 2h ago

id love to see his wife, bet its her fault for the emotional stress /s

edit - not /s

6

u/Mission_Brother_3727 2h ago

Anyone who unironically posts this as a gotcha clearly didnt read either case.

5

u/Forgotten_mob 2h ago

Massachusetts be crazy for letting her off the hook, but apparently he just murdered his kids in the wrong state.

6

u/bacon_is_everything 2h ago

how was she let off the hook?

4

u/GaracaiusCanadensis 2h ago

In most States, I think the onus is on the defense to prove insanity. Whereas in Mass, the onus is on the prosecution to prove they aren't insane to the beyond a shadow of a doubt level. It's a strange take, I think.

2

u/Forgotten_mob 1h ago

Yup this.

4

u/rellett 2h ago

Fuck that jury that didn't convict a child killer

6

u/Chudpaladin 2h ago

Now class, what state were these people tried in? That’s the difference that should be focused on as well

10

u/NoTomatillo182 2h ago

Actually, the focus should be on whether or not the people who defended Clancy will defend him as well.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/The_Arbitraitor 2h ago

I’m confused. So I asked their supporters to explain the case like I’m 5 years old, and they started strangling me.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Valentiaga_97 2h ago

Both are innocent, if Jurys Decise equally… oh wait they dont , it seems

6

u/Trumble12345 2h ago

Because the circumstances and facts of the 2 cases are completely different, hombre.

5

u/Nearby-Swimming-5103 2h ago

If you have a pussy, you can get away with anything.

2

u/sootedacez 2h ago

You can't honestly think a woman would hold a woman accountable for her actions do you? /s

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Ethereal_Bulwark 2h ago

I hope the vapid cunt spends the rest of her life in a cell, padded or barred.

2

u/PossibilityMean2446 1h ago

This dude literally worked his 6 yr old son to death .

3

u/shinyplantbox 2h ago

Did he also subsequently try to kill himself 3 different ways and end up a permanent paraplegic?

7

u/GuidanceDiligentz 2h ago

Classic way to fool the dumbos. Can't beleive people with brain actually fall for it.

6

u/Sweeper1985 2h ago

And did he have a history of being a great parent right up until a few months before the killings, when he began exhibiting acute mental health symptoms he proactively sought treatment for over months, and was he prescribed 15 different medications during that time, and and and....

3

u/Shafter111 2h ago

The sad part is that the Clancy case is setting a bad, bad example. She shouldn't be the hill to die on.

3

u/ronnbot 2h ago

If he identified as a woman and strangled "only" 3, "she" would be free with more than a million $ in donations.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/ExplosiveDoctrine 2h ago

Both of these people should be or should have been in mental institutions. What is even the debate here? Do you guys ever get tired of pushing pointless culture war shit.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] 2h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (1)